NYC Meatballs & Pizzeria

About to re-open some time in Aug 2024!Was definitely the BEST pizza place in Oakleaf.

We dined in on a Thursday night for the first time since the management change. the restaurant was busy but we were seated right away. We got draft beers, fried garlic knots, an oakleaf salad, two pizzas. The knots were crispy and delicious with lots of garlic. The salad was a good size. Pizza crusts were thin and crispy and there were plenty of toppings on both. The only thing that dampened the experience was that beer pitchers are no longer available. We will definitely be back.

Was searching for a new spot to eat at and came across this place. Nice restaurant located in a shopping plaza. We were immediately seated on a Saturday evening and the staff was very nice. We ordered a cheese pizza, garlic knots, baked ziti, and the Cajun ranch wings. Everything came out in a decent time. The garlic knots were very good. The wings were okay but still good. They had drunk options as well and were playing the football game on multiple screens.

Called in for a pick-up. No long wait on phone, took order quickly and politely. Pizza was ready on time 20-30 minutes. Upon arrival, service was good and nice. Pizza price was a little high, 25ish for 16". I ordered supreme and the flavor was good, but the crust is paper thin. I didn't see crust options so I'm assuming this is the default crust. It is not my preference, but flavor was okay.

Best local restaurant. Great pizza, amazing garlic knots. Nice atmosphere. Owner is very community oriented.

Under newer ownership, NYC has come back to their roots - good pizza, fantastic wings & great service!I couldn't ask for a better neighborhood joint.Each visit that I've made since the ownership change has been very consistent - this was unheard of previously - in both the quality of the food & the service provided by the staff.They have a weekly special (Mon-Thurs) currently that's hard to pass up: garlic knots, 10 wings & XL cheese pizza

What a menu! Whatever you crave it's here in a pizza form. Pickles and ranch maybe? They have it.Crust choices include cauliflower, thin or New York. Maybe your favorite toppings include, Feta or Ricotta with Grilled Chicken maybe? Steak or Meatballs? Even Eggplant it's avaliable here on freshly made crust of choice so enjoy some great flavors and have a slice of life.Don't forget to order those knots too...mmmmmm

My wife, nephew and I dropped by on a Friday evening around 630pm and although busy had no problem getting a table. We looked over their beer list on the wall and found a couple of favorites. Our server promptly took our order and when we mentioned it was our first time enthusiastically suggested bread knots to start. Good thing to as we hadn't eaten since breakfast. The knots were just OK in our books but did take the edge off while waiting for our pizzas to arrive. The pizzas arrived on a two tier stand that was handy and space saving. Our nephew got a glutton free pizza that he enjoyed. My wife and I got a 14" deluxe pie with a good mix of meats and veggies but no olives. Yeah. The pie was fresh and cooked to perfection. Overall the pie was fine with a light dough that was very similar to what we make at home. The 14" size was good size to share for two. Service was good the entire time. The dining room was a little noisy but not bad. It was oddly laid out though with a high booth wall that kinda chop the space in half.

The pizza is fantastic, so are the wings. The inside of the restaraunt has been updated, and it looks so upscale. What's even better, it that they have a full bar. YEAH, GROWN UP DRINKS ! Do yourself a favor, go and enjoy!

Service and food was great we ordered a large pepper and onion pizza crust was perfect, we will definitely be back!