Yummy Crab

Appetizers

Hush Puppies (10)

10 pieces. Comes with melt butter.
$4.27
Onion Rings (10)

10 piece, comes with Tartar Sauce.
$6.71
Spring Rolls (3)

3 pieces, Vegetable only.
$6.71
Garlic Bread Sticks (4)

4 per serving.
$7.01
Fried Cheese Sticks (6)

6 per serving, come with marinara sauce.
$6.71
Chicken Tenders (4)

4 per serving, do not come with fries.
$10.00
Fried Jumbo Shrimp (8)

8 per serving, do not come with fries.
$11.25
Fried Scallops (8)

8 per serving.
$10.37
Fried Calamari (10)

10 per serving,
$10.37
Popcorn Shrimp

come with Tartar Sauce.
$11.25
Fried Oysters (8)

Come with Tartar Sauce.
$11.25
Steamed Oysters

Choose your seasoning and spicy level.
$12.25
Chicken Wings

Comes with celery.
$9.76
Crab Cake Bites (6)

Come with Remoulade sauce.
$12.18
Edamame green soybeans

cooked Green soybean whith salt
$5.98

Soup/Salad

Broccoli Cheddar Soup
$6.71
New England Clam Chowder

A thick creamy soup.
$8.52
Lobster Bisque

Thick and creamy soup.
$8.52
Coleslaw (4oz)

Cabbage salad.
$3.60
Caesar Salad

Green salad with Caesar dressing and cheese.
$6.25
Crab-meat Salad
$8.23
Shrimp Salad

Shellfish salad.
$8.23
Chicken Salad
$8.23
Gumbo Soup

shrimp.chicken.sausage.vegetable.rice.(12oz)
$8.23

Fried Basket

Fried Shrimp Basket(8)

8 per serving, come with cajun fries and Tartar Sauce.
$14.03
Fried Tilapia Basket (4)

4 fillets per serving, come with Cajun fries and Tartar sauce.
$13.75
Fried Catfish Basket (4)

4 fillets per serving, come with Cajun fries and Tartar Sauce.
$15.25
Fried Flounder Basket (4)

4 fillets per serving, come with Cajun fries and Tartar Sauce.
$13.75
Fried Oyster Basket (8)

8 per serving, come with Cajun fries and Tartar Sauce.
$15.55
Lobster Tail Basket (1)

1 fried Lobster Tail (6oz), comes with cajun fries.
$23.18
Soft-shell Crab Basket (2)

2 per serving, come with cajun fries.
$18.75
Chicken Tender Basket (4)

4 per serving, come with Cajun fries.
$13.42
Wings Basket (8)

8 per serving, come with cajun fries.
$16.47
Chicken Nuggets (10 pcs) Basket

10 pcs per serving, come with Cajun fries
$11.87

Po'Boy Sandwiches

Chicken Po'Boy
$13.35
Shrimp Po'Boy

come with Cajun fries.
$14.57
Fried Fish Po'Boy Cat Fish

come with Cajun fries.
$14.57
Fried Oyster Po'Boy

come with Cajun fries.
$15.80

Get Your Hands Dirty

No Heads Shrimp(12 pc)

1/2 lb come with 1 corn&2 potato; 1 lb come with 2 corn&4 potatoes &1 broccoli.
$15.25
Head on Shrimp

1/2 lb come with 1 corn&2 potato; 1 lb come with 2 corn&4 potatoes &1 broccoli.
$12.81
Blue Crab (Seasonal)

soft-shell whole crab. 1/2 lb come with 1 corn&2 potato; 1 lb come with 2 corn&4 potatoes &1 broccoli.
$12.20
Snow Crab Legs

1/2 lb (one cluster) come with 1 corn&2 potato; 1 lb (two clusters) comes with 2 corn&4 potatoes &1 broccoli.
$18.91
Dungeness Crab

1lb (half of the whole crab) comes with 1 corn&2 potato; 2 lb (whole crab) comes with 2 corn&4 potatoes &1 broccoli.
$21.25
Lobster Tail (6 oz)

come with 1 corn&2 potato.
$20.74
Black Mussel

1/2 lb come with 1 corn&2 potato; 1 lb come with 2 corn&4 potatoes &1 broccoli.
$10.37
Green Mussel

