Mix pizza , half "white pizza" and half House special".
Website Elevated Salad - what my salad should have looked like but did not
Mellow mushroom bar
Bar area. TVs everywhere
Sweet Thai chili wings
a pizza on a table
Pizza and Bingo
Entrance sign
Art on the wall
Anchovies and Mushrooms
Holy Shiitake pizza
Mellow. Mushroom 'house special' pizza
My terrible salad with little chicken and small quantity
Sweet Thai chili wings
If you can't do it right why bother?! Mellomushroom get your kitchen in order!!!
Mellow Mushroom buffalo chicken pizza
Thin crust Maui Wowie
Pepperoni but not much pineapple
Build your own. Thin crust with pepperoni, green pepper and onion.
Half meatball sub and tater tots
Caesar salad
Exterior
Regular Greek Salad add chicken
Katie F.
Nov 13, 2024
Stopped at mellow mushroom and Saint Augustine saw Joe passing and we're like we need to eat there for dinner. I got a small pizza with dairy free cheese pepperoni and pineapple and my mom got a small cheese pizza with marinara. I also ordered a sprite and she ordered a Coke zero. I love the ambience of this mellow mushroom- so the inside of this mellow mushroom meets local living with funky art around state of Florida there is a giant triptych on the wall of like alligators dolphins surfers and ocean items there is a giant fossilized alligator on the wall; in the bar area there is like a Mural around the top talking about the Spaniards coming over and the Indians in Florida with a bunch of trippy mushroom drawings. No let's talk about the highlight of our meal our server was attentive, kind, and very nice. Sarah is phenomenal server; she needs a raise. She's amazing and very good. SARAH IS PHENOMENAL 100/100
Read More
Scott W.
Feb 23, 2025
We showed up and half the place was empty. The thing at the weight stand, which I think was a boy, but I wasn't sure we could add a pink banana hair clip with hair down to his butt told us that they needed to give the kitchen space and we had to wait for 15 minutes for a booth. Then when we got seated, it wasn't a booth because apparently you need five people and we had three but yet they didn't tell us that when we said we wanted... A booth. if you're a hipster that does mushrooms and this is the place for you. But if you're adult with a hungry child, then I would highly suggest you go to places that aren't being run or greeted by dudes that prints around with their hair in a clip, needing safe spaces for the kitchen and concerned about trigger warnings from guests that are hungry after sitting for 15 minutes with a half empty restaurant
Read More
Daniel L.
May 29, 2024
I only stopped in here for a drink and an appetizer and it was good. There are drink specials and a happy hour. I just had a domestic draft beer served nice and cold. My wife and I split an order of the cheese bread. Enjoyed everything here.
Read More
Monica C.
Feb 3, 2024
We do love this pizza so we cameback again! They are very busy, Saturday at 7:20 PM, 50 minutes waiting time. I ordered my strawberry lemon limeade, no alcohol but still strong so I mixed with half a glass of water and oh Boy, I am addicted. I love the great white pizza, that didn't come cut all the way through, I hope next time they do. My family decided on created their own pizza, pictures here. They do have live music on Saturdays after 5:00 pm, very nice very nice. We had a great time here today.
Read More
Lorie B.
Jul 27, 2024
I just visited the Murabella location in St Augustine and ordered to go for the very first time and I was not impressed with the food portions. I ordered an Elevated Cobb salad and I waited 35 minutes for it which is not an issue for me. But when I received the salad, it was nothing like I expected as I paid close to $20 and it was a very smallPortion for the price I paid, similar to a side salad from McDonald's which you pay only $6 for. I ordered a chicken add on I only received one small crumbled piece. The website picture for this item shows several slides of pieces of chicken that I was supposed to receive and I did not. . The staff was very friendly and I did inform them that I would not be visiting again as I can go next door to Zaxbys and receive and amazing high quality and larger portion of a Cobb salad for half the costs with many add one for less cost! The associate did not even offer to refund my order and I just walked out after kindly discussing my unhappiness. So I do not recommend Mellow Mushroom for any salads as they are cheap on their quantity and portion size such as chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, etc and for $19.90 with tax and approx. $2 tip, I should have received a better salad. I have attached picture of what my salad should have looked like from Mellow Mushrooms Website, and the salad I actually received, and the high cost of this small side salad when it should have been made with better quantity of food and a bigger portion size for the higher costsHowever, the location is very beautiful inside and the waitresses and bartenders are very nice. But again, I will not be visiting again nor ordering .
Read More
Laura K.
Nov 26, 2024
The food is good, but dang the service is always HORRIBLE at this location. We tried carryout this time because of how long it took to get our meal in the restaurant the last two (2) visits. The buger and pizza sat in the commercial warmer for 20 minutes because of a problem with the dressing for the ceasar salad? Wait, what? They let the warm food get soggy looking for ceasar dressing. Strike 3, MM. I'm sad.
Read More
Mindy S.
Apr 20, 2024
Look, I'm a little shocked at this place's rating. My mom offered to have a sleepover with our kids so we went to Yelp and looked for a 5 star place for a date night. It was awful. On the way home we passed Mellow Mushroom and I was starving so we stoops in and the service was AMAZING. Sat down at the bar and Brian IMMEDIATELY looked at me and said "I'll be right with you darling". He talked to us about beer, we had the best pizza ever, he let me order beers and mix them (it's a thing I do), he talked to my husband about whiskey... we just wanted something in our stomach before we got home and instead were like 4 drinks deep and wondering why this place only has 3 stars on Yelp?Look, the location could be better. This intersection is awful. But the service and food is worth it to come here.Thank you Brian for turning our date night around. We'll be back to visit you next time grandma is willing to keep the kids overnight!
Read More
David C.
Feb 12, 2024
Rushed to open with very inexperienced staff particularly the kitchen team. Very slow food at peak times and wait staff routinely messes up credit card charges. Been twice due to other people choosing and had the same poor experience both times. I have spent almost 4 hours there and never saw a manager unless the place is being managed by an 18yo girl in Jean shorts. Will not be going back and have spoken to multiple neighbors in WGV with identical experiences and sentiments. People, you are not that hard up for pizza to be eating here!
Read More
Leilani D.
Feb 10, 2024
Have been soooo excited to have MM close to home now. Went Thursday night. 2-8-24 aroun 5:30pm. Was seated right away at a high top. Sat for 15 mins without 1 person coming to us. Never got a drink order or anything. Got up and left and let hostest know server never even came to our table...One walked by multiple times. Looked at us and even sat and talked to table next to us just chatting while we just sat. Horrible serves
Read More
Christine L.
Feb 1, 2025
I usually get a great fresh pizza from this place but today it was like a pizza from and arcade that has been sitting on a warmer all day. Very disappointed! Don let the pizzas set there all day then run it through the oven! I wanted that I would have went to the gas station for pizza!
Read More