Burtucci's New York Pizza
Burtucci's New York Pizza
food
pizza, food
Best Pizza in Huntington Beach!
interior
My personal pizza for pi day!
Specials a few months ago
a hand holding a piece of pizza
The pizza guy that day
outside
interior
From the outside
interior
Jalapeño poppers false advertisement
Just wave your card over the machine. No touch payment
Jalapeño poppers false advertisement
Philly Cheese Steak
Mediterranean Pizza
interior
The slice that would not budge.
Slice of the Greek
Meatlovers. One of their many speciality pizzas
Ken H.
Jan 10, 2025
A decent place to feed anyone's greasy needs. I was early for a first date at a coffee place nearby; I saw Burtucci's; I thought I am mostly of Italian descent, why not?I ran to the counter and said: "Pepperoni and cheese me, please. One slice is all I've time for." The clerk behind the counter made his way to the pepperoni pizza & then the real trouble started. The kid did not know how to effectively use a pizza cutter, a knife, or his hands to free the slice I had ordered. He ran the cutter over the section of pizza too quickly and feebly. The pizza slice remained linked to the main pie by strands of crust and cheese. The lad began to sigh, grunt, and lament as the slice thwarted his every effort to pry it free. At one point he cried: "Ay-ay-ay-ay-ayyyy." He even offered to get me another slice, and I was far too amused to say anything other than: "No you got this." The struggle continued when he made a last ditch effort to separate the slice out by hand. He ultimately cut the piece free with a cleaver, but it took some doing.The pizza was a surprise party of grease. More than I expected. Grease popped out of every corner of this pizza & shouted at the roof of my mouth. Fortunately, I welcome grease if enough cheese is around. I finished this slice in seconds. There might be chairs in Burtucci's, but I never wanted to take time away from my slice to sit down.The pepperoni pizza at Burtucci's put me in the right satisfied frame of my mind for this first coffee date. I felt relaxed but not stuffed or overloaded. Long story short: I got a second date. Now if I can only find a way to get another slice of Burtucci's...
Read More
francine l.
Dec 28, 2024
I was tasked with ordering food for the funeral reception of the father of my brother-in-law. Someone in the family mentioned Burtucci's due to its proximity to the reception location. It was very helpful to have the catering menu with prices online, because I was able to gauge what we would like to order and about how many people each tray would feed. I called and spoke with Angelique, who was very kind, very compassionate in offering her condolences, and very helpful in answering my questions and taking our large catering order. It was a great first interaction. The day before pick up, the owner called to let us know its best to bring an SUV since there would be many hot trays. He also let my brother-in-law know he would take good care of us and ensure to pack each tray with a LOT of food. It was a nice touch from a small business owner, to show his appreciation for new customers.Yesterday was the day of pick up. He had us park in the back as he reserved 2 spots for us, for easy loading of the food. I did not get his name but he mentioned he was the owner and ensured he packed everything with care. My husband was very hungry and the owner gave him a free pizza slice hot off the press. I had a few bites, and it was heavenly! My BIL's father would have loved it: melty high-quality cheese, delicate pizza sauce, tasty pepperoni, and a soft inner/crispy outer crust. The owner was very personable, friendly, and compassionate as well as he offered his condolences to us. He packed up our SUV, and the other car as well. My BIL mentioned he threw in a few extras for us, which was so very generous of him.Once we got to the house, the guests descended upon the food and everyone raved about how delicious everything was. Here is a list of what we ordered:House SaladCaesar SaladChicken AlfredoSpaghetti w/ MeatballsMediterranean Chicken10 Pizzas - Supreme, Cheese, PepperoniJumbo CannolisCheesecakesTiramisuChocolate Chip CookiesEverything was so so good! The salads were fresh with no wilting, dressings were perfectly balanced with not too much acidity or oil. The pastas were perfect as the noodles were not over cooked and not drenched in sauce. Presentation was nice and felt upscale. The pizzas were the first to go, so that's all i'll say about that! I will say, the spaghetti w/ meatballs was a fan favorite. There was something about it that was so tasty and elevated the flavors. Many guests loved the cheesecake and the tiramisu recieved rave reviews. I actually have a party i'm hosting in mid-January and now I know who to use for catering! Thanks, Burtucci's, for making this experience seamless - from ordering all the way to pick up. My brother-in-law's father was near and dear to us, and he truly appreciated good quality food. We know he would have approved of Burtucci's for sure.
