Juicy Mayport

The restaurant is located on a business strip. The sign is easy to see. The restaurant was very clean and spacious. We went on a Saturday during lunch time. The service was quick and professional.The food was delicious and hot. I love cheese sticks and these are some of the best I've taste. The shrimp fried was had eggs in it and the shrimp were a nice size.The fried shrimps were hot and tasty. Next time I will try the all you can eat Seafood,You select 4 items at a time and keep selecting until you get full.

The food was great and prices are reasonable. The oysters and seafood was fresh. I only wondered why the served the appetizers and food nearly at the same time. Didn't give us time to finish before the main dish. Clean and nice inside - simple set up with lots of screens if you are into that.

The all-you-can-eat seafood special at this place is definitely worth the price! Price range from $45-$52 per/person . I've been here four times already, and it hasn't failed to impress me. The sauce is incredible, and the seafood boil selection is fantastic. You'll leave feeling stuffed and satisfied. Only downside drinks are okay, and the service was generally okay.

I almost admittedly don't want to write this review because then everyone will know about this place lol but I can't hold in my secrets lol. Hands down best seafood spot in Jacksonville with such a great all you can eat option. The flavor of the sauce is insanely delicious and the food is super fresh. Such a great restaurant with even better food. Run don't walk!

We originally saw this restaurant on a Instagram post and decided to try after I searched it on Yelp and TikTok to get more honest reviews. The location was in a nice large lot which had ample parking and the restaurant was extremely clean and large. Upon arrival we were greeted and sat almost immediately. We opted to try the AYCE menu as that seemed to be a popular option and who doesn't love AYCE seafood boil?! We started off with waters, calamari and my husband ordered a dirty martini. The waters and calamari came out fairly quickly and we proceeded to place our first round of orders. The seafood boil came out pretty quickly after ordering and that's about all that went well. we were still waiting on the martin when the food came out so my husband inquired and the waitress went to check on it. We started in on the seafood. The crab legs were extremely thin and we did not have a tool to crack them open, typically I don't need one but these were tough and the meat did not slide out like everyone else's experience claimed. Our shrimp were overcooked and the sausage were rubbery. The sauce was minimal and had virtually no flavor. The crab leg sliced my finger when I tried to crack it. We ordered a second round to give it another try thinking we got a bad batch but the outcome was the same. My husband's martini finally came out and it did not taste like a martini at all. He was very disappointed and yes he knows exactly what it's supposed to taste like. For dessert they brought us what looked like what we'd describe as prison ice cream lol extremely frost bitten in a styrofoam cup. The price point was great but unfortunately the food did not match the reviews we read. We may go back for another try as maybe it was a bad night in the kitchen but I'm not so sure.

Juicy Mayport has been a favorite of mine for awhile now. Great location, good drinks, good food and the service is good as well. I usually get the pound of snow crab with juicy special sauce medium and it's amazing!! But today I got the fried shrimp, Cajun shrimp, and coleslaw and everything was good!! The shrimp was fried to perfection and seasoned very well. The coleslaw was sweet like i like it, not too sweet but flavorful as well.The ambiance of the restaurant is very chill and seaside-ish!! They also have an all you can eat special!! Make sure to check them out!

This place is delicious, ate so much we did not have room for dessert, but I forced that keylime pie down.Had the all you can eat from a TikTok recommendation. I would eat here everyday if possible ***Warning***You are charged for any leftovers!!!

Definitely not worth the price they charge for the AYCE. Both my husband and I ended up with food poisoning. We had crab, crawfish, shrimp and sausage were the only things ordered for the AYCE... about 2-3 hours after eating we both were running to the toilet.. all night. Even into the next day we were both sick. The service was awful. Took 20 minutes to even get drinks (just sodas) the waitstaff stood around talking instead of paying attention to customers. Won't be back.

We came here for a birthday after we were disappointed by the prices at the juicy crab (16$ for 1 cluster!). We came to juicy Mayport for the all you can eat seafood which included snow crab, shrimp, mussels, fried oysters, krab Rangoon and so much more. The ambience was very clean and cutely decorated. The service was quick and didn't leave you waiting long for your food to be served. When you finish your first order you can put in the next one right away.

If you enjoy quality seafood this is NOT the place for you. I came for the AYCE. The food tasted like it's premade back of house HOURS previous and thrown into sauce. Half the muscles I ordered were under steamed so the shells weren't open. The crab legs were ok. But again tasted old. appetizers were underwhelming and lacking flavor. My side salad was in a hot bowl with the worst ranch ever. I only came to try it from the good reviews but everyone has different taste. Idk for $45 I expected a higher quality.