Serafina’s Pizzeria

We were looking for authentic NY style pizza, and we found it! We've had a few different apps with pizza and everything has been delicious. There is a few for purchases made with a credit card. The ambiance is 'Everything NY, Staten Island, etc. '

Oh look...another "authentic" New York Pizza place! It's all downhill from here folks.Being an "authentic" born & raised New Yorker, nothing disappoints me more than these subpar pizza joints pretending to be like a NY pizzeria! Undercooked, overpriced, and bland tasting toppings, crust and sauce. In other words the whole pie was bad.You know those Elvis impersonators that think they're Elvis? Well, Serafina's is a poor impersonator for NY style pizza. I'm only surprised their not trying to sell me a "genuine" piece of the Brooklyn Bridge!In conclusion, this is mall quality food at best. Shame on you Serafina's

Food & Service...both 5 STARS. This is Brooklyn Pizza...as a NYr, I often crave NY pizza, wings and calzones, etc. This pizzeria is second to none. Food is always fresh...Thanks Christina & husband for making my family feel welcomed.Dan

Solid slice! Overall great tasting from the sauce to the cheese to the crust. This makes stop 3 on our local mini pizza tour. Definitely comparable to a decent NY slice. And yes, I know pizza, born and raised in Queens.

I really don't understand the hype with serafina pizza.. it wasn't bad but it wasn't great. Lacks flavor big time! The white pizza was so bland, the ricotta was rubbery and wouldn't even separate with your hands.. The sausage and mushroom was good though the mushrooms are canned and had major flop. No garlic or seasoning at all on either pizza.

LOVE this NY pizza place! Best pizza place I've found since moving to FL. The dough is thin but not too thin, perfect to fold and shovel in! Sauce is super tasty and I love getting the pizza with spicy pepperoni and jalapeño. Also tried their sub and it's super filling and delicious. This is my go-to pizza joint! I usually order to go but eaten inside a couple of times. The place is small but there are a few seats. Clean and very much reminds you of NY! Staff is very friendly and efficient. You must try!

I'm from NY & I know pizza. This is the best traditional pizza in the area. There are several other places that I enjoy for pizza but for traditional NY style pizza this is your place.

Good quality ingredients and great taste. I asked for light sauce and extra crispy that is exactly what I got. I would come back.

Missing ingredients!Ordered a 18 inch Sicilian Margherita with anchovies and chicken toppings, it came with no basil which was supposed to be there; and they ran out of anchovies but didn't say anything until the pie was already made, also put on very few pieces of chicken.The pizza not look anything like the pictures at all, looked like something from papa johns. I expect better for a near $40 pie!Edit: Fortunately, they have refunded without my asking.

I'm from NY and i mist say in all the pizza places i have tried in Jacksonville this is by far the best The Sicilian pizza is true SicilianYou wont be disappointed