Stone’s Irish Pub

Wow ...Not sure where any poor reviews could have come from, however this place definitely didn't disappoint us!We had the Wings, Jerk and Bourbon seasoningWe had the Pilly SteakSmash Burger (animal style)Chicken Quesadillas.Oh boy! And Reeses Peanut butter CheeseCake! (Sorry no Picture of this, too eexcited when it came :p)The service from Katie was perfect!Thanks guys! We'll be back!

Not what it once was unfortunately. When we moved to FL from TX three years ago, this was my it very first favorite dining joint. We would drive over an hour round trip to eat here. The service was amazing and the quality of food was so high you would never think you were at a bar. Unfortunately after the name change it is just not the same. We miss the old mchenry's. Big time!

So, another little gem in sleepy Keystone Heights. Off the main road is Stone's Irish Pub. We came here with another couple for trivia night, but it was on our list of places to try since we relocated from Orange Park to KH late last year. Arrived around 5:30 pm and glad we did, as they filled up pretty fast after 6. We're seated promptly, and our server Cassie (ask for her section if she's working) was delightfully candid and all-around awesome. Drinks and apps were ordered and delivered pretty quickly, and they hit the spot. Add to it that you get a free domestic draft with a Yelp check-in, and there's a winner. Boom-boom shrimp as an app is highly recommended, with just the right heat in the sauce to dunk the perfectly cooked fried shrimp. Entree orders were placed when the apps were delivered, and were brought out right after the app was done. A side note, if you want the corned beef and cabbage, order it when you order apps, as it takes a half hour to get it freshly steamed. I had the Shepards Pie, and mama had the Southwest bowl with blackened chicken. Both entrees were delicious, as I can attest because I ate mamas leftovers the following day. Our companions had the Corned Beef with cabbage and Shepard's Pie, and both said they were delicious as well. Numerous TVs around the perimeter give Stones a Sports Bar feel, so don't go expecting a gourmet experience, but if you're in the area, definitely go and enjoy the ice cold beer and good food.

Got seats right away . Our waitress was very, very friendly. This place came recommended to us from a friend. Unfortunately, they were out of the cabbage, so the wife had to change up. Appetizers were very Casey and good.. But then my waitress tells me they have no yellow rice for my chicken bowl..lol .Gave my wife regular fries not the sweet potato fries she ordered. I got all beans, not even a smidge of rice. Food tasted good except for the discrepancies. Place with pretty busy..

I wish this place wasn't so cold every time I came in so I could actually enjoy my meal and not just be sitting there waiting to leave because of the room temp

Excellent atmosphere. 99 degrees outside, but when you walked inside, it was in the 70's. What a relief coming into a restaurant that actually had a sufficiently outfitted air conditioning system.We had the blackened wings for appetizers. They were perfectly cooked as requested and seasoned perfectly.The shepherds pie was very very good and well portioned. The beer was ice cold. Coldest I've had in a while. We will return.

Great service. Great band. Friendly staff. Should have oysters on menu other than that a fantastic night out.

Food and service was great Katie is a great server and provided outstanding service! Her drink and food recommendation were great 10/10

We eat here often and bring visitors as well. We never have to worry about the food or the service as they are always spot on. It's our favorite place to eat in Keystone.

Servers are very rude food is ok had to send food back twice and server was very rude and wanted to argue