Mint cupcake
a hand holding a pastry
a variety of cupcakes
Nana Teresa's Bake Shop storefront
Wedding cake
a variety of cupcakes
Red velvet cookie
Chocolate mousse pie
Nana Teresa's Bake Shop
Storefront
Memorial Day cookie up close!
Open is my happy sign!
interior
Cupcakes and apple dessert
Wedding cake
Cannoli
Unicorn cake.
Exterior
food
interior
outside
Chocolate tart
Carley S.
Feb 4, 2025
I got the chamomile tea and a gluten free chocolate cake slice. Super yummy! The store is a little tight if lots of people come to check it out. Great selection.
Read More
Phil E.
Dec 9, 2024
There were a few things I would enjoy from this shop We had/split the peanut butter and chocolate cheesecake (yum) Decent price
Read More
Kerri E.
Dec 10, 2024
So many delicious options! Ice cream, pastries, cookies, etc. we got a peanut butter cup cheesecake to go. It was delicious. Nice employees.
Read More
John B.
Sep 30, 2023
This pastry shop made choosing difficult. I managed to dodge the kouign aman, a notoriously buttery creation, but the things I got were nonetheless quite rich, with what tasted like buttercream icing on my small but delicious andes mint cupcake. I was told their almond croissant is a signature item for them, and this was no ordinary croissant, more of a croissant sandwich with almond-flavored cream and a few raw almond slivers. It was indulgent, but it was worth it.The ice cream is a brand that's available elsewhere, but they had some decent drink options and I was nowhere near being able to try all of the nice looking pastries.
Read More
David A.
Apr 5, 2024
Stopped by Nana Teresa's bake shop during a recent visit to Fernandina Beach. We stopped by in the morning to get some ideas for later in the day. A really charming little shop where the staff was friendly and welcoming. There are tables inside and out and they had constant business for good reason. I decided to try the ultimate white chocolate cookie and we ordered some other desserts to take home. The cannoli, a lemon curd tart and coffee cake. We were fortunate. Many of the great desserts that we saw in the morning were gone. The cookie was fantastic. A soft hearty sugar cookie base with a great vanilla buttercream frosting. On top of that was some white chocolate shavings, pieces of a white chocolate Kit Kat and Hershey's white chocolate as well. It was really an elevated cookie experience. As good or better than anything I've had in a cookie. There are many other ultimate cookies to try and I can't wait. This morning, I had some of the coffee cake. THE best coffee cake I've had anywhere. Excellent. This is reason alone to pay a visit. We'll be back. Highly recommend Nana Teresa's.
Read More
Kelly K.
Sep 15, 2024
I got a slice of their NY cheese cake. It was tasty, however I thought it was too expensive at $7.50 a slice. If I was at a restaurant I expect to pay this price but not taking a slice to go from a bakery. I didn't like how no prices were listed. You have to ask how much if you want to know a price.
Read More
Angela H.
Apr 14, 2024
Just a quick stop before having lunch. But oh did I not realize how TASTY these macarons are! There is a Biscoff - you know the little tea biscuit from Europe that you get on planes? Cinnamon and brown sugar kind of taste. The Biscoff macaron has a slight outer crispy shell but when you bite in, it's soft and a little chewy. Mmmmmmm so good
Read More
Alicia A.
Aug 3, 2024
YUMMY YUMMY YUMMY I will definitely be back and I am excited to try more of these amazing treats- definitely the hidden gem of Amelia
Read More
Carla D.
Nov 17, 2023
During a day trip to Amelia Island we had a sweet tooth. So I decided to pull out my phone and check out places near me that had baked goods. Nana Teresa's Bake Shop popped up.I will say I had my eye on this shop multiple times when I've searched for something sweet in the past. We arrived later afternoon. When we arrived it was a brightly colored shop that had a few display cases of sweets.I will say we got there too late, because they didn't have a ton of items to choose from. Luckily for me they still had a few cannolis left.We bought a few cannolis and we all decided to wait until we got home to dig into our sweets.When I had my cannoli it had a crisp outer shell, creamy filling, and topped with mini chocolate chips. It was good, and I was happy that the shell wasn't soggy.If you're making a trip to Amelia Island/Fernandina, and want to make sure you grab something sweet here, you can order items online and pickup in store. They do everything from classic Italian pastries to custom cakes.
Read More
Louis B.
Jan 12, 2024
HeyHey play, the food was homemade food that is supervised so the dough was just the right way the crust was perfect in this dessert. Just wonderful food little tiny spot that can do big things low profile expensive so they're aware service was excellent. Ambience was nothing here in downtown Amelia Island in a little box, but it was OK coffee little Napoli you're good
Read More
Rated: 4.2 (79 reviews) · $
Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Juice Bars & Smoothies