1/2 lb come with 1 corn&2 potato; 1 lb come with 2 corn&4 potatoes &1 broccoli.
$10.37
Clams

1/2 lb come with 1 corn&2 potato; 1 lb come with 2 corn&4 potatoes &1 broccoli.
$9.15
Crawfish

1/2 lb come with 1 corn&2 potato; 1 lb come with 2 corn&4 potatoes &1 broccoli.
$9.76
Squid

1/2 lb come with 1 corn&2 potato; 1 lb come with 2 corn&4 potatoes &1 broccoli.
$10.37
Scallop

1/2 lb come with 1 corn&2 potato; 1 lb come with 2 corn&4 potatoes &1 broccoli.
$20.13
King Crab Leg(1 LB)

For the King Crab Leg, 1 LB ONLY comes with ONE LEG (not one cluster). come with 2 corn&4 potato&1 broccoli.
$67.10
Bule Crab

1/2 lb come with 1 corn&2 potato; 1 lb come with 2 corn&4 potatoes &1 broccoli.
$13.42

Yummy Crab Popular Combos

1. Two Items Combo

1/2 lb of snow crab legs(one cluster) and 1/2 lb of no head shrimp. come with 2 corn&4potato&1 broccoli.
$32.33
2. Three Items Combos

1/2 lb. of snow crab legs(one cluster) and 1/2 lb. of no head shrimp and 1 piece of lobster tail(6 oz). come with 3 corn&6potato&1 broccoli.
$53.07
3. Four Items Combos(Crawfish)

1/2 lb. of snow crab legs(one cluster) and 1 piece lobster tail(6 oz), 1/2 lb. no head shrimp, 1/2 lb. of crawfish. come with 4 corn&8 potato&2 broccoli.
$61.61
4. Four Items Combos (Green Mussel)

1/2 lb. of snow crab legs(one cluster) and 1 piece lobster tail(6 oz), 1/2 lb. of no head shrimp, 1/2 lb. of green mussel. come with 4 corn&8 potato&2 broccoli.
$62.22
5. Four Items Combos (Black Mussel)

1/2 lb. of snow crab legs(one cluster) and 1 piece lobster tail(6 oz), 1/2 lb. of no head shrimp, 1/2 lb. of black mussel. come with 4 corn&8 potato&2 broccoli.
$62.22
Set Sail

1 LB No Head Shrimp,1/2 Sausage (made by pork, beef, and turkey all mixed), 2 boiled eggs,10 Pc Broccli. 2 corns and 4 potatoes. (NO SUBSTITUTIONS)
$34.16
Shelled

1/2 LB No Head Shrimp, 1/2LB Snow Crab.1/2 LB Black Mussel.1/2 Lb Sausage (made by pork, beef, and turkey all mixed), 2 boiled eggs, 10 PC Broccli,2 corns and 4 potatoes. NO SUBTITUTIONS.
$46.36

Side

Corn on The Cob (3)

3 per serving.
$3.35
Potatoes (3)

boiled red skin potato. 3 per serving.
$3.35
Broccoli (10)

10 per serving.
$4.40
Boiled Egg (3)

3 pieces.
$5.50
Sausage

Made with pork, beef, and turkey ALL MIXED.
$7.32
White Steamed Rice
$2.50
Sweet Potato Fries
$6.05
French Fries
$4.85
Cajun Fries
$4.85
Lemon Slices(6)

6 per Serving.
$1.50
Spaghetti Noodles
$6.15

Seasoning/Sauce

8 oz Seasoning
$6.25
16 oz Seasoning
$12.50
32 oz Seasoning
$25.00
Melted Butter (8 oz)

Plain melted butter only, no garlic chunks.
$3.00
BBQ Sauce (2 oz)
$0.75
Buffalo Sauce (2 oz)
$0.75
Cocktail Sauce (2 oz)
$0.65
Honey Mustard (2 oz)
$0.65
Ranch (2 oz)
$0.55
Tartar Sauce (2 oz)
$0.55
Caesar (2 oz)
$0.90
Marinara Sauce
$0.65
Blue Cheese
$1.20
Remoulade (2 oz )
$0.90
Cajun powder (2 oz)
$1.00
Lemon pepper powder (2 oz)
$1.00
Lemon Slices (6 PC's)
$1.50

