Everything Bagel

I've been here 3 times now and it is pretty solid. It's not the best bagels I've ever had but they are pretty good. The egg bagels taste fresh. The BEC bagel are also pretty good. The hamburger bagel was not our favorite. Overall, the bagels are good and taste fresh, but slightly pricey. Would recommend for a quick bagel in St. Augustine.

This place is a cute little bagel shop!! Order at the counter, super nice staff and fast! I ordered an egg, bacon and cheese on an everything bagel, it was fluffy on the inside and toasted nicely on the outside with a generous amount of bacon and two eggs(omelette style) plus a hot coffee to go. Everything was prepared quickly even with the amount of customers in queue!They have other bagels, toppings, and sandwiches, and salad options and will go back to check it out! Also the sign in the window says wifi available but I wasn't staying but good to know for next time!

A Bagel Bliss at Everything Bagel!In St. Augustine's charm, where the mornings are bright,Everything Bagel is a pure delight!With bagels a-plenty, fresh out of the oven,This cozy little spot is a foodie's true haven!Step through the doors for a warm, friendly greet,As the scent of good bagels fills up the street.From plain to Everything, each one's a delight,With toppings galore that make breakfast feel bright!Try their cream cheese, whipped silky and smooth,With flavors that dance, you'll find your groove.Add lox or capers for a brunch so divine,At Everything Bagel, it's always on time!The vibe is so cheerful, with laughter so near,It's a perfect spot to gather with cheer.The staff is so friendly, with smiles that invite,Making your breakfast a pure morning light.Grab a hot coffee to sip as you munch,The perfect companion for your bagel brunch!With cozy seating where you can relax and unwind,This bagel shop is a treasure you'll surely find.So if you're in town and your stomach's on cue,Head to Everything Bagel--you'll love every crew!With whimsical flavors and joy on each plate,This delightful bakery is simply first-rate!So gather your friends, make it a special day,At Everything Bagel, where dreams come to play!In the heart of St. Augustine, come enjoy the bliss,Every bite is a joy you truly won't miss!

Pretty disappointed with everything bagel and definitely won't be returning. We used to frequent them a couple times a week as we live close by. It seemed to change hands and slowly the quality of the food went down. We went yesterday for a dozens of bagels and a 1lb of cream cheese. The total was $40+ (not sure if they were price gouging due to the storm or this is their norm)?! nearly double of other local places like joint bagel. The bagels were raw even after toasting, we had to put them in the oven. The girl filling our order was very nice but a woman with glasses next to her overseeing was completely rude. With places like joint bagel, half the price, way better quality and great customer service, we will take the long drive.

The bagel maker who has been there years lied to me after waiting a half hour when I confronted him on the egg he used . I was ripped off bad ! This is not a scrambled egg liar !

Had a very short window of time before I had to pick someone up, so I checked to see what wasn't too far away and to my surprise, Everything Bagel came up (hooray)!I knew exactly what I'd be getting: an everything bagel with veggie cream cheese, a plain bagel to go for my kiddo. What I didn't know was that they also sold cannolis and macarons!That being said, I stopped in, made my order, plus added a cannoli and got everything to go.The store has had some updates since I was last in (new signage, and some updated decor inside, which was def.a plus). This place reminds me of a NY deli, they have everything from bagels with a schmear to bagel sandwiches.My order was ready in just a few minutes. When I got back to the parking lot where I had to pick someone up, I dug into my bagel with cream cheese. They def know how to make a bagel with schmear. There was a TON of cream cheese and you could tell the veggie cream cheese was chock full. The cream cheese was flavorful, creamy, and piled high!I haven't dug into the cannoli (YET), but super excited to.Pros:-Variety of homemade bagels-Homemade veggie cream cheese-Thick bagels-Flavor is deliciousCons:-NoneTips: Parking is ample and super close to a few other gems in the area.

Dare I say best bagel shop in Florida? Hard to beat portion sizes and truly customizable options. Can't recommend more

I used to work in the plaza next door to Everything Bagel and would get bagels or BEC or lunch sandwiches alllllll the time from here and it was amazing food, service, staff, and with great prices. All of my coworkers loved Everything Bagel, we would rotate who would be buying lunch that weekend. Since being back in the area, I heard they have changed ownership within the past 2 years. I recently went there twice in the last 3 months, the prices have drastically increased but without the same quality food. Honestly, the food isn't the same quality (especially the BEC- no flavor and not enough egg to bacon ratio), the bagels aren't as "fluffy" and fresh. The staff is't as nice, or helpful either. Clearly something has changed and I might find another bagel place in the area.

We randomly chose Everything Bagel based off of proximity to our condo and previous yelp reviews. We ordered a dozen bagels and have enjoyed all of the different flavors we picked. The lady working was provided excellent service to us and was patient as we chose from the different flavors and selected our flavored cream cheese. The inside was a nice and clean as well.

Just moved to the area. Thought I give the local bagel shop a chance. Man that microwaved egg and bacon made me want to pack my crap and move back home. Nice people though!!