Read More
Tiffany H.
Oct 26, 2024
I'm always excited to see Ny Pizzeria's in Cali however, this one was a big miss. The crust had zero flavoring and was semi, not done. Crust, makes the entire pizza and this was more like a cracker that had not been fully cooked. I've yet to have a bad "Alfredo" sauces pizza and this was was full of ricotta cheese and little to no Alfredo. The pizza just lacked flavor. Also, they told me 20 minutes and the pizza wasn't done for 35 and still needed to cook a bit longer. The meat lovers pizza was okay. Again, the crust lacks flavor and that really Ny pizza grease, fold, and flavor. The plus was the customer service, the set up of the pizzeria, and the Dodger game was playing during the World Series, on mute though. I would not come again.
Read More
Krista W.
Mar 2, 2025
This place sucks. I have given them SO many chances because the food is actually good, last time they took over 2 HOURS when I ordered a pizza they said would take 30 minutes and today they forgot my salad dressing on a postmates order. Never again
Read More
Kent D.
Sep 24, 2024
Took advantage of a Bogo deal this restaurant had and I was pleasantly surprised! They practically had Bogo everything! From the Meat Lovers Pizza, to the Cheesesteak Sandwich and Meatball Marinara Sub... I couldn't decide so I ordered it all! I was pretty certain I'd have to loosen by belt buckle for this feast, but it seemed worth the caloric guilt. The order took awhile to deliver but I ordered a massive amount so I wasn't complaining.When the food arrived, I was astounded by the portioning, size and quality of the items.The sandwiches were generously stuffed with loads of meat & cheese, the pizza was properly topped with an array of delectable meats and the salad was massive, bright, fresh and loaded with veggies! I was very impressed but now it was down to how everything tasted.The perfectly baked pizza dough held the ingredients nicely without losing its integrity and the first bite was absolutely satisfying.The cheesesteak was delicious as well as the meatball marinara sub. I honestly had no complaints. They do get busy during lunch so order thoughtfully and be mindful that with patience comes amazing rewards, namely fresh and delicious Italian cuisine you'll come back for time and time again!Happy Eats!
Read More
Will C.
Jun 26, 2024
Just stopped by myself for a quick slice. Just as good as first review two years ago. parking lot is a little busier now, but there's plenty of tables for outside dining alongside the other restaurants as well.Stillwell recommended, we will return
Read More
AJ T.
May 9, 2024
I love this little place! Great ambiance!The pizza is BIG and delicious.The garlic knots are also excellent.Very NYC of you to grab a slice & go.Highly recommended as the best pizza joint in this part of town.
Read More
Garett Y.
Apr 17, 2024
Hands-down, one of the best experiences I've had in a while. Went over to rip Pizza to have dinner and the wait was extremely long. Hopped on out and looked up pizza nearby and this place came up. The sad thing is, I've driven by this place about 1000 times and never thought to give it a try. Pepperoni pizza : this pizza was extremely good. It was nice and big, there was a little bit of flop, and the underside was cooked perfectly. My only issue with the pizza is that no matter the size after large the slices just get bigger. Had to cut it when I got home into smaller slices, but in the grand scheme of things that was not a big deal.Sicilian pizza: this is my favorite pizza. It was filled with flavor. You would think it would be a bit doughy considering that they use double dough but it was fantastic. The staff was extremely nice and explained everything when I asked questions since I've never been there before. Will definitely come back.
Read More
Sarah M.
Jan 23, 2025
How do you false advertise your jalapeño poppers? That's bad business. And the ones you served were disgusting freezer food I could have air fried myself. I did not eat them they went straight to the trash. Clearly not the picture on your website. Did not come with marinara either, came with ranch, I literally thought I got an order of chicken nugget. Pizza was decent, that's what the three stars is for.
Read More
Myriha W.
Mar 1, 2025
best pizza in town! The variety of pizzas are delicious as well as the price point is amazing compared to competitive pizza joints
Read More
