Selma's Chicago Pizzeria & Tap Room

Ok, this time we are sitting in the restaurant as I write this. We got a table in the dining room. I go to the bar to grab a beer. There's 2 customers sitting at the bar. The bartender is just talking to a customer at the bar. Once I stand at the bar and he looks at me he walks by, grabs dirty dishes and puts them where they go. Then goes to the computer then grabs some wine from the cooler and pours those. Sets them out for a server. Then walks past me again and does something, then comes back by again and pours more wine. Never once even acknowledging I'm there. I waited a few minutes then just walked out of the bar. Go back to dining room where my family is and no server yet. There's only 6 tables of customers. 4 tables in the carpeted area (where we are), and I believe 2 tables in the other portion. We waited at least ten minutes before a server came over, even though numerous employees have been walking around and even gone to the table next to us. I will say, as most employees here, she is nice. Regarding the bar, for those that wonder why I don't order a beer from the table, i used to, however it has always taken forever to get that beer. When I would originally get a beer from the table server it would take forever which is too bad because there's been plenty of times I would have gotten a second beer, but knowing it would take so long and having to wait forever for a server, there's no time.Update: the server asked if we wanted salads to come out before the food, we said yes. About 20 minutes later someone brings our pizza out. lol. So it took 20 min or less to make which explains why the bottom crust was not fully cooked and goes against what the owner of Selma's had once replied which is it takes a bit longer than 20 minutes to make and cook one pizza. We have no plates. We ask for plates. She's says sure. Minutes later she comes back with another one of our food items and no plates. lol. Then the salads come out. On top of that one of the salads was completely incorrect. When server asked about the food we did let her know about the salad simply to let them know they are screwing up, no need to remake it. The server stated she didn't get to see the food before it came out. Well here I am again pointing out the clear issues here. No quality control whatsoever. Cooks are running the show here, management and owners completely aloof which explains the mess that is Selma's in RSM

Inconsistent quality for the same pizza. I have ordered 3 times now and every time it's a surprise and not a positive one. One time the pizzas were too salty, the other time it had thyme added to a pizza that usually does not have it and one time the pizzas were just burnt. Service is friendly but at the same times quality control is horrible. How do you allow burnt pizzas to leave the premises? The price is costly so expect the food to be of high quality. At this point, I don't know if I will give them another chance.

Took the family to the Rancho Santa Margarita location on a Tuesday night. Had to wait to be seated at a nearly empty restaurant by the host that seemed a little inexperienced at her job. After being seated, our server was very friendly and informative. We ordered the first round of different beers (which was delicious) also ordered the sampler. The best was the wings. Probably one of the best wings I had ever. So nicely marinated and seasoned. The pizza pie was also very delicious and full of hearty flavors. The chicken salad was another item that was unexpectedly delicious. Overall a great place with excellent food with a decent amount of beer selection. I would definitely recommend this place and will be back again.

This pizza joint is located in a big plaza along with several other food places and a Lowe's. Lots of parking. They have a small patio and the interior is partitioned with a bar on one side and the dining area on the other with one side of the dining space having tables and the other booths. I arrived solo for an early dinner while they were still having happy hour prices. They are known for their deep dish pizza so I ordered a small one with pepperoni and black olives added to the cheese and tomato. Aside from a tall glass of water I also chose a glass of a red blend Kendall-Jackson wine. As an aside for any wine novices, I personally have found that vintner to consistently produce a decent, middle-of-the-road wine that family restaurants often have on their menu; you can't go wrong with that label.Deep dish is thick and takes a little longer to prepare but the wine kept me busy. Once the pie arrived, a slice was placed on my plate for me (the small size has four pieces total). The crust had the perfect crunch and I absolutely loved this pizza. With one slice left my attentive waitress brought a to-go box to my table but I waved her off; I ate the whole thing. It'd been a long time since I had deep dish pizza and it was a pleasure to devour.

Great pizza and beer! Highly recommended. Service is always excellent and food is cooked to perfection! This place is close to my work so I eat here a lot! Love it!

Always a favorite and just why the service can make a big difference the success of the business. The service is always friendly, they recognize me, know my orders, and this last time I visited even made a new suggestion for the pesto pasta and my goodness was it delicious. my server recommended that a little feta cheese on top and she was spot on. This is a great place.

This place was really good. We are picky with our pizza and theirs is pretty good. We had a few other items and allWere delicious. The thing my husband loved most is that they had a selection of the beers he likes. He's a wheat beer guy but doesn't care for the typical Shock Top or Blue moon that everyone carries. When they have German beers, it's a place we tend to frequent. The service was really good and we left talking about when we'd be returning. It's a little bit of a drive but we'd go return because we had such a good experience.

Love LOVE LOVE this place. Came here a Sunday for brunch and got the bottomless mimosas and the Di Vinny pizza. We got the pizza deep dish style and the wait was definitely worth it. The mimosas were also very good! 10/10 would come back. I'm only taking a star off because service seemed to be really slow. It took our server about 15 minutes to just take our order.

Great pizza, deep dish every time! Lots of selections, always good.Nice and quiet atmosphere.Good service.

Pizza is good, and they have a great beer selection In tap. They always have a Russian River beer on tap too!**If you want the best service at the bar, go on a night when Zack works. He's extremely helpful, and always polite**. My wife and I always enjoy a bartender that cares - Zack is your guy!