Holey Moley Bagel Shop

* Bagel with flavor cream cheese ( They didn't added the flavor cream cheese I asked for. Gave me plain ) with a cinnamon raisin bagel tasteless . * Fruity Pebbles Waffle was yummy! ( Can't go wrong with Fruity Pebbles )* Holey Moley Sandwiches was tasteless and flavorless. Rather go to Einstein Bagels way better!

Bagels are huge and they don't skimp on the cream cheese We also tried the bagel egg and cheese with bacon . They have a lot of different choices . Close to NY bagels as you can get

The flavor of the overall sandwich was good. There were just some aspects lacking...One thing I don't appreciate is hidden fees. I don't recall seeing anything about up charge for choice of bagel or cream cheese choice but there sure was...The person who took our order was lackluster, I'm not sure if it was his confusion on how to operate the register or just a bad day but felt like we were inconveniencing him by being there. Overall the lox was good and fresh, the bagel is pretty dense and could have been benefitted from extra toasting but it wasn't bad The decor is a little dingy, not sure if that's part of the older building status quo or what. If we were nearby we'd try again but we definitely wouldn't go out of our way to eat here.

Stopped in for a quick lunch. You walk in and can see the bagel display right away. Then you order at the counter and they bring out the order to you. I was able to order right away. Got an Asiago everything bagel ( two of my favorites in one! ) with cream cheese and a fountain drink. It came out to $8.05 which I felt was expensive. The bagel came out warm with the cream cheese already on. The cream cheese was thicker than the half of the bagel. Which isn't my favorite but it was tasty. The bagel was soft and chewy even lightly toasted. The inside is pretty sparse with decorations and there was an empty deli case and a beverage case that was out if order. It seemed clean in the dining area and the open kitchen area. It was good but just be aware it was a bit pricy.

I've been searching for a bagel shop near me, so when this came up, I was pretty excited to try it. The place itself is pretty cute. I like the graffiti wall and the menu display. The selection of bagels, though, pretty disappointing. We were planning on getting a dozen bagels but changed our minds when we got there. I love the smell of a bagel shop, but this one was a turnoff. Smelled like dirty water. We ended up just getting breakfast sandwiches...I guess I would sum up by saying, if you are hungry and close, stop in. I wouldn't go out of my way though.

You're just the G.O.A.T... You're just undeniably the greatest of all time with the chopped cheese breakfast bagel. Whoever made it... you're the GOAT too. Just speechless.

I wanted to try this place for a while because they said it was like NY bagels and it wasn't. The service for the person at the counter was great and the place looked clean, but my bagel was not toasted and there was too much cream cheese for my liking. I will be giving them a second try soon.

Honestly pretty alright bagel for Jax, iced coffee wasn't the greatest unfortunately it tasted exactly how you would expect it to. The home fries weren't personally MY cup of tea but it may be yours! Honestly I'll be back I love bagels and this is the closest bagel sandwich joint to my house. Also this is now NY bagels not holey moley? Oh and the service was amazing loved those girls vibe was perfect as well. The Weeknd was the only artist playing and I was obsessed.

Growing up in New Jersey, I've been to many bagel shops and have had lots of bagels in my life. Holey Moley Bagel Shop was very disappointing.Their bagels are just okay, nothing special. Definitely nowhere near as good as a NY/NJ style bagel. They do not seem to function as a typical bagel shop either. When I order a bagel with cream cheese, I expect to be asked if I want the bagel toasted. Then to have the cream cheese put on the bagel. They did not so that. Instead they gave us cream cheese on the side and charged us way too much for enough cream cheese for half a bagel. This is just unacceptable.The service was spotty at best. It seemed like their employees were not trained well.I will not be back to Holey Moley.

This bagel shop is tasty and reasonably priced! The man who took my order was very sweet and he carried my food directly to me instead of having me walk up which I thought was sweet. I got the 3 pancake platter and a lox bagel. The pancakes were perfect and syrup was provided. The lox bagel was good and the amount of cream cheese was great but could have been toasted a little more. I will definitely be back here for breakfast again in the future!