Holey Moley Bagel Bar NYC

Bagels were awesome. Mine had a nice jalapeño flavor. I thought it might not be as flavorful and spicy but it was perfect. Blueberry bagel was delicious. We got everything to go but will mention issues below next time. Asked for toasted bagels and they did not appear to be toasted but they were so delicious and loaded with cream cheese, I'm not unhappy at all. In fact they were so soft and fresh, honestly didn't need toasting. Service was friendly and fast. Coffee tasted really weak. The help yourself coffee area needs some attention to cleanliness so those two issues were where they lost points today. Still a great value for 2 coffees and two bagels with cream cheese for about $10.00.

Fantastic bagels and friendly staff! I had the Holey Moley sandwich on the Jalapeno Asiago, and it was very tasty - hit the spot!Tip: go early as they sell out of some of the bagel varieties. Also know that they have drip coffee and some premade, flavored iced coffees, but do not have espresso drinks or cold brew.

HELP!!!!! I love this place but had a question about if they are closing? Google says they are temporarily closed. I tried calling the number and it says the number is out of service, I also noticed another place with the same name pop up in orange park on HWY 17?? Does anyone know what is up?

Fantastic bagels and great service. We love the options and freshness of the food. The one item we didn't care for was the hash brown. The time we ordered them as they were soggy/oily, but otherwise the food is great!

What can I say? Being from NJ, I feel I have an undeniable right to judge any place that boasts bagels from NYC.As far as bagels go, this place isn't the worst, but it's certainly not the best. Especially when you consider its slow service, it took 30 mins to get a bagel. Not to mention that their exhaust fan was broken, and the amount of smoke in the place had people crying. I really wanted to say I found a good bagel shop but this isn't it. You are better off not actually making the trip here and just ordering from Uber Eats to save your lungs and eyes.

Awesome little bagel shop. They have coffee too! Good amount of indoor seating. Fast service and good prices. Will be back for more.

Got there early afternoon and they were mostly out of everything. Ended up having bacon, egg and cheese on jalapeño Asiago bagel. It was good. Coffee was pretty good. Would come back.

This was such a great find! Extremely clean, with friendly, thoughtful service. There are a myriad of breakfast sandwiches and options--my bacon, egg, and cheese breakfast bagel was just about perfect. The bagels are also excellent, with plenty of varieties , and plenty of different cream cheese choices, as well. If you've been disappointed with some of the offerings of the chains, this should be a welcome (and superior) alternative l. This is an excellent breakfast spot, and we will be coming back quite soon.

1st visit with the new owners and I have to say I was impressed. The garlic bagel with Lox was fantastic. The garlic on the bagel wasn't overwhelming and the thick cut Lox was some of the best I've had. No surprise, it's shipped in from New York.....The owner also offered up a sample pork roll and it too was fantastic..........GO EAT HERE......

We arrived to find the bagel shop closed. Online and posted on the door it says they open at 0800 we got there at 0930. No explanation. Never going back.