Tomato Pie Pizza Joint

What a find. First, the service is impeccable. Carol greeted us at the door and took care of us. I've never had better breadsticks; the salad is enough for two. I expected a ho-hum salad, but this salad was a work of art. The pizza was certainly worth the drive from Martinsville. There was a constant flow of carry-out customers, but this summer, we'll take our car clubs there, and they can seat about a hundred on the patio. Everyone at the Tomato Pie likes what they do, which certainly shows in their friendliness and product quality.

This is located a little bit of 67. You can't miss it when you drive into Paragon. It's on the right with a neat painted on logo on the building. The building has character and it's nice inside. The employees were friendly and they had a steady flow of people picking up orders or coming in and having a sit down meal. They have a spot on check in area if you earn points. I keep the tag on my keychain and scan it whenever I see a spot on area. The breadsticks were warm and fresh. They aren't dense they're light and delicious. You could see all the employees rolling dough and adding toppings. All hard at work! The lasagna was made with their house pasta sauce and have a lot of flavor. I liked how they had a stack of to go boxes and lids to take home with you. The servings are big and it's nice they thought of that. They also had gelato available and numerous beers. It's a great place to stop!

Not exactly on the way, but this served as our stopover lunch spot between Cataract Falls and McCormick's Creek State Park. No way we would have found this without Yelp. You order at the counter and they bring your food to the table. I'm guessing most people carry out because the restaurant is very small and even a bit run down. The food, however, is fabulous! We ordered the breadsticks with the jalapeno cheese. Somehow the breadsticks were both airy yet chewy, foretelling of the excellent pizza we were about to enjoy. We shared a medium Ultimate which was more than two of us could eat, so we happily took some home. Nice craft beer selection and pleasant service. Are food arrived relatively quickly considering that it was baked fresh for us.With a 20% tip our bill was nearly $40; some might consider this expensive for pizza and beer.

O. M. G. If youre looking for amazing pizza and breadsticks tucked away in a tiny town, youve found it. People travel from greenwood just to get this pizza!! (Thats us lol) Worth the drive yall!!! And we're picky with pizza, so this place is aaaamazing!!!

Delicious gem hidden in a small town. But that is part of what makes it so special. Great food at a great price.

Good pizzaGreat selection of toppingsOutstanding bread sticksExcellent saladsReally good sandwichesLocal ownerLocal staffOpen for lunchOpen till 10:00One large pizza 3 soft drinks $34.00You choose.... Dominos??? Or great pizza at a local spot

Great flavor in their pizza if you like cheese! Until 2 pm, you can order pizzas by the slice made to order. Although the staff said it would only take about 5 minutes, I realized that it would be more like 15 to 20. And when they say slice, it is more like a quarter pizza! Huge servings, loaded with cheese and a reasonable wait time is okay by me! I was getting my order to go, so I didn't partake of the Quaff On or Sun KIng craft beers available, but it's nice to know they have those.Each slice was so large that they were each placed in their own styrofoam box for transport.The pizza itself is the real soft bottomed (almost soggy) crust that is meant to be folded if you don't want any grease from the meat to drip on you. The one negative I noticed was that the toppings I requested were more densely packed near the outer crust than the center. They don't slice the mushrooms or pepperoni any smaller to fit down into the point of the pie slice, so the first bite or two are mostly the cheese and sauce flavors. But nearer the crust they have plenty of toppings. Still, it would be nice if they would take that one extra step to make the quality the same throughout the pizza.Review #1778

Delicious overly cheesy pizza with the best breadsticks and marinara! Currently offering pick up only due to COVID.

Love Tomato Pie!! Have their pizzas and Sammies quite often. Breadsticks are awesome too!!

Great old style pizza. Great service. Highly recommend. Nice little drive to enjoy this family owned pizza place.