Square Pizza

We were near Independence Square and stopped at Square Pizza for a late lunch. It was warmer and more humid inside than expected on a hot summer day. The a/c definitely needed to be adjusted. The menu had a lot of good options and we settled on cheese bread, a small Chicken Alfredo pizza, a small Square House Supreme, and a pepperoni calzone. The cheese bread was quite good, but the accompanying marinara needed some seasoning. The pizzas overall were fine. I liked the crust and they definitely were not skimpy on the cheese. On the Alfredo, the sauce lacked punch and the cubed chicken similarly didn't have much flavor. The Supreme had fresh toppings, but again the sauce was just okay. Full disclosure, I am the only one in our group who had this opinion. My daughter who ordered the calzone really enjoyed it. My husband and another daughter really liked the pizza and would definitely go back. But I am a sauce enthusiast and was underwhelmed. Service was...mostly quiet. The guy who brought the cheese bread to our table was polite. The guy who brought the pizzas was mute. We were kind of amused by his stony silence. My daughter swears she heard the faintest "You're welcome" after she thanked him but I think she imagined it. Hey, not everyone is a people person.

Great tasting pizza, one of the best in town! The staff was quick and friendly and washed down nicely with one of the local made Polly Pop, which they sell cold in house.

Always my favorite. They have gluten free pizza, I don't have a gluten allergy but it helps keep my blood sugars lower. But even the regular pizza crust doesn't raise my blood sugar as I'm a Type 1 Diabetic. The toppings, atmosphere, and people are all wonderful as well. Love it!

I visited Square Pizza recently and the pizza was pretty good. The restaurant is extremely clean and the staff were pleasant and very helpful. This restaurant is in an excellent location near Independence Square.

Best pizza ever nice and thick lots of toppings a lrg will feed a family it's so big my adult kids really enjoy picking up for family events

This place has pretty good pizza, but to me it seemed way overpriced. A couple of years ago I went in with a group of friends and we bought a Hawaiian pizza to share. My cost, although I only had one slice, was $8!Then, about a year later, a ordered a small gluten-free pizza with mushrooms and anchovies for carryout, and my cost was over $26! It was very tiny, too. Way too tiny to justify that price.I see now that you can order online, and their menu adds $5.00 to the small price for a 10" gluten-free crust. But their prices are still really high, even for non-gluten. Their small Supreme is $12.99, and their large Supreme is $20.99. That's a lot to ask for a pizza whose only special feature is that it's baked in a square pan. Like most places located on Independence Square, the Web menu says this one is only open from 11:30-8:00 Tues-Sun. However, they now offer chicken wings at 10 for $9.59, corn nuggets for $4.59, and cheese curds for $3.99. They also offer calzones and salads, along with a couple of the usual bread-based desserts.It'll probably take something special to bring me back, though, although I might consider it based on the corn nuggets and the cheese curds.

Really high quality pizza and nice guys running it. I got the cauliflower crust and Greek salad. I also loved the local old-fashioned soda. Thank you!

If you like pizza (which I certainly do), but you want to try something just a little different; then I recommend you try this place. Not only do they have options you can't find elsewhere but also there is just something different about the way they cook them in those square pans.

Pizza is my favorite and we have it quite often. First time trying the Square Pizza and will definitely go again. We ordered the Buffalo Chicken and it was delicious! Ingredients tasted fresh. Love the soft crust, it has a very good flavor. And I like that it's a little different than the rest of the Pizza places around.

We are visiting from Oregon for 6 months and we have eaten here 3 times already. Friendly staff, great accommodations and really good pizza. The crust is just the way I like it. A good crust but chewy and holds up to the toppings with good flavor.