Jesse James Pizza
Lemon pepper and bbq wings..
pizza, food
Mafia's All Meat Pizza
Pepperoni XL
Cheesy Breadsticks
Honey Hot Wings
Extra large pepperoni pizza
Cheese sticks
The Boss
Calzone
pizza, food
Interior
menu
Exterior
Lemon Pepper Wings, Buffalo Wings, Pepperoni & Beef Pizza
Calzone - Yes... a small pizza folded in half.
Special build your own ... you name it we make it
Other side of the menu
outside
interior
food, pizza
Peek of the menu
One slice left of Buffalo chicken and yummy pepperoni!
Kendra M.
Nov 26, 2024
Their all meat pizza is fire and with no pork! The wings are good as well. Never had a bad experience there.
Read MoreCrystal B.
Jun 23, 2024
I only ordered wings for delivery. They were so hot and fresh and good! I will have to try their pizza next.
Read MoreStacy S.
Aug 20, 2024
My fave pizza spot in South KC. The pies are always good. Great price, nice staff. Always convenient when I place an online order in advance.
Read MoreSteve P.
Nov 10, 2024
Came on a whim for a late Saturday night take out. Man it was good. Got a sausage and pepperoni and another BBQ chicken. Top notch. They do not have dining in. Only take out. Would get this again for sure.
Read MoreKalana M.
May 29, 2024
really good pizza sauce!! cant say its the best pizza in town because i haven't tried every pizza spot in town but, it is definitely up there with that red sauce they make! no place to sit inside but i took it to the lake not far from there so it was a win win.
Read MoreRafraf B.
Sep 28, 2024
Our original review was going to be a great one. It was our first time trying this place the initial pizza we got was delicious and for a small hole in the wall this was excellent. Then we went to call to order a second time and they didn't even pick up the phone even though it was 40 minutes before closing time. I mean I understand too a certain point but sometimes you can't control when you can order if you just got off work yourself. Either way definitely worth a try it's a good place.
Read MoreAngelis L.
Apr 13, 2024
It is a pickup only do the building is rather utilitarian with little ambiance, service is fast friendly and respectful. Now the food! I can not say enough positive things about the food, saying they serve amazing pizza is like saying the Sistine Chapel has nice paintings. The English language does not have the words to describe the quality of pizza they serve.I would suggest grabbing the cheese bread with the pizza!
Read MoreErin G.
Jul 26, 2022
I might be biased because I haven't yet found a great pizza take-out place in the city, but this pizza exceeded expectations for me!A friend of mine just moved to Raytown, and heard from some neighbors and friends that this Southside Mafia Pizzeria was THE PLACE to go for pizza. So, after he moved over there, we decided to try it out, originally not sure if we wanted to dine in or take out--PRO TIP: there is no dine in! So, we walked up and ordered from the counter, which was super easy and fast. As others have noted, the inside of the shop is very small--I think about 8 people were waiting inside when we went and it was a bit crowded so we waited outside. When we ordered, they told us it'd be about 20-25 minutes, which makes sense since it was Friday and pretty busy even though we were there within the last hour if them being open.While we waited, we walked to the liquor store nearby, grabbed some goods, and when we waked back, the shop front had cleared out so we went and sat on the chairs inside. We weren't in there more than 5 minutes before the pizza was ready (total about 15 minutes waiting). While we were sitting inside, we learned that you can even order single slices, they have wings, cheese bread, and other options! Do note that all of their meats are actually turkey or beef--no pork!We ordered the Jesse James pizza that comes with beef, jalapeño, cheddar cheese, and "bacon" and it was fantastic. The jalapeños had a bit of heat like I enjoy, and the flavors, crust, and overall construction of the pizza was spot on! Definitely worth a trip if you're over that way and want some great pizza.Note: the parking lot is small and some spots connect to other businesses since it is in a mini-mall type area. Don't miss it!
Read MoreEllyn H.
May 6, 2023
We Postmated this pizza tonight. Wow! It came hot, bubbly, and it's SO good! I see this pop up all the time and I'm so glad we finally tried it! The breadsticks are delicious, the sauce is perfect, we will be back! Thank you!
Read MoreRobert M.
Jun 15, 2024
My wife and I have been searching for a great new pizza spot, and we finally found it! Our first experience with Mafia Pizzeria was fantastic. The crust was perfectly crispy, the sauce was delicious, and the pepperoni, placed on top of the cheese, was delightfully crispy as well. We have a new favorite!
Read More