Catullo’s Italian

First time at the new location and blown away by the consistency. Beyond impressed that that the same level of food quality and service is upheld. To those fools complaining about the service being too good, I suggest you go to a chain restaurant. Really, what is wrong with you! Also, being upset that liquor isn't served is a non complaint. Maybe take a long hard look in the mirror and ask yourself why you need hard alcohol to enjoy amazing pasta. Will definitely be back for the most delicious homemade pasta dishes in town, excellent service and fantastic wine pairings.

Good Italian place. There is no ambiance. Does not compare to the original one on San Pablo rd in Jacksonville. Service was fine

Came here on a Friday around 5:30pm and I was so glad they were not busy so we were seated right away. Having visited their other location and reviewed the menu beforehand, we knew exactly what we wanted to order--thankfully, because the lighting inside was so dim that reading the menu felt like a challenge without using the flashlight on our phones! LOL! Here's what we tried:Ma's Bruschetta- definitely different from other bruschetta that I have tried. They used crostinis but I would prefer a softer baguette. The toppings were also served too cold for my taste. This was just okay for me. I still prefer the traditional version.Coda Alla Vaccinara - This was the special for the night: oxtail braised for 12 hours. The dish was incredibly flavorful, and the meat portion was generous. I like my pasta al dente but the treccione pasta that came with it was a bit thick and hard to chew. I would substitute it with pappardelle next time. Sunday Suppa - the meatballs were amazing and the pappardelle pasta was cooked perfectly! My husband and I enjoyed this! For dessert, we tried the Ricotta Pistachio Cake, which was light and not overly sweet--perfectly complemented by a cappuccino and espresso.Overall, we had a great experience and will definitely return. My only wish is that they could take reservations for larger groups

Great food, great service! The lasagna may be the best lasagna I've ever had a restaurant. Jimmy was our waiter and the entire staff assisted. Easy 5 stars!

Great spot for Italian! Amazing menu with some creative options. Ask about the specials because they are usually delicious. Service is always very attentive. Jimmy was fantastic tonight! Tables are quite close so you'll likely get to know your neighbors. Not a ton of space for larger parties so you may want to call ahead if needed. Everything we ordered tonight was fabulous!

Delicious food love the scallop risotto and the service. Have been here a couple times and they also do a great job of your celebrating someone's birthday and bring everyone champagne.

Another five star experience at Catullo's! The staff here is like no other and have become like family. Chris at the bar always takes great care of us and Joey as well when we sit in the main dining area. My husband and I went tonight with a friend visiting from south Florida and had a lovely experience. I had the scallop risotto, my husband got the pear fiocchi and our friend got the special which was ox tail. All phenomenal! The dessert special was the peppermint cheesecake and it was truly the best dessert I've ever had. They recently redecorated and the wallpaper and new additions really jazzed the place up. The staff is exceptional and truly goes above and beyond for their customers each visit. Love Catullos!

Delicious Italian, homey and comfortable vibe, family-owned. This is one of my favorite kinds of restaurants and we have loved supporting them as they opened their Nocatee location.Service has always been excellent for us - at both locations. We are checked in on multiple times and never are left waiting or wanting. Everyone is friendly and takes good care of you and your party.No reservations, so be prepared to wait in line depending on what time you arrive. We have been lucky the last few times and were able to squeeze in at the bar (for just two of us) or had a very short wait for a party of 4. No matter what, it's worth the wait and who knows, maybe you'll get lucky, too!The food is super fresh and it feels like Nonna is cooking these excellent dishes with a modern twist. The pear fiocci is one of my all-time faves -- something different and special and just oh-so-good. We love the arancini for an appetizer, plus the fresh bread, of course. I always like to try their specials! I have been impressed pretty much every time and it gives me the chance to try something new. The duck ragu I had last week was outrageous. I ate almost the entire thing and it is not a small dish! I have no shame :)The cannoli is perfection. Crunchy. Sweet. Fully loaded. Extra pistachios and just great flavor. There have been a few dessert specials we tried and the toasted almond cream cake was probably my #1. Grab a coffee, get a glass of wine, and eat all of the amazing things. Just trust me.

First visit at the new location and it's almost exactly like the one on San Pablo. Not a huge place and the lighting is horrible for taking pics. LOL.The food is as scrumptious and the service is as fantastic as the original too tho :)The place is cozy, not great for a big group. Table of 6 is ok, 7 or more...you'll be waiting a bit unless you're first in line.

Just tried Catullo's for the first time. Great Food and Service.I had the arancini appetizer and the ravioli with Catullo's special sauce and both were excellent. I will be back.