Musselwhite's Seafood Grill

We have been here 2x already an both times it has been great. We were greeted as soon as we walked in a seated. The place is very cute and very clean. There are a lot of tables so I'm sure you would probably never have to wait very long for one. Our waiter came over immediately and greeted us an took our drink order and then came back for our order. The food came out pretty quick and was very good. I love when food comes out hot and not like warm. I had Blackened Mahi which was cooked perfectly. Just the right amount of spice and very moist. Highly recommend it. My husband had the seafood platter, tilapia shrimp and he said it was very good. Our waiter was very good. He kept coming back to make sure we had everything we needed and to refill our drinks. The prices are very good for the amount of food that you get and everything I've had so far there has been very good. Great service great food and great people.

Good food a little pricey tho. We just went back for the second time after several years and left with the same feelings.Most be our taste because they are always packed.

Thought it was going to be much more expensive & fancy than I thought from the outside. Just good honest seafood grill and great house made pies! Not expensive in the least! Be sure to try their Key Lime Pie! I got mine to go since I was full!

Stopped for lunch on a weekday. Excellent fried shrimp, great sides, and amazing homemade pie! Reasonably priced too! Our server was awesome!

This is my favorite local restaurant. Our go to is the fried shrimp. Homemade ranch is on point. The onion rings are huge and delish. Service is fast and friendly.

Coconut shrimp was great, staff were very accommodating, and prices are more reasonable than other locations. We'll be back to try other dishes.

I had the Ribeye and it was the most tender and flavorful ever. The Gator Bites were so good and the Key Lime Pie was the best I have ever tasted. An overall excellent place to eat. Will definitely eat there again.

Service was excellent. I got the shrimp and fresh flounder prepared St John Style. It was good but I had to send it back to be broiled to brown it up. The juice from the fish on my plate got the fried shrimp all wet and soggy. There is additional change for St John style and the fish being fresh which we were ok with but not informed when placing our order. Everyone was very friendly.

I read the review by "Mark" from CA. I think he must be California trippin'.I've eaten at Musselwhite's for as long as they have been open, I suppose 10 + years. They serve the absolute BEST shrimp in the area. These are fresh shrimp, not frozen like most. and they a large, butterflied and lightly battered, ( i.e. more shrimp, less dough). My understanding is that the owner learned to cook them years ago while working for "O'steens"... probably the best seafood in St. Augustine. I suggest you ignore one bad review and give them a try if you haven't already. You will be glad you did! JT

I ordered the Seafood Platter for $25. The presentation was jus a little better than grill scrapings. Maybe 3 shrimp, 2 scallops, and the rest could pass for batter fried mini french fries. The crab cake and fried fish was eatable, definitely not fresh. I would stick to only grilled items on the menu if you chose to eat here. This place has potential as the bar staff was friendly and so were the customers. I try to patronize local businesses while on the road, but this one goes in the FAIL column in my book.