The Old Custard Stand

First ever custard experience and I loved it! I had the blueberry white chocolate custard and it was amazing. Not suuuuper sweet, but just the right amount. It had chunks of white chocolate shavings and berries scattered throughout. It was a touch pricy, especially their "blizzard" knock-offs, but it was worth the price for me! Love the walk up and drive up options.

Don't let the picture fool you, everything doesn