Sylas & Maddy's Homemade Ice Cream

This Icecream is amazing, great, wonderful, inspiring, classic, groundbreaking, innovative, and everything in between. The service is fast and they get your right on the serving size if you know what I mean It's also a super nice place to sit in and eat since it is much bigger than your average icecream place. Good for a date night as well, or a family outing. The vibes were great.

I see it's been almost ten years since I last reviewed Sylas and Maddy's; with as much of my money as this place now has, I feel it's time to drop them an update to cover this decade!Surprise - IT'S STILL AMAZING!! Since my first review, they've expanded the size of this location and remodeled the interior to allow MORE Olathians (Olathites? Olathenese?) to enjoy some of the best flavors of ice cream in the Kansas City metro!There are more flavors than Baskin Robbins, more ways to enjoy them than DQ, and a local flair that can't be beat! I have more favorite flavors than I have fingers to count them on!Our family took advantage of a couple new things (or new for us, at least) this year - we signed up for Ice Cream Pies in November (5-star!), and Ice Cream Advent Calendars in December (a million stars!)!! The latter, in particular, was so much fun for our ice cream-obsessed family! Scratching off a new flavor for 12 days in December added a little magic to my favorite month of the year!The staff is always helpful, the samples are always free, and the flavors are always BURSTING with amazing, sweet treats!I meant what I said about this place having too much of my money - if it were a public company, I'm pretty sure I'd be a majority owner now!

Silas and Maddie's Homemade Ice Cream is a local gem, offering some of the best handcrafted ice cream in town. The shop has a charming, nostalgic feel, with a small-town vibe that makes you feel welcome as soon as you step inside. It's a family-friendly spot, perfect for a casual treat after dinner or a weekend outing.The star here, of course, is the ice cream. Silas and Maddie's is known for its rich, creamy texture and an ever-changing selection of inventive flavors. You can find everything from classic vanilla and chocolate to more creative options. Their rotating menu keeps things fresh, encouraging repeat visits to try new flavors.Each scoop is generous, and the flavors are well-balanced without being overly sweet. The homemade waffle cones add an extra layer of deliciousness, and they often offer fun toppings to elevate your treat even more.The staff is always friendly and patient, even when there's a line, which can happen during peak hours since it's a popular spot. Prices are fair for the quality and portion sizes, making it a great value for homemade ice cream.Overall, Silas and Maddie's is a must-visit for ice cream lovers. The quality, variety, and welcoming atmosphere

I was craving ice cream so I went here after work, and this definitely satisfied the craving! I went here last October so lots of fall flavors. I was able to sample flavors, which is always very appreciated, and went with pumpkin chocolate chip and apple pie. Both very fall and both went well together. Pumpkin flavor was perfect, not too heavy on the spice, with nice bites of chocolate chips, and the apple pie had some nice cinnamon flavors, pie crust, and a few apple bits. Perfect sweetness and no complaints on texture. Service was good and interior was clean, there's also a cool mural about the history of ice cream. A great American ice cream place! As soon as I finish my cut, I'm coming back.

Y'all - you gotta check out Sylas & Mattie's ice cream!! There was a line when we arrived but it was fairly quick. The staff allowed me to try different ice cream options and all of them were extremely good. We actually got two pints to go as well because the ice cream was very good. They also offer options where you can take home multiple different scoops of ice cream options. I'd call it a flight of ice cream! This place is neat, clean and fun for all ages! I had the batter ice cream and it was yummy!!!

I haven't been here in ages: they used to do mix-ins on a cold slab of marble--in talking with Wes, at least since 2016, if calculations are correct and probably a lot longer ago than that. Plenty of seating the time I went --around 4 on a Tuesday. It was so nice outside, my friend and I took advantage of the weather and their outdoor dining.Wes was a great ice cream clerk. We were able to sample a few flavors--I opted for the Mahomes Magic.The downside to this experience was that although they have names of flavors on their wall, there's no detailed description to make an informed choice unless you ask what's in each, which leads to expending more time trying to make a decision and could ultimately be a problem for those who have allergies. (Hopefully the patron would ask anyway...) Parking and entrance exit is sometimes a hassle, but not a complete deal breaker.I'd most definitely go again.

We had really tasty ice cream here the other night. One big perk is that they have a pretty large seating area, separated from the ice cream counter, so it's good for larger crowds or kids and families. The only downside is that the portions are wildly inconsistent. It's not too easy to tell because of figure-ground distortion, but in my pic, both of these cups are mediums. My partner's further away from me, the photographer, is easily 3-4 oz more than the cup I had (that is effectively a whole scoop by volume!). Just something to think about, regarding their standardization of amounts!

We LOVE Sylas and Maddy's.If we want to celebrate a special occasion? We go to Sylas & Maddy's.When we want to showcase something in our city for out of town guests? We go to Sylas & Maddy's.We want to support local business? We go to Sylas & Maddy's!!The smell alone when you walk in will overwhelm your senses with dopamine. LOL. Their flavors are so rich and pure and amazing. The service is typically pretty good too! They have so many original flavors, there is something for everyone - including quite a few sorbets!But the best flavor you ask???? Hands down - peanut butter freak!!

I'm from Los Angeles and I don't think I've EVER had better ice cream at such a great price. They have a ton of flavors to choose from. The line gets long but the kids working move through the line quickly without making you feel rushed or guilted for wanting to try different flavors. Besides, there's a sort of magic to waiting in line for ice cream at sunset after a long, happy summer day.I noticed a lot of the people working seemed like high schoolers but they were all so friendly and welcoming! However, the shining star was Megan, a trainee. She was so warm and down to earth; I know it's a summer job, but I can tell she has a bright future ahead of her. Btw, I couldn't get enough of the Mahomes Magic flavor--we got it two days in a row!

Large serving and great ice cream. Friendly helpful servers. The only problem is it is always busy.