Desserts

Molten Chocolate Cake
$8.20
Peanut Butter and Chocolate Cake
$8.80
Cheesecake
$5.70
Tiramisu
$8.20

Soda/Juice

Red Bull (8.4FL)
$4.20
Pepsi (32 oz)

32 oz foam cup.
$3.60
Diet Pepsi (32oz)

32 oz foam cup.
$3.60
Sierra Mist (32 oz)

32 oz foam cup.
$3.60
Dr.Pepper (32 oz)

32 oz foam cup.
$3.60
Mountain Dew (32 oz)

32 oz foam cup.
$3.60
Crush Orange (32 oz)

32 oz foam cup.
$3.60
Lemonade (32 oz)

32 oz foam cup.
$3.60
Fruit Punch (32 oz)

32 oz foam cup.
$3.60
Unsweetened Tea (32 oz)

32 oz foam cup.
$3.60
Sweetened Tea (32 oz)

32 oz foam cup.
$3.60
Apple Juice (16 oz)

16 oz foam cup.
$3.96
Orange Juice (16 oz)

16 oz foam cup.
$3.96
Cranberry Juice (16 oz)

16 oz foam cup.
$3.96

Daily Special

Seafood Delight

1 Pc LobsterTail+1/2LB Sonw Crab Leg+1/2LBShrimp No Head+1/2Lb Sausage+10 Pc Broccoli+2 Egg+2 Corns+4 Potatoes
$57.34
Yummy Combo

1 Lb Snow Crab+1 Lb Shrimp No Head+1/2 Lb Sausage+10 Pc Broccli+2 Egg+2 Corns+4 Potatoes
$68.32
Double Lobster

2 pc Lobster Tail +1 LB shrimp(no Heads) 1/2LB Sausage 10 pc Broccoli 2 Egg, 2 Corn, 4 Potato
$73.20

Chandra L.

★★★☆☆

Oct 18, 2024

I ordered this to-go & let me tell you it smelled SOOOOOOO good on my way driving home. I was salivating the whole time! The costumer service when I went inside was great. They were very kind & polite. I got the yummy special seasoning mild and it was so flavorful and delicious. Oddly, One of my king crab legs was overcooked and was very tough & chewy. I got potatoes, broccoli & corn in the order as well. The potatoes were alright. The broccoli was perfection. The corn tasted very strange, I was not able to eat it.

Billie K.

★★★★☆

Dec 25, 2023

Today is Christmas and we thought it would be a nice carry out. dinner option. Our seafood boils were very tasty -as usual. We both opted for the mild and the sauce that has everything in it. Try that because you will be amazed at the taste. It's unlike any other seafood boil taste you've had. Very very flavorful.I always use Yelp to order which is GrubHub for this restaurant. Be aware that when you go to pick up your order giving your name. The gentleman helping me to say it's a GrubHub order. Not just using my personal name. Lucky another gentleman who was friendly was there and said, "yes she is correct, that's hers." He even told me merry Christmas.

Richard Walton C.

★★★★☆

Aug 3, 2023

I arrived for lunch and was seated immediately in a booth next to their pseudo bar. The bar is basically a lunch counter and not an alcohol type bar although they do have bottled beer and wine available. I ordered the Fried Shrimp Basket which comes with Cajun fries. The shrimps were BIG! Yeah you might be able to eat a whole one in one bite but I ate them in 2-3 bites. They were delicious. I couldn't tell anything cajun about the fries. They seemed to be just regular battered style fries to me. Service was excellent throughout my stay. There is plenty of parking available in the huge shared lot of the shopping center.

Kayla H.

★★★★★

Jun 23, 2024

Food and service was phenomenal! I found this chain when i lived in Georgia and i was so excited to find our indy has a couple locations, service was very quick, im genuinely surprised it was so empty in there guest wise, i love it and will be back again! We ordered mild spice and cajan seasoning and i do recommend! Very clean, beverage options but not a full bar.

Val M.

★★★★☆

Mar 1, 2023

Food was good. Very affordable restaurant and service was very fast. I loved the casual ambiance over there. Very great place to have seafood

Niesha N.

★★★★★

Feb 14, 2021

I'm definitely addicted to this place. I have yet to visit them personally, but do enjoy delivery from Door Dash and Caviar apps. I absolutely love the crawfish. The piece are HUGE! The seasonings are awesome too. My favorite thing to do, is to have a side of rice or pasta already cooked up. I like to drain the juice over my rice or plain pasta.. then I'll have an extra meal. :)

Lyndsay C.

★★★★★

Jun 21, 2022

last night was my third time ordering take out from the Yummy crab, I hate online ordering so I always call to order, each time they have been pleasant and friendly, answering questions with ease. The snow crab and shrimp boil with potatoes, corn, sausage (have to add this), and broccoli has been my go to move. A few suggestions, get the yummy mix with all the seasonings added in the bag and add melted butter on the side, you won't regret it. Also add more broccoli, this has consistently been so delicious. Yummy Crab is worth the drive from Fishers!

Dan Y.

★★★★☆

Feb 16, 2025

Good spot if you're in the mood for a seafood boil. Convenient location at pike plaza and Lafayette rd.

Phil S.

★★☆☆☆

Aug 1, 2024

If you order the special meals, they are served in plastic bags, with no knife or scissors to open them, so I had to rip it open, which was very difficult, getting sauce on my hands and forearms. Speaking of the sauce, it is very greasy and with very little flavoring, so the meal was not good. It was a good price for the amount of food you received, but certainly not a good meal. Atmosphere was fine, as was the service.

Evita E.

★★★★★

Jun 11, 2024

Everything was delicious the seasoning was perfect I just wish I had a little more liquor dip my potatoes in

Yummy Crab

Menu

Appetizers

Hush Puppies (10)

Onion Rings (10)

Spring Rolls (3)

Garlic Bread Sticks (4)

Fried Cheese Sticks (6)

Chicken Tenders (4)

Fried Jumbo Shrimp (8)

Fried Scallops (8)

Fried Calamari (10)

Popcorn Shrimp

Fried Oysters (8)

Steamed Oysters

Chicken Wings

Crab Cake Bites (6)

Edamame green soybeans

Soup/Salad

Broccoli Cheddar Soup

New England Clam Chowder

Lobster Bisque

Coleslaw (4oz)

Caesar Salad

Crab-meat Salad

Shrimp Salad

Chicken Salad

Gumbo Soup

Fried Basket

Fried Shrimp Basket(8)

Fried Tilapia Basket (4)

Fried Catfish Basket (4)

Fried Flounder Basket (4)

Fried Oyster Basket (8)

Lobster Tail Basket (1)

Soft-shell Crab Basket (2)

Chicken Tender Basket (4)

Wings Basket (8)

Chicken Nuggets (10 pcs) Basket

Po'Boy Sandwiches

Chicken Po'Boy

Shrimp Po'Boy

Fried Fish Po'Boy Cat Fish

Fried Oyster Po'Boy

Get Your Hands Dirty

No Heads Shrimp(12 pc)

Head on Shrimp

Blue Crab (Seasonal)

Snow Crab Legs

Dungeness Crab

Lobster Tail (6 oz)

Black Mussel

Green Mussel

Clams

Crawfish

Squid

Scallop

King Crab Leg(1 LB)

Bule Crab

Make Your Own Seafood Combo

Make Your Own Seafood Combo(min 2 items)

Yummy Crab Popular Combos

1. Two Items Combo

2. Three Items Combos

3. Four Items Combos(Crawfish)

4. Four Items Combos (Green Mussel)

5. Four Items Combos (Black Mussel)

Set Sail

Shelled

Side

Corn on The Cob (3)

Potatoes (3)

Broccoli (10)

Boiled Egg (3)

Sausage

White Steamed Rice

Sweet Potato Fries

French Fries

Cajun Fries

Lemon Slices(6)