XL Meat Lovers
Pepperoni pizza
a menu for a restaurant
a deer in the grass
Garlic knots
the menu of the restaurant
Medium Supreme
Meat Lovers (Medium)
Pizza, garlic knots
Pizza, garlic knots
Eggplant Parmigiana dinner (also came with spaghetti side, it's the same size bowl filled full)
Half Cheese Half Pep/Pineapple (Medium)
interior
outside
outside
outside
menu
The Supreme- pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, onions, mushroom.
menu
Chicken Parm
menu
interior
Cheese Pizza
Greg L.
Feb 21, 2025
When I walked in I was taken back by how ugly this place is. The ceiling tiles alone made me think I might need an antibiotic upon leaving. BUT, don't let first impressions fool you. Grandpa is in the back making pizza's and his granddaughter, who is adorable, is out front giving incredible customer service. The pizzas are good especially compared to the trash Domino's and Pizza Hut are throwing out there these days. It may look ugly but the tables are clean and the food is good! When you get sick of seafood give this place a try.
Read More
Kelsey K.
Nov 5, 2024
So many restaurants in the area are closed on Mondays so this was a good and easy week-night option! We got a pepperoni pizza with Pepperoncini. It was good and kind of true to new york style (I wish they cut our slices bigger). It wasn't too greasy either which is usually my biggest complaint when it comes to pizza. The crust held up to the toppings and the sauce was pretty solid. 4/5 stars because the dough wasn't my favorite but that might be because we got take out and it had a little too much time to sit and get hard/stale. I bet it would be great right out of the oven
Read More
Nati A.
Jan 28, 2024
Absolutely delicious. Love this locally owned place. Such wonderful people and the food is top notch! Will recommend to anyone who asks!! Just wow!
Read More
Paige G.
Dec 26, 2023
We ordered a medium supreme pie and a chicken parmigiana sub. The pizza was delicious but the chicken on the sub tasted off. Definitely recommend getting their pizza!
Read More
Laura T.
Sep 1, 2024
We grabbed takeout the other night. Pizza was soggy, wings were small and meh and they forgot our dressing. Out of the dessert we wanted which was a bummer ... maybe an off night?
Read More
Douglas B.
Apr 20, 2024
The supreme pizza we ordered was amazingly delicious. The order was ready when promised and the service was courteous. We picked up the pizza but the inside of the restaurant looked like they mainly did take out as there weren't many places to sit.
Read More
Heather C.
Oct 16, 2023
Arrived in the area for a few days. Wanted to go to the local seafood places but it appears they are all closed on Monday's. So we went with a time old favorite: pizza. Looked on yelp for a local run place and picked Tony's Pizza. Sigh. I thought ok New York style. Nope. Same thickness/thickness as normal pizza crust. Ordered xl sausage and pepperoni. Sausage was all exactly the same size- that made me think frozen right away. I read reviews that the sauce was good. I don't know what these people are used to but this sauce had no flavor. The entire pizza was blah. We eat A LOT of pizza lol, it's my fave food. And we threw away 3/4 of this pizza. It hurt my heart putting pizza into the trash. We also ordered garlic knots. Same thing: no flavor. Very disappointed
Read More
Petey S.
Mar 28, 2024
Thick sliced meat on really good toasted sub bread. Perfect for a grab and go on a beach day. Antipasto was also good, everything nicely sliced. Didn't try the pizza but would return for it based on the other items we tried!
Read More
Kamilah B.
May 18, 2023
This place is amazing. The pizza, garlic rolls, and desserts were so good. Highly recommend the baklava, it was fresh, crispy, and delicious! The ambiance was cozy and inviting. The service was probably one the best we received in a long time. Our family was in town for a wedding, the cashier was extremely kind, polite, and patient as we had a large order and decided to add on more food. They even gave us a free dessert. The owner of the restaurant was so sweet! He personally carried our pizza to the car and accommodated it in our trunk (suv). We offered a tip on top of everything and he refused, asking us to put it in the tip jar for his staff. World class man, and we would absolutely recommend this place to anyone that comes here. I'd give ten stars if I could, great service!
Read More
Stephanie C.
Sep 1, 2024
Pizza was very good! Excellent service and great customer service. I would definitely recommend this pizza.
Read More