Chipotle Maya
Fajitas
Woodchuck Hard Cider and Modelo
Tequila Esperanto Blanco
Chicken Quesadilla
Octopus Ceviche. Pink lemonade.
a table full of tacos and drinks
a table full of tacos and drinks
Key Lime Pie.
Guacamole
paella, food
The Botanist
Outside seating and live music
Great strong drinks.
Cava
Ceviche
The outside bar
salads, salad, food
Margarita
Bathroom decorations
Yummy drinks!
Lee D.
Jan 18, 2025
This place is a solid option when dining in St Augustine. It was a busy Saturday in the city and we were quickly taken to a table on the heated patio. Our drinks weee good. I had a mezcalaruta. Good flavor and fresh ingredients. For dinner I had the barbacoa which was lamb based. It was adequate. The meat tasted tough but the plantains were excellent. Our service was slow but it was a nice night. We were between music sets. It seems they need to improve the time between acts. Would be nice to hear music at 5:30.
Read More
TJ K.
Jan 1, 2025
The tacos are excellent! Had soft corn tacos with carnitas and mahi mahi. They were as good as I remember.The service was good, but the place could use some sprucing up.
Read More
Conrad B.
Nov 9, 2024
Election Day 2024!Stopped by for a lite bite instead of a big lunch, so we ordered Ceviche. I had a glass of Sauvignon Blanc while my wife had to settle for a seltzer since she was on meds.Have to say, I can't complain, the Ceviche (with chips) was very good, as was the wine and the service. I'd be happy to stop in again anytime.
Read More
Jen C.
Feb 22, 2025
Went for lunch and ordered the Apocalypto Breakfast Torta. The baked bread really made this sandwich top notch. The flavors all meshed really well together. Especially loved the guacamole and bacon. They also had a habanero hot sauce that gave it that extra kick I needed as I love spicy food. Sat in their outdoor seating which also had heating lamps. They were supposed to have a live performer but it never happened. Good ambiance and good food.
Read More
Ed D.
Sep 26, 2024
Atmosphere is good. Had some live music during our meal. The food is ok not bad not spectacular.Unfortunately, my meal wasn't very good. They had some spoiled or rotten crab legs that was part of the dish. After eating one leg I complained thinking it was raw.The waiter brought me some new crab legs and said someone else had just said the same thing.So I tried the new ones. I immediately spit it out. The waiter said they were taking them off the menu as they were bad. They reduced the cost of my meal. Appreciate that but I'm surprised they didn't just comp it. Prices are overpriced for the food you get.I don't see me returning there.
Read More
Robbie C.
Sep 8, 2024
We had a nice lunch at Casa Maya. We sat inside upstairs because of the heat and had the place pretty much to ourselves. The old historic house was cozy and felt authentically St. Augustine. For drinks we got a couple sangrias and beers. Wish the beer menu was a little bigger but they did have a few seasonal rotations. The cocktails were good and not too sweet.We got the tacos and the carne asada. All the food was great and came out relatively quick. Initially I was worried that the tacos wouldn't be enough food but you get three stuffed tacos and beans and rice. Was plenty of food even if it was a little overpriced considering the quality.Our server was attentive even though we were his only table upstairs for most of the meal. The only negatives with the experience were the higher prices than what you might expect given the food and location and the auto gratuity. The gratuity was added and buried in the receipt with the part you sign only showing the final price. Nowhere was it mentioned that gratuity would be included and we almost double tipped because it wasn't apparent it was added. That part kind of turned us off what was otherwise a really nice meal. Even still, we will likely return and look forward to sitting out on the balcony when the weather is a little cooler.
Read More
Wendy B.
Mar 26, 2024
Delicious margaritas, but the oysters were not separated. We sat outside on a gorgeous day and just had these 2 items. For the cost they charge they could separate the oysters from the bottom shell.We sat at the outside bar and were immediately greeted by the bartender and our drinks were served pretty quick.
Read More
Megan M.
Aug 9, 2024
We arrived at Casa Maya around 5:30 and got seated immediately inside to avoid the heat. The upstairs was nice and spacious with its own bathroom. We ordered the chips, salsa and guac right away and it was so good & fresh! You may have to ask for some extra chips. We got the shrimp and steak tacos, they were loaded with steak! The shrimp tasted excellent with the chipotle mayo sauce. We got the Chicken Quesadilla and it was very good, you can't tell the tortilla is spinach, and it was full of chicken.
Read More
Prerana C.
Sep 16, 2024
The food and drinks were not bad, maybe would dine in just for the live music and a couple of drinks. We got the chip and salsa and queso, Barbacoa and the Fajitas. It was Saturday night, and a lot of miscommunication, we asked for more salsa and only got more orders of the chips and salsa. The 5 of us ended up having 3 orders of chips and salsa and 3 orders of chips and queso.
Read More
Alexis A.
Jul 9, 2024
We were a walk in party of 12 people and sat upstairs right away! The waiter was honestly one of the nicest waiters I have met, very attentive and honest in his feedback on drinks and food! The hangover breakfast was the perfect pick me up for our brunch with the chorizo and steak tasting delicious!! Anyone visiting st Augustine must come here!
Read More