Brooklyn Boys

Only been twice and the food has been very good both times. First visit they had smoked and then flavored chicken wings which were excellent. A month later the waitress informed me they are no longer smoked. Disappointed about this since I liked to get the smoked chicken wings and antipasto salad. I'll still be back to try their other food. Service is somewhat slow do to how busy they generally are. Don't expect to come in and out in 30 minutes. Atmosphere is relaxed and light. Overall great little place in Keystone Heights.

I'm incredibly disappointed in the service provided by the restaurant tonight. The waitress was fine, but they literally closed down around us, turning off the games in tv, mopping and stacking chairs as we were trying to enjoy our food. Whoever came to speak with us was rude. We would've never come in at 8 pm except the website stated that they close at 9:00. Fortunately, I don't live in Keystone, where there are literally three restaurants to choose from. However, the family we were here visiting does- as does their large extended family, and they won't be back. What a shame. The food was good, but the attitude of everyone who worked there was absolutely atrocious. If I could give less than a one star I would!

Been in KH for a year and finally have this place a shot. Decor is defo as described by others as Politically Incorrect, but I don't base my food options on politics, so not bothered. Mama and I both had a stromboli, hers was steak and mine was the Garbage. Both were good, but the garlic knots were the real star. Swimming in garlic butter, hit and fresh, and super tasty. They come with marinara but you don't really need it. Service was passable, with nothing to set it apart or give me a reason to complain. They also charge a fee for all card transactions, so just be aware.

This restaurant came recommended by a friend in the area. I was surprised by the looks of it. You would think that it isn't an Italian restaurant, but when you eat the food. It's simply amazing. My wife always judges an Italian restaurant by its sauce. And she loved it. So we knew the food was going to be great. We had a really good talk with the stepson of the owner as he was our server, and we learned a little bit about the restaurant . supporting local business is important. Are food came out hot tasty, with more of the tasty sauce for dipping. I know next month. Where will we take a large party to this restaurant after our event. If you're in the keys, don't area or passing through. It's definitely worth a stop. They've got some really cool signage inside and out

fed 5 adults & 2 littles pizza, sub, wings, stromboli, and beverages outdoor dining perfect for these FL wannabees :)

Pretty good ! We ate that all up so fast. Great flavors. Food came out hot and fast. Every time we finished one dish the next just about came out right after. Not pictured are the medium wings. Could've been a bit saucier but the ranch was good.

The online reviews said this was the best pizza in town. If this is true, Keystone Heights has a problem. The Domino's had better pizza, even though it received a worse overall review. We ordered a pizza to-go; 1/2 pepperoni and onion and ham and mushrooms on the other 1/2. The pepperoni and onion 1/2 was ok, but the pepperoni used was very spicy/hot, which was not to my liking. The onion was stringy and seemed like there was onion skins in the mix. The other 1/2 was terrible! The ham and mushroom side looked like the had dumped Spam on it. The toppings were not recognizable, because it was very finely chopped up. My husband said it was the worst pizza he'd ever had, and we've traveled the world, getting pizza in every county. Needless to say, we will not return.

Waitress seemed annoyed we came in an hour before they closed and didn't even greet us. Just grumbled under her breath. Bar tender came and took our order but at that point it was kind of awkward. Pizza was just ok. Wings at the table next to us looked legit...wish we would have ordered that instead.

Food was good. Had Stromboli. Kudos to cooks. Greek salad came late. Never ate it so can't review. Looked like a standard Greek so I'm sure it was fine. Group of 8 of us. No complaints from anyone regarding food. Waitress was new. Very sweet but obvious she was new. Despite our experience, we tipped her 20%. If future of this place has anything to do with service & attitude, don't expect it stay open for more than a year. Can't imagine people in that community putting up with it no matter how good the food is. Bartender was very rude. Some other guy working in there was a jerk as well. Spoke to manager & he could less if we were happy or not. Based on actions of employees, can't help but think owner must be similar or they wouldn't act like that. Bottom line is this- We don't live there. Might visit once a year. The other 6 people who we were with do actually live in that community. They've eaten there numerous times. Said food was usually good, but service was usually bad. According to them, this was worse ever treated. They won't be back. Avoid this place.

Atmosphere is pretty plain and our waitress was brand new but had a great attitude and worked hard to make up for her lack of experience but... went in with a party of twenty (they don't take reservations) and they seated us and got us drinks and everything came out on time and together. We all stayed with Italian even though they had sushi and Mexican etc etc. food was great! I rate places for what they are trying to be and not against other places of different categories so this is a great 5 star local small town Italian restaurant. Great food and service !