The Scoreboard

The pizza was really good. It was pricey, but you are paying for quality. The pizza weighed a million pounds, very substantial. Really enjoyed it. (Ordered takeout to take over to the Madam Carroll, right across the street) Will definitely order from here again and would love to dine in sometime

This place is a shell of what it once was. Menu is scaled WAY back and main dining area is now self serve drinks and condiments. We got breadsticks with nacho cheese and marinara. Marinara was hot which is a big plus, but the nacho cheese was cold (?). My son got a calzone with a few toppings, one of which was bacon and it wasn't cooked and had giant pieces of fat. Also, way too much cheese inside. We also got a burger that was just ok and boneless wings were pretty good. Sad to witness the decline of this place- it was a Friday night and totally dead. They did credit back the calzone and our server was super sweet.

Stopped in at The Scoreboard with my two young children. They don't have a kids menu so we opted for a plain boneless wings and a cheeseburger for them. I went with the Chicken Burger and it was delicious. I have had a lot of chicken sandwiches in my life, including some at some posh burger places in Indy, and it is up there in the top 10. Will definitely order again the next time we stop in. And the prices!! Very reasonable--in fact it cost less to eat there than it did at Subway earlier in the week.

Came by with my underage son at 7:15pm on a Thursday but was told the restaurant side was closed. Listed hours show they are open until 9.

Great wings and pizza! I suggest they do something with the tons of flys flying around inside restaurant!

The food was amazing, we got a pizza, salad, breadsticks and chicken meal we had four adults and one child and it took the next day to eat it all. The salad can feed four easy. The garlic sauce was amazing it did take an hour for the food to be ready but it was a Friday night so that wasn't a surprise. If I lived in the area would go back.

Have been going there over the last 10 years and will not go back. I took 4 kids with me under the age of 12 and they all wanted fries. Was told you cant just order fries you have to order "loaded" fries and then just take off everything...$8 each! Also their pizza has always been really good but has been declining in taste the last few times of being there. This time it was not cooked all the way, was dry with not much sauce and the only taste i could find was the crushed red peppers I had sprinkled on it. We told the waitress that we would never be back because of all these things. She apologized and we told her not her fault. She said a lot of people have been complaining as well. She said it's been a young kid making the pizzas and he doesn't know what he's doing!!! You would have thought she would have had the manager come talk to us but no one came around. Also they are very rude and seem to have a lot of anxiety when the place gets busy. My guess is the owners only care about the craft beer they make and sell. Oh and don't get there 20-30 minutes before closing time because they'll tell you the kitchen is closed! I could understand if your open late but the place does a hard close at closing time. So sad because I've always enjoyed the pizza but will never go back!!

Food is good, service was very good and friendly however it was a slow Wed night so take into account. Beer is great. Always enjoy our time here but they do leave the big doors open for good weather sometimes and may be the reason so many flies are inside. I recommend the outdoor seating to avoid the flies. Still would recommend as the food is good and at a good price. The pizza is really good and the combo meals are worth it....plus the free fountain drinks with your meal are a bonus especially for kids! I always hate paying $4 for a drink and here they are free.

We have been a couple times. The first experience was poor with mediocre food and too many flies. When mentioning the flies to the server they could only apologize instead of opening the large overhead door in hopes that some would go away. The second time was a much better experience with fresh tasting and good food. Each time we purchased a pizza and wings. I'll chalk it up to the fact everyone has a bad day every so often. I will go back again.

Horrible service. We waited over an hour. Wait staff was unaware when our order was placed then proceeded to serve a table that came in 30 min after us first. Will not be going back any time soon.