Primo Pizza

I love that they offer slices, huge plus! Great crisp, very minimal flop, not very saucy which isn't a bad thing for me. The cheese and dough had a good flavor and the smell is just intoxicating. Definitely worth the 20 minute drive and honestly I'd drive further if we had to. A must try if you're looking for a good slice comparable to NY pizza.

We ordered from Primo pizza on a Tuesday. When I called they confirmed my name and phone number was correct.After looking at the menu, I opted to get a large half pepperoni and half cheese pizza and a large order of garlic knots.The gentleman on the phone said it would be 15 minutes. I was stunned, so quick!When I arrived everything was ready to go. Got home and dug into the pizza and garlic knots. THe pizza was piping hot and there was a ton of pepperoni on the half side, which was great. The garlic knots were good, but we were missing the marinara dipping sauce.I'll come back!

Fantastic pizza! They have the pizzas available on display through the glass at the counter and most are packed with all sorts of yummy ingredients! The Buffalo chicken and Primo supreme were my favorites but they have many other options as well. They also have fountain drinks, sweet and unsweetened tea and water for beverages. They offer a few bar seats and booths for those dining in

Definitely Primo Pizza is a can't go wrong choice if you're craving a really good NY Pizza! I also had Primo Pizza's meatballs' "so good!". Locally owned and operated Nick is an awesome pizza man. Top ingredients!

Atmosphere is very quaint. The pizza is fast and high quality ingredients. Staff is super friendly and has real Cheers vibes. I'll definitely be back

The first step to a problem is admitting that you have one...and on that note...my problem is I love pizza! That is, my family and I love pizza and we are self-proclaimed pizza snobs! Hubs is from NY and I'm pretty sure if anyone in his family ever gets cut they'll bleed marinara. Ha! After all, you are what you eat...right? Seriously...a good pizza is a beautiful thing! There are certain ingredients to a pizza that you just can't reproduce...water being one of them. Water has a greater impact than you think. That said, I do love New York-style pizza and honestly, no place down here has perfect NY pizza and that is probably because of differences in things like the water or whatever...but there is one that is close though and that is Primo Pizza! I must say, Primo Pizza is as "close" to being as perfect as you can get and is by far the best pizza in this area. How can I not give them 5 stars? OK...some may argue since we all have different taste buds and even NY pizza is different and territorial. To me/us, if you are used to the pizza in Brooklyn, Long Island, etc...this is your place!!! The prices are fair and you get a lot of bang for your buck! They actually have a large menu and offer a lot more than pizza. We haven't tried anything else on the menu...yet!!! We always say we are going to try something else, but the pizza is so good we just end up salivating thinking about it and get pizza! There is indoor dining, carry-out/pickup, and a delivery option. The owners and staff are always super friendly when we go there to pick up. Doesn't matter who picks up in our family...we are always greeted fondly and get a chuckle from something. Moreover, they have a uniformed discount with proof of ID too. They are a family-owned business and considering the pandemic, the price hikes, etc....most folks are happy they weathered through it and are here. The store/restaurant is located in a small strip mall. Always easy to get into, but can't say the same for getting out of it. Depending on the time of day, it can be quite tricky and/or frustrating. You can go around the corner by the ACE Hardware store to proceed onto the back road, but depending on which way you turn and the time of day or the day of the week...it can present a different set of interesting issues. The parking can be tricky at times because quite frankly...there isn't enough of it. If you don't see a spot, just drive around the corner on the end by ACE hardware, you'll find a spot down there and it's just a few more steps. I wish they were located in Palencia Commons, but they aren't...so where there is a will, there is a way...and we always find parking and get that pizza home warm! Oh, forgot to mention...there is a restroom inside as well as a small bar. As for all the other pizza places...Fahgettaboudit...just come here for a smile and a slice! The pizza does not disappoint!

First of all walking into this place brought me back to my childhood up north traditional New York Style Pizzeria. With all the touches bring back those memories. Now I'm no David Portnoy but I know the pizza from Primo would score high on his scale. Service was great my kids even told them the pizza was delicious and they even took the time to explain to us what sets them apart from the other. It's all in the ingredients. We will definitely be back, the boys even enjoyed watching some March Madness !!!

One of my favorites pizza joints in the area, typically sells out on weekends though so you need to get your order in asap during dinner rush. I'd describe their style as New York but with slightly more crispy crust. While there is a small dining area it's best use is for waiting to take your pies back home right when they are fresh out of the oven.

Trash. Fake NYC pizza served by rude yo yo's. Went twice. Utter shite. Way better options close by.

First, Im 71 years old and this is the first time I ever wrote a review. I want to let folks know this was not only the tastiest meatball sub I have eaten since here in Florida filled most generously with meat and cheese. This is the type of meal I grew up with in local pizzerias in New Jersey! Great job fellas! Pizza is always the best here, but now it's great to have another option