14" The Rock Meat Lovers
The Meat Lovers Pizza. BKA The Cold Craptastic Choice.
Pepperoni 14"
Picante Piccante Pizza
Small Chili and Cheese Fry Basket
Outside seating, with bar area looking inside the restaurant
Pesto!
Inside - on the right is Larry's sub counter, left is Fired Up Pizza and the bar (zoom in)
I'm eyeing that bar
There's that oven
Watching the Eagles
food, pizza
Love this pizza
Small Chili and Cheese Fry Basket (after we mixed it up, lots of toppings to distribute!)
Food Menu (June 2023)
The Rocks Meat Lovers Pizza
Traditional Pizza, added Italian sausage. It was really good, not too "floppy" like NY pizza sometimes is
Deli & pizza
Food Menu (June 2023)
Drink Menu (June 2023)
Drink Menu (June 2023)
Authentic di Bufala Margherita Pizza
Rustic interior is lovely.
David M.
Nov 21, 2024
Don't let the name or the space shared with a Larry's Subs fool you - the pizza here is outstanding. It can be on the pricy side, with a 14-inch pie running in the neighborhood of $25, give or take a few depending on which you're ordering. But it's super worth it - great thin crust, with outstanding cheese, sauce, and toppings. One large is easily enough for two people to share. Also, do not miss out on the Bushmaster wings - a little spicy, a little sweet, perfectly crispy. We mostly do takeout or DoorDash, but they've got a ton of screens inside the seating area so it's a great place to watch some sports while eating. It's also super loud, so if you bring kids no one will mind. The service is perfunctory but the food comes out fast.
Read MoreKaitlyn S.
Jul 29, 2024
We originally planned to go to Murray Hillbilly, but then found out it was a vegan restaurant. Thankfully Fired Up Pizza and Larry's Giant Subs was right next door! Our server was super friendly. We ordered fried ravioli (soo good!) and then had subs (pizza sub and Italian sub). The restaurant was pretty empty when we arrived, so we got our food quickly. But it was packed by the time we left. Friendly staff. Good food. Cool atmosphere.
Read MoreTony S.
Jan 13, 2025
Ordered a pizza with "light sauce" and went inside to pick up. Bartender asked "whatsup" instead of greeting us like a normal employee. Said here to pick up a pizza and she sent us over to Larry's giant subs. Super weird set-up? The pizza was thin an a slice on bologne and there was absolutely no sauce at all on it. Pizza tasted like cardboard. Would highly recommend Biggies Pizza instead.
Read MoreCami W.
Feb 3, 2024
Authentic di bufala margherita was very boring to my taste. But it's pretty! My friend loves her white pizza and gets it every time. I love all the cheese!
Read MoreBarry B.
Nov 6, 2024
Having lived in Naples Italy for three years and eating pizza all the time there. I can say hands down this is the most authentic Neapolitan pizza I have had anywhere in the States. One bite and my wife and I said this is the real deal.
Read MoreIt's Just M.
Jan 18, 2024
Pizza had an unusual smell for meat lovers, and looked nothing like the image online, taste was not good at all . We actually threw the 14in pizza away after 2 slices, just couldn't make ourselves eat it considering it smelled bad. Wings just lacked flavor, very bland taste threw that away as well. Just wasted 50.00 . No desire to go back. , the staff was friendly maybe because its a shared restaurant with Larrys Giant Sub. I thought it would compare with V's Pizza, but not even close. Possibly comparable to Blaze pizza. Depending what sauce you choose at blaze.
Read MoreQuy M.
Nov 10, 2022
We discovered this restaurant during the Hill-o-Ween event last month. Very lucky we did. I ordered a couple beers that day, and a large pepperoni pizza. Not sure if it was because we haven't eaten all day, but it was off the chain. We decided to come back on Halloween night and dined in. We ordered the large pepperoni pizza again, cheese curd and the Bushmaster wings. The pizza was good, not as good as last time, but still good. I also liked the cheese curd. The Bushmaster wings were absolutely burnt. Not sure if that's how it was suppose to be, but that was a big nope for me. We love us some Larry's sub and haven't gotten to try that yet. Will be back for sure.
Read MoreBruenella W.
Jan 28, 2024
Stopped for a drink b4 the show at the Murray Hill theater as it was the only placed that served alcohol Great choice!Went back after about 10:40 pmThey close at 11pmStill had awesome service & great foodStaff was super friendly We didn't feel rushed & they were in no hurry for us to leaveA+++Will definitely visit againPS the Philly Cheese Steak fries are bomb!
Read MoreLeticia C.
Dec 6, 2023
Pizza and wings are always good! Cocktail was just right, ordered 2. Ive been here multiple times and everything from service and pizza is always good
Read MoreAmanda L.
Jun 30, 2024
Cool atmosphere and delicious pizza! Plenty of parking too. Shared space with Larry's subs so if you are with large party it gives that option too.
Read More