Tony’s Pizza

The food excellent!The service amazing!The ambiance a comfortable and casualLove my new pizza joint. Reminds me of being up north to grab a couple of slices. Which they do... sell by the slice that is.

Nice small business. Food has always been good, and they are willing to customize the order. My wife loves the stuffed Manicotti, and they are always willing to make it with their Alfredo sauce instead of the marinara. The Stromboli fills the pizza pan, and we always enjoy the garlic knots.

We ordered a large pizza. It seemed like it was taken out of the oven, had more cheese sprinkled on it, and then not re-baked. It was covered in semi-melted, odd textured, mozzarella cheese. I wouldn't go back.

Back again!!! Best pizza in NE Florida. Good cold beer ! Pleasant staff. Great cuisine had it in the past!!

Great food and service! It's our favorite pizza place in Middleburg! Highly recommended.

Second time here. Had meatball sub for lunch. Excellent. Great sub and great price. Service was wonderful as well. Service with a smile.

The hours on apple map say they close at 10, but when I called for a pick up order at 8:40, they let me know they actually close at 9. I said nvm I didn't want to place an order & do that to them, but they said it was no problem. When showing up, I found out I called the wrong number somehow & they did not mind making me my order. I showed up at 9 & left with my fresh, hot order no later than 9:15. Needless to say, I will only be getting pizza from here from now on

In town for a 50k trail race and wanted pizza for my pre-race meal. Daughter yelped and found Tony's Pizza. What a find. Young lady who waited on us was very attentive and helpful. She recommended the garlic bread with mozzarella and it was . Mozzarella sticks were great along with pizza. Tony was there and he is very interactive with customers which was fun! Will be back when in town. 5 for Tony and 5for daughter for recommendation.

Called in an order and was quoted 20-25 minutes, it was ready at the 15 minute mark when I walked in. Pizza smelled absolutely heavenly on the ride home, everything was delicious!

The pizza was really good. The pizza was perfectly cooked on the crust but the middle felt not cooked enough. The atmosphere was very cute, it was like an old times shop. It had music in the background.