June 12, 2024
Calamari - July 31, 2024
Carmelo's Supreme Pizza DELICIOUS - June 12, 2024
Calamari - July 31, 2024
May 2023
Comforting Spaghetti & Meatballs, Carmelo's Supreme, Calamari and Kids Cheese Pizza. #supportlocal @ Carmelo's-St. Augustine.
Comforting Spaghetti and Meatballs, Carmelo's Supreme Pizza, Calamari and Kids Cheese Pizza @ Carmelo's Pizzeria-St. Augustine.
Always aヽ(*‿*)ノGREAT experience @ Carmelo's Pizzeria-St. Augustine. Thank you Haylee! Highly recommend if you are in the area!
February 10, 2024
Spaghetti and Meatballs DELICIOUS - June 12, 2024
Italian Style Jumbo Wings
Excellent weekly specials! L*‿*VE their Eggplant Parmigiana, Spaghetti and Meatballs, Calamari and Carmelo Supreme.
Wednesday Special - June 12, 2024
Homemade Meat Lasagna...so COMFORTING on this beautiful afternoon. #supportlocal @ #Carmelo's-St. Augustine
Excellent dining experience and highly recommend! Thank (・‿・) you McKenzie!
7/3
pizza, food
February 10, 2024
If you ENJ(*‿*)Y black olives, mushrooms, onions, pepperoni and sausage, highly recommend Carmelo's Supreme.
New York Style Thin Crust Fresh from the Oven DELICIOUS - March 3, 2024
Ancient City Matanzas Red Ale. Warning: 24 oz mug is harder to balance as it gets empty. I bet this mug weighed 20+ ounces before the beer.
Garlic Knots
Spaghetti and Meatballs DELICIOUS - May 2023
pizza
Rich G.
Nov 6, 2024
Lunch at Carmelo's. Great service and good food. We got a small Carmelo's special- perfectly baked. Nice crust with plenty of toppings and cheese. They are replacing their gas tanks so the parking lot will have some construction. Pumps are closed but the store and restaurant are open. Great pizza. Worth a visit.
Read More
Sharon M.
Apr 12, 2024
Good option if you just need a quick bite. There's two separate seating areas: the counter-service side has a couple tables in the convenience-store side of gas station. The other section is a few steps down a short hallway and includes a bar, tables and booths with indoor and some outdoor seating too. We initially walked into this side but moved over to the convenience side after we realized we could grab a few slices right away and be on our way. Attached to a Shell gas station at the corner of King St and Malaga St. Parking can be hit or miss..
Read More
Laur R.
Nov 24, 2024
This is my fave pizza place in st Augustine. I don't get to go very often, but if anyone asks me where to get a slice here that's my recommendation. The sauce is perfectionz
Read More
Francine C.
Jan 31, 2025
Food is amazing, love their pepperoni pizza for kids and their coconut cake is great .too bad they don't offer it on their Yelp menu
Read More
Dana J.
Nov 8, 2024
The best Italian pizza around. They serve other things but really, if you're looking for a good pizza like what you can get up north, this is the closest. Being inside isn't much to look at but just get the pizza to go if the ambiance isn't up to your standards.
Read More
Nate K.
Jul 15, 2024
This place has really good pizza, and I didn't see it coming.Don't judge the gas station location, looks can be deceiving. The pizza is very high quality and they went above and beyond by giving me a large cup of marinara sauce for dipping.The marinara sauce had chunks of tomato and onion, it was obviously freshly made and delicious. Friendly service, they have italian herbs, crushed red pepper, and parm cheese on the tables. I'll definitely be back and wish them nothing but the best. This place attached to a gas station has MUCH BETTER pizzas than even some sit down restaurants.
Read More
Jana P.
May 16, 2024
I had to take a friend to St Augustine for a simple procedure and while under her anesthesia she rambled on about a Stromboli so I went to my ol reliable source of google and found this place. Let me tell you the reviews speak for themselves!!! The pizza AMAZING I had a calzone and it was one of the best I have ever had!!!! The staff was super helpful and attentive!!! And for it to be a joined to a gas station was really cool vibes!!! I will be going back!!!!
Read More
gloria m.
Feb 19, 2025
Great NY style foldable pizza! Small cozy venue. Good prices and very good pizza! Service is friendly and very efficient.
Read More
Lou D.
Jan 24, 2025
I ordered lasagna and the peanut butter pie. Both were outstanding! Delicious, generous portions and reasonably priced. I'll return when I'm back in Saint Augustine for sure. Cheers to the chef and friendly staff!
Read More
Cecelia H.
Feb 14, 2025
Our go to; best pizza in St Augustine! We do counter service, then eat out on the patio!
Read More