Wise Pies Pizza and Subs

This was a great experience! We started out with pizza by the slice - mine was pepperoni and hubby had the barbecue chicken. They were generous slices, the crust was excellent and they weren't stingy with the toppings. Service was great and it gave a good family vibe. Our mistake was then we ordered a Calzone to share. Holy-Moley!! We had never had one before and half of it easily fed both of us and I ended up taking the other half over to my daughter's. Ricotta cheese, Italian sausage and black olives. Marinara on the side.

Pizza is always amazing and the staff is super lovely as well. It's usually a pretty chill atmosphere and since I'm student, I like to study in here around lunch time as well. Highly recommend!

Always a favorite pizza spot downtown TH! Friendly staff and great food... cold beer too! The chicken bacon ranch pizza is my go to!

A clever name.I admire their ability to handle a large group a couple months back. The availability of wine certainly did not detract from the experience, even if the service of it requires some logistical gymnastics to skirt some arcane local law.Unfortunately, the pizza is thin, lifeless, and not that memorable in terms of taste. I would eat it again, but only if someone else were to foot the bill.It's just not my slice of pie.

While I would have to give a slight nod to Maurizio's in terms of the Terre Haute pizza crown, the truth is every time I think about knocking the Wise Pies score down to 3-stars something holds me back. Located in downtown Terre Haute near the Indiana State University campus and not too far from both the Hilton Garden Inn and the Candlewood Suites, Wise Pies Pizza and Subs has two Terre Haute locations and is a solid choice for anyone wanting a slice or a pie of New York-style pizza (or at least New York-style pizza as made in Indiana). I wasn't in the mood for much when I stopped by Wise Pies after a visit to the Terre Haute Children's Museum and a brief detour to my nearby hotel room. I was wheeling around downtown getting used to a newer wheelchair that I would be using for a long distance event and remembered the sign for Wise Pies that said it sold pizza by the slice. I ordered a combo option they have that includes a slice, in my case sausage, along with a couple of breadsticks. I also ordered an unsweetened iced tea. The modest meal came in at less than your usual mall slice combo at a bit under eight bucks. The entrance to Wise Pies isn't particularly wheelchair friendly - this is mostly because it's an older building and they've opted to maintain the old school charm. You enter and there's a handful of tables along with the ordering counter. To the left, however, you have an entire room of booths and tables available. Both rooms are rather narrow, but I found them comfortable and charming. The menu consists mainly of pizza, subs and breadsticks along with drinks. Prices for a whole pie start at $10.99 for a 14" cheese and go up from there based upon size and toppings. I ordered and found a table near the front of the side room. It allowed me to window browse while also leaving lots of room for the wheelchair. At the time I arrived, the place had only a couple other diners but picked up the longer I lingered. The pizza slice was solid, though perhaps a tad on the smallish side. It was certainly tasty, though it didn't really blow me away. The breadsticks, on the other hand, were top notch. While I've seen several comments about service, I must say I found the service to be friendly and attentive. I received multiple iced tea refills including one to go. Even though I was sitting in a corner, I was tended to regularly and never really had to wait for service. I also watched the staff interact well with multiple children who were with one party - if you treat the kids well, I'm a fan of yours. I've wrestled with whether or not to give Wise Pies a 3 or 4-star rating. The truth is that a 3.5 is just about exactly right. Since that's not an option, it comes down to winning service for me and a meal and atmosphere I enjoyed. So, a 4-star rating it is. While Wise Pies has some accessibility concerns, it's far more accessible than Maurizio's and offers free parking on the street. When I'm in Terre Haute, I won't hesitate to go back.

My favorite pizza place ever. Fav is the WOW pizza. Thin crust is my favorite so this place is perfect. If you get the combo (one pizza slice with bread sticks) it will fill you up. I would definitely advise getting an entire pizza you're hungry because three silces cost the same price as a full pizza. Restaurant is cozy inside with an old school vibe. I enjoy sitting outside when weather permits during lunch and chatting with friends.

Cute little pizza shop downtown right off Wabash and 6th. Great location! Black and white artwork throughout with what looked like original floors gives it a rustic feel. My son ordered 2 slices of pepperoni pizza and I ordered a slice of cheesecake. Pizza slices are massive! Definitely worth 5$ And I'm pretty sure he made the classic New York style cheesecake himself. It was absolutely delicious!!

The absolute best pizza in Terre Haute. The crust is so good and it wood fired pizza. I always get the hot honey pepperoni and the margherita pizza. SOOOOO GOOD!!!

The calzones were huge and delicious! Great atmosphere and super friendly staff. We will be back!

Bit of a hole-in-the-wall, could be easy to miss. Customer Service/Staff: 5/5Vibe/Ambience: 4/5Slices are massive and good value size for price. The dough/crust is or nears top quality, but the entire pizza on it's own was lacking. For typical, traditional NY style, thin crust, I can see why this place ranks highly. But, I'll look for a different pizza place to try next time I'm in town.