Nicky's Pizza
Nicky's Pizza
My barbecue chicken pizza
Supreme without green peppers
the front of the restaurant
Nicky's lemonade with friends! My friends are locals and they say you have to have this. It was delicious!
Buffalo Wings bone in. Extra ranch
a slice of pizza on a pan
Nicky's lemonade
14" Large Taco Pizza
Chicken pizza on a gluten-free crust
menu
menu
take out
Half and half make your own
Grinder (subbed turkey for the ham)
Inside the seating area near the jukebox
Medium thin crust with jalapeños and mushrooms
Half and half? Make your own
Side salad
Ham and turkey club sandwich.
Ham and turkey club sandwich.
Cobb salad, very good
Ham, pepperoni and sausage medium pizza
Kids mostaccioli with marina and a meatball.
Marcia W.
Dec 4, 2024
We visited Nicky's to try the cauliflower crust pizza. Our server informed us that the cauliflower crust is very good, so we ordered one to verify. It was delicious!! Be aware that the cauliflower crust is only available in a 12 inch size. Also, there is a $4 up charge. Our pizza date was good-Nicky's is a good place to dine.
Read More
Claudia E.
Nov 28, 2024
Pretty solid place that I inadvertently stumbled upon. I had heard great things about a nearby place but they were closed when I got there, so I settled on this. It was a great decision!I sat at the bar, watched the Royals game on TV, and eavesdropped on the gentlemen near me having a conversation on who the GOAT quarterback is. I started with the grilled chicken salad, which I'm very glad I got because I always forget how much I like strawberries, bleu cheese, and pecans in a salad. I also ordered a Nicky's Favorite pizza to eat some now and take some to go. It was very solid pizza!Overall really cool place that I'd definitely recommend if you're in the area!
Read More
Eric K.
Mar 2, 2025
Over priced, went there 3 times, with the same results.Not a bad place to have a beer, but I would rather save $40 and go to Little cezars or Dominos.
Read More
Lesley F.
Nov 23, 2024
Went there on a Thursday evening with a group of friends. We all had salads and shared a large pizza. The salads were surprisingly delicious! I just had a house salad with blue cheese dressing. My friend said their dressings are homemade and I could tell. The pizza was excellent as well. Our server was fantastic.
Read More
Renae D.
Dec 29, 2023
We ordered carry out but the inside seemedCool & welcoming. We got the taco pizza which we reallyEnjoyed. The lettuce, sour cream, chips & salsa came on the side to top yourself (I would ask for extra sour cream if you're getting a large) We also really liked the creamy garlic dressing on our salad. But if you're a ranch lover they have really good ranch.
Read More
Libby G.
Jun 5, 2024
Called in order for pick up on Monday night, with 15/20 min wait time. Got the THIN CREST pepperoni pizza with pepperoncini, thin crest cheese pizza with no sauce and garden salad with ranch. The salad was super small but tasted great, just wish there was more for the value. Thin crest is amazing!The staff was super sweet and everything was ready upon arrival. Only thing was inside was a little dark but was clean!
Read More
Kellee F.
Jul 6, 2024
Pizza was yummy. Good spacious dining area. Fast service and the waitress was very friendly.
Read More
John M.
Sep 22, 2023
Well, well, well... pizza, huh, alright, I'll bite.The easiest way to explain this place is a pizza bar, the atmosphere sphere is what you would expect when you think that phrase, slightly louder than a pizza place, but not as rowdy as a full bar. It's family friendly, so the little ones can go, and they have quite the selection of beers, I stopped looking after Peroni as I rarely see that on a menu anywhere and just ordered it.The wait staff is pleasant and helpful. We had a trainer/trainee combo, so attention was there with no issues.We ordered the garlic cheese bread and the meatball with cheese as appetizers, and while I personally think the meatball was a tad pricey for what you get, it was good so if you haven't had it before i recommend it at least once. The bread was almost a perfect consistency of chewy cheesy goodness.That's where the wow factor kinda ends as we head into the main course:We ordered 2 medium build your own split pizzas... and .. well, they were pizzas, nothing really to write home about. They weren't bad, but I have certainly had better and I either don't understand my own spatial awareness or the split on the thing crust was off (yeah I know pedantic) but it caught my eye and I disliked it.TLDR; Overall score:Service - 5Ambiance - 4 (bar scene isn't my thing)Food - 3.5 (appetizers were wonderful, main courses acceptable)
Read More
Ron A.
Jan 26, 2025
Great pizza & appetizers make the trip every time to get it. Staff is always pleasant.
Read More
Marshal G.
Feb 10, 2025
frozen pizza at grocery store is better. Supreme pizza had less toppings than a totinos $2 pizza. bread sticks are literally a mini cheese pizza. Sorry, but never again. ugh
Read More
