Tonys Cafe
Tonys Cafe
Delicious Perfection
Breaded tenderloin and fries
Daily specials
Tony's Cafe in Fishers
Excelente servicio,buena comida es la primera vez que venimos y regresaremos
Delicious once again
Dining room
Corn Corned Beef Hash Skillet
Coffee
Menu breakfast
2 aides of bacon ! We love bacon!
Veggie Skillet with grits and of course coffee.
The Greek Skillet, black coffee and toast
Menu for pancakes and waffles
Menu for omelettes and skillets
Menu for kids, sides, drinks, wraps
Menu salads and sandwiches
1 egg over easy + 1 order sausage links
Plain Pancakes
Nutella French toast
Tony's Tony's Meat Lovers Skillet
Spinach Bacon Swiss cheese Omelette
Side of biscuits and gravy
Mediterranean Scrambler, no green peppers
Richard P.
Mar 24, 2024
Tony's Cafe is a relatively small, family owned breakfast/brunch restaurant located in a fairly nondescript strip center in Fishers. I must confess, and this is a bit of a generalization, that my experience has mostly been that when visiting a brunch restaurant you mostly forget about the "unch." In other words, when breakfast is the emphasis one should focus on breakfast. Tony's is along the lines of places like Lincoln Square, etc. They serve breakfast all day (closing at 3pm) and also serve lunch. I arrived on a Sunday about 1pm. I was in the mood for lunch, however, I was also a bit hesitant. I'd hoped to go to CR Hero's (located in an adjacent strip center), however, they're closed Sundays. Thus, I ended up at Tony's. Tony's has a full breakfast menu with all the usuals along with a lunch menu of sandwiches, burgers, chicken options, etc. I'm always on the lookout for a decent breaded tenderloin for my good buddy and fellow Yelper Rick G., so I opted for a breaded tenderloin with fries. This building has a handful of accessible parking spots along with curb cuts at both ends of the building. Tony's Cafe is toward the west end of the building. However, those spots were taken and I parked at the other end. There's a double-glass door entryway and then you're in the dining room. There's a small hosting area to the left - this is also where you pay. Service was friendly in a quiet way. I have to admit that the tenderloin was a bit of a disappointment. It was very mid-range. It came on a toasted bun with the usual tomato/lettuce toppings. It wasn't bad. It wasn't good. It was just sort of "meh." The fries, which are not crinkle-cut as pictured on their website, were also definitely mid-range. I was for sure wishing I'd opted for a breakfast selection. The iced tea was fine and in a decent-sized glass, though I was never offered a refill (a major faux pas for this iced tea lover). The bill came in at just over $15 without tip. I would not even think about ordering this meal again, though I likely would return and try breakfast since the atmosphere was fine and the service was friendly if unremarkable. The atmosphere? It's an opening dining room with booths on the side and tables in the middle. It's fairly nondescript, however, it's also definitely clean. I did not check out the restrooms on this visit. I was easily able to find a wheelchair friendly table and there was decent space between tables. Overall, this was a full-on mid-range experience. It definitely wasn't as solid as I'd been hoping going into it, however, it was a decent meal. Again, my gut told me to go for breakfast options and I likely should have listened to that. Business was modest, though it was getting near the end of the day when I finally left right around 2pm.
Read More
Dave T.
Feb 11, 2025
Good food and service. Small place that's very clean. Breakfast and lunch. Only had breakfast. Will definitely try lunch next time
Read More
Maya T.
Sep 29, 2023
About our third time here ALWAYS amazing!This time I got some coffee OM goodness the only other coffee I could drink black was the coffee at our coffee shop. DELICIOUS!Tried The Greek Skillet, I have some comments. I took off the green pepper 'cause personally I don't like peppers, but the onions... kinda take away the flavor of everything else. Gyro is AMAZING!It's never too crowded, it's comfortable and the service I always great! Tony's, keep doing what you're doin'
Read More
Michelle T.
Oct 4, 2023
Been a few times now and is always delicious! It is a small gem of a place in the Geist/Fishers area! They have a huge menu for breakfast, brunch, lunch and dinner, whatever you are looking for! Never over crowded, so no line like everywhere else in Fishers and Geist! We always go for late breakfast and get varies skillet combos always a hit, pancakes soft and fluffy, chicken tenders perfectly crispy for the kids, grits smooth and creamy, and coffee is great as well! Will keep going and bringing new customers.
Read More
Lindsey M.
Jan 22, 2023
We decided to go here after waiting way too long somewhere else for brunch. We came around 1pm on a Sunday and had no wait for 3 of us to be seated! The waitress was friendly and attentive. We ordered several food items as we were starving from trying to be seated at another restaurant for brunch. Our food was perfect temperature and came out in a timely manner. Portions are good size and prices are very reasonable here. I would definitely recommend this place for breakfast or brunch. I love corn beef hash and they alot of corn beef hash options. I only suggest more veggie options for skillets, why only green peppers? What about the red, orange and yellow peppers? There was parking readily available out front of the restaurant. The bathrooms were clean.
Read More
Andrea Y.
Jan 19, 2024
You can't beat Tony's for a quick, solid, fair priced meal. Everything I've had from Tony's has been satisfying. Great local breakfast/lunch place. I'm always surprised when the place isn't packed. Maybe it's not bougie enough for the area? Terrific for take-out!
Read More
Ravi S.
Sep 19, 2021
1) I love brunch. It's by far the best meal and I won't hear otherwise from anyone2) it's so fun finding new locally owned spots and I'm really glad I ran into Tony's! The place is fairly big and open and the menu has many traditional options, but also some more interesting things like what I ordered! I found it absolutely delicious and a worthwhile restaurant to stop in and try!Eggs Benedict biscuits and gravy
Read More
Tina R.
Feb 9, 2025
We loved everything about this place. Family owned and operated. Kind and attentive service. The food was delicious and came out quickly. The menu had a variety of breakfast options. Perfect food portions and great prices. We will definitely be back.
Read More
Beas D.
Aug 17, 2024
Stopped in for breakfast on Saturday. Place was not very crowded. Service was slow and food was cold.Would not return.
Read More
Erica M.
Nov 17, 2024
We went for Sunday morning breakfast. We were the only ones for a bit but service, food and atmosphere will bring us back often. The portion sizes were perfect, not too much!
Read More
Rated: 3.4 (113 reviews) · $
Breakfast & Brunch, American, Steakhouses