Fantastic Fudge

Great ice cream!! We walked in and we were greeted right away. They were friendly and will let you try the different flavors. Friendly fun cute store!

We come just for a small treat after dinner. It's always busy and so worth the wait! We got coconut clusters and chocolate fudge...it did not disappoint! We enjoyed sitting outside for some people watching too.

My favorite place on Amelia Island to get ice cream is at Fantastic Fudge. Now there's usually a line our the door, but the staff is usually pretty efficient and it moves relatively quickly. I've also only had ice cream from here. I love the Raspberry Haze, but everyone has their own preferences. The rest of my family goes for cookies n cream, cookie dough, butter pecan - and no complaints.

Fantastic Fudge really does have fantastic fudge among many other delicious treats. Hubby is a huge fan of fudge so naturally we had to take a look at the case while we were up in Fernandina.Their rocky road and peanut butter fudge was so good! A few other items that I think are awesome include: milk and dark chocolate pretzels, dark cashews, pecan turtles and chocolate covered Oreos.With the holidays upon us, stop in today for some tasty Christmas gifts!

Busy busy busy. Ice cream with large topping selection. But my favorite was the pecan praline. It just melts in your mouth! The fudge and chocolate selection will leave you wondering which one(s) do I buy because I really want to try them all! Small shop but judge selection. It's always busy but they have enough folks working there to move the line pretty quick.

NOT what it claims. I understand why they don't give out samples: it's not economical in these tough times and if they did, no one would buy it! I think the ingredients are fresh (at least the marshmallows in the rocky road were), but the fudge was hard the next day!I made the mistake of assuming it looked so good, it would taste at least good. I didn't get much of a chocolate flavor and certainly not the taste of nuts. My next mistake was buying it shortly before closing on my way to dinner, so I didn't eat much more than a tiny bit on my way to restaurant...and it wasn't creamy then. The next day, it was hard, grainy, and crumbly. Perhaps that's not a popular flavor and it's been sitting around, but for $10 a slice, I expected more. So disappointing.

We really enjoyed the ice cream here. I had the mocha almond fudge in a waffle cone, and it's definitely high quality ice cream. The single scoops are huge too.There was a long line when we went, but they have a ticket ordering system. Make sure you grab a ticket, because that takes priority over who is ahead in line.

Tried the Cookie Monster icecream today! It had pieces of chocolate chip cookie dough and cookies and cream! The cone was crisp and fresh. They weren't too busy on the weekday in the afternoon, but on weekends - the line can be out the door!

After enjoying a lobster roll, we took a quick walk around and found this delicious shop! All items are marked with allergens. I enjoyed a HUGE scoop of rocky road, in a cup. The smallest scoop was still huge! It tasted fresh, and delicious! Terrific way to top off a delicious meal. Smiling faces, quick service and delicious ice cream-not sure you could ask for more.

Title: A Delightful Experience at Fantastic Fodge in Fernandina BeachRating: Review:I recently had the pleasure of visiting Fantastic Fodge in Fernandina Beach, and I must say, it was an absolute treat for my taste buds! Located in the old historic area, this charming ice cream and fudge shop exceeded all my expectations.The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with warm smiles and friendly faces. Paxton, Andie, and Jacob, the incredible staff members at Fantastic Fodge, went above and beyond in providing exceptional attention and service. Their enthusiasm and knowledge about the ice cream and fudge selections were truly impressive.Now, let's talk about the star of the show--the ice cream and fudge! The flavors available were nothing short of amazing. From classic favorites to unique creations, Fantastic Fodge had something for everyone. Each scoop of ice cream was rich, creamy, and packed with incredible flavors that left me craving for more. The fudge was equally delightful, with a smooth and melt-in-your-mouth texture that was simply divine.What truly sets Fantastic Fodge apart is their commitment to quality. The ingredients used in their ice cream and fudge were clearly top-notch, resulting in a truly memorable and indulgent experience. Whether you're a fan of traditional flavors or feeling adventurous, you won't be disappointed with the options available here.The ambiance of the shop added to the overall experience. The old historic area provided a charming backdrop, and the cozy interior of the shop made it a perfect place to sit back, relax, and enjoy your treats. The attention to detail in the decor created a welcoming and nostalgic atmosphere that added to the enjoyment.In conclusion, Fantastic Fodge in Fernandina Beach is a hidden gem for ice cream and fudge lovers. The outstanding service from Paxton, Andie, and Jacob combined with the delectable flavors make this place a must-visit. Whether you're a local or a tourist exploring the historic area, I highly recommend stopping by Fantastic Fodge for a delightful and unforgettable experience.