Prohibition Pizza

The underground pizza is to die for. The theme of the place ties in perfectly for a great atmosphere. We visited on a home-buying trip from Maryland. I grew up in the Northeast around the Philadelphia area, and this was by far the best pizza I've ever had. This place is Florida's hidden gem!

Very unique pizza place. Options were very creative and the two pies we ordered were delicious! Friendly staff--the owner came outside to the patio and greeted us and asked if everything was good.

I was here because I was across the street at High Springs Brewing and wanted dinner. Already parked, already hungry, already starting my first beer. What to eat?And then, the "sandwich board" in the entrance got me and I didn't even have to look at the menu. The combination of ingredients just had me. The Dillinger which is "Vodka sauce, mozzarella & provolone cheese with sliced meatballs, bacon, caramelized onions, jalapenos, ricotta dollops finished with hot honey drizzle." About 15 minutes after ordering (and after my first beer was done), I was back over here to pick it up.Perfection. Spicy, meaty, cheesy, simply delicious.[Review 1037 of 2024 - 1912 in Florida - 22065 overall]

WOW! Just wow! I gave this pizza place 5 stars because everything I tried was delicious and the service was great! My family had the Old World and they loved it. I had the Blind Pig which was surprisingly better than I thought it would be. Every ingredient blends well together! The green olives or jalapeños don't overpower, they add to it. Again, I was pleasantly surprised and would eat here again!

Overview: 5/5 I am admittedly a New York pizza snob. This place passes the test with 5 stars across the board. Thank Heavens for a new restaurant choice in High Springs!!!Ambiance : 5/5Love, LOVE, love the decor throughout this place. The women's bathroom was AMAZING. No expense spared on new pizza ovens, plenty of tables inside and out for smaller groups. Large parties might have trouble getting seated together. Food/Drink 5/5I order a Margarita pizza that was perfect. The crust was just right, sauce was not too sweet and fresh mozzarella and basil. Beautiful presentation.My wife had a build your own with pepperoni, mushroom, peppers and onions. It was outstanding. It was crisp on the bottom but light and not too thick. Only thing that would have made this better is a beer from High Springs brewery (which is right next door). This place is working on a liquor license so fingers crossed. They have a unique dessert with a clever name called the "Beeramisu" which is a spin-off on Tiramisu. The owner created the recipe and it was delicious.Service : 5/5Wonderful!! Kelly the owner brought the food to our table and checked on us a couple of times. I always think it's pretty important afor a new establishment (open about month) that the owners keep tabs on the customers. Well done Kelly.Conclusion : We live in Alachua but I will have no problems jumping in a car to ride to this place. Hopefully many, many times.

Super nice place, super great pizza and super great service. Shaded outdoor area if you have your pup with you.

THE BEST GF PIZZA IVE EVER HAD!! Prohibition Pizza was not only delicious, but they have a really cool atmosphere with indoor and outdoor seating. The staff is SOOO friendly and really care for their customers. They were extra careful with my allergy, which I appreciate so much!! 10/10 recommend, do yourself a favor and go get some pizza from Prohibition Pizza, trust me.

Cute little place with great pizza. Service was great. The have a selection of alcoholic drinks - beer, wine, cider and seltzers.

Amazing taste really good very clean love the atmosphere great attitude very pleasant

Service, parking and pizza were all top of the line. Would absolutely recommend visiting!