Veggie Lovers
Pizza with extra cheese???
Italian sub.
Lunch special plus 3 garlic knots
two slices of pizza on a plate
Matzah pizza
So fresh!!!! Pepperoni & Cheese slices!
Meat lovers pizza
Coffee soda?!
Pepperoni pizza
Garlic knots
Pepperoni pizza
Pizza
Cheese pizza
food, pizza
Brooklyn
pizza, food
Inside
interior
pizza, food
outside
We always go for the Cheese! It's perfect NY style pie!
Fresh filled cannoli in regular, chocolates and pastacio
Pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms very greasy but very good!
Jaima M.
Oct 31, 2024
Great New York style pizza. Family owned is cute stop for a slice and special sodas. Service is super and efficient. Our steady shop for pizza that's good.
Read More
Jeremy M.
Nov 22, 2024
Eh. Medium pepperoni only had 2 pepperonis per slice. Ton of flour on bottom made it almost sandy. Cheese was dark and crispy which I like. Crust thin. Just seems rushed and skimpy. Mozzarella sticks were good. Crunchy and hot even Togo.
Read More
Gregg K.
Jan 21, 2025
We've had there pizza before and it was really good. Decided to try a stromboli and a Italian sub. Had it delivered. The stromboli was small but wife said it was ok. The sub was terrible. Not a lot of meat. Hardly any lettuce, and very soggy. Very disappointed. With prices the way they are felt like we wasted $35.00.
Read More
Ken B.
Dec 14, 2024
No comment Manischewitz Matzah cost $4.09 at;Publix this "pie" cost $16.50 at Brooklyn Pizza Bartram Park
Read More
Athena B.
Dec 28, 2023
I needed a quick spot for lunch with my daughter. We drive by Brooklyn Pizza every day and I've always wanted to try it! We did the 2 slides & drink special for $6.99. It was fantastic! I had the pepperoni and my daughter had the cheese. Both were perfect with a nice thin crust! Absolutely will return for more pizza!
Read More
Monica C.
Aug 22, 2024
All I got was the slice combo (cheese). Wasn't expecting it to be so great. Perfect amount of cheese - and the sauce was tasty (not like the battery acid other places serve). But the real star was the crust. Wasn't soaky and had a great flavor. I'm definitely going back!
Read More
Connor M.
Jul 22, 2024
First of all this is the best pizza to get in north east Florida. Second of all it's a crime to say anything negative about their traditional cheese or pepperoni. The only reason for someone to not think this is not an 8 out of 10 is because they're used to bad florida pizza. Inside feels like a real ny pizza spot. Service is great and they'll keep the pizza warm for you. I don't have a picture review but I recently saw their review on the one bite app and it's criminally underrated.
Read More
Carol R.
Feb 14, 2025
Stromboli tasty - service was good- ambiance okYes I would and I do continue to order from Brooklyn Pizza- the employees are always very kind
Read More
Ralph D.
Jan 27, 2025
Pizza was undercooked. Felt like I was eating raw dough. Unfortunately I got the pizza to go, so there was no recourse having it re-cooked.
Read More
Gene H.
Nov 8, 2024
Exactly what I was looking for! Thin, crispy crust with generous toppings!!2 large slices and a drink for 6.99.
Read More