Antonio's Pizza And Italian

We are visiting from Granger, Indiana and asked are friends who live in Fort McCoy where we could get good pizza. Several of their neighbors recommended Antonio's. It did not disappoint! The hubby is a bit of a New Haven, CT pizza connoisseur. The 3 guys in our group had the 16" Supreme pizza. It was basically a meat combo. I tried some of the meatball from it and it was a perfect meatball. The fork slides right through it kinda meatball. So goood! My bestie and I shared a 12" Eggplant pizza because it was such an unusual offering we just had to try it. The Eggplant was cut in rounds and breaded, then added to the pizza. This is the best thing ever. I'm feeling inspired now to try to make my own fried green tomato pizza. I never would have implemented Eggplant on a pizza. Ingenius!

First time ordering from Antonio's NY Pizza as a take out and oh my, a super large delicious Supreme Pizza amazing and crust thickness was perfect. Will dFrequent this business when we want a far out pizza. Thanks again

Did pizza delivery in Palatka...super good Supreme (I.e. meaty good!) and Vegetarian Supreme (even better than its meaty counterpart!). Good sauce and crust! Ample toppings on both!

Antonio's New York Style pizza was decent at best. My pizza came a little bit over cooked. The pizza was very cheesy, sauce was average, but the dough was probably the highlight of the pizza Cheese: 7Sauce: 7Dough: 7.5

I'm new to the area and have been looking for a legit NY pizza joint. Well I certainly found it! The regular pizzas are fantastic but there is creative alternatives like the "shrimp alfredo" pizza which was fantastic. I also got the baked shells which didn't last the night. I look forward to trying the meat lasagna and the calzones and the tiramisu in the fridge! This place is legit, call because they deliver locally and they were even spectacular at that. The delivery made it a little pricy. But these days, good delivery pizza is worth paying a bit extra for. They took every minute of their estimated 30-45 minutes but she was lovely. I'm pretty stoked to to be settling into my new house and already have "my pizza joint" dialed in. Looking forward to eventually visiting in person! Thanks guys.

So glad we stopped in. The pizza was outstanding, natural, crispy. Very comfy place to visit.

This is a delicious 5 star pizza joint! The main chef is from near Greece and really knows how to make pizza! The extra large is big enough for 2-4 people. You will love this pizza! One of my favorites for Florida. It is ever bit as good as Niko's in Palatka. This place is a real treat!!! Way more flavorful than Pizza Boyz. They are usually very busy so make sure to call in your order first so you have a time frame.

Food was great. There were 4 of us. 2 shared a small pizza, 1 had the baked ziti, and 1 had the hot ham and cheese! All very good. Service was great. Plenty of room to sit and enjoy our lunch.

Best New York style pizza in Palatka and surrounding area everyone should try Antonio's pizza

Refused to refund raw wet chicken and old pizza with some fresh cheese thrown on top