The Toast Cafe

What went well?EVERY SINGLE THING!My wife and I finally made our way over to The Toast and DANG do we love everything about it!Great service from the moment we opened the front door.Delicious food - you can't go wrong with the Breakfast Biscuit Manhattan, which the server brought me when I said "surprise me" for my order.The wifey says the Biscuit French Toast was superb!!Darla and Gary (owners) have done it AGAIN in Anderson and we are SO grateful!!

Terrible service! First time ever stepping foot in this place! Never ordered and won't try again! Service is beyond appalling! There were several folks there at breakfast. The hostess said it would be about a 10 minute wait because the kitchen was behind. She cleaned and set all of the tables. There were several tables cleaned. There were 3 older ladies ahead of us that had been waiting longer than my wife and I. My wife has leg problems and can't stand for long periods of time! I finally asked the hostess if she could at least seat the ladies for their wait. She blew up on me telling me how she said it'd be a 10 minute wait. Why couldn't we wait sitting for instead of being a fire hazard in front of the door. The hostess was extremely rude and disrespectful chasing us out the door yelling at us! As a tid bit of information, my wife and I frequent and rate restaurants on or page Foodies of Central Indiana. I'm certain that since we were basically ran off, we will not only give you a bad review here but also on our food blog page. DO NOT RECOMMEND! Since my review the owner Gary Sallee continues to harass and bully me on facebook! Do not give this place business! A simple apology could have changed this! 25% bad reviews on facebook.

My new favorite breakfast place! Can't wait to try lunch here too! I had the biscuit French toast. Amazing! Never thought to make French toast from biscuits. Large portions, good coffee, diner experience mixed with glam, and great service. Well done! Side note: and there is good parking, outside seating when the weather is nice, great photo backgrounds.

What a wonderful surprise we found in Anderson. The service and food was excellent! The flavors of the sausage and gravey just like my auntie used to make. Thanks Beth for the hot sauce from Fortville recommendation. Wifey had the Grilled cheese on rye and tomato basil soup and salad. And the coffee was delicious!

I nice new building and really friendly staff is the only thing that got me to bump up to a second star. Food was a little less than so-so. It is not anything close to as good as what it was when The Toast was under the previous owners. Two people with basic breakfasts was just under $34 before the tip. The portions were huge. what we got for the two of us would just two breakfasts was easily large enough to feed four or five people. I would suggest the portions bringing the price back down and improving the quality of the food.

The Toast is/was a small dinner located in the downtown area of Anderson. I say was because it is currently closed for renovations. A couple of guys bough the diner about a year ago and renovations started not long after. It is taking some time but the wait will be worth it. They are returning The Toast in to a classic dinner, or so that is plan I read. When they are finished, it be great I am sure.The Toast is a place I go regularly for a classic diner style meal. Nothing fancy, nothing Michelin-esq. Just you basic diner. The prices are very resonable and the food decent. It is popular with the locals, of which I am one, and can fill up quickly of a morning. I have tried most everything on the menu and haven't had anything would order again. My go to is two eggs, over medium with bacon, hash browns, and a coffee. If you know the movie Dirty Harry and the scene where Callahan goes in to the diner in San Fransisco to get his usual cup of coffee, then you should have some idea of the coffee at The Toast. Typical diner!I can't wait for The Toast to open back up so I can go enjoy the food and atmosphere on a random morning when I am craving a good, basic breakfast! See you there!

Phenomenal service. Food was delicious. Love the strawberry rhubarb jam. Wife got the avocado toast. I got the veggie omelette. They NAILED those and the hash browns (we like them crispy) were perfect. Got a to go order of the biscuit French toast. Can't wait to try that. Alicia was so great. Forgot to take a photo of the food.

I always enjoy visiting the Toast ! Neeceey is always extra nice and attentive ! She always gets me seated right away ! No one wants to stand around at the front door waiting to be seated when theres seats available ! The food is always delicious too !!!! Great job Neeceey and The Toast !!!!

Went for breakfast for the first time today all I can say is it's not even close to being as good as it was under original ownership

We have a drummer's breakfast once a month and we picked The Toast Cafe for December. It was my first time here. It was amazing all around! The staff were super nice and attentive. The building is remodeled and looks great! I got the Big Breakfast. The food tasted great! I could tell none of it was frozen and that it's all fresh. The B&Gs were my fav! The menu is huge and unique! I plan to come back to try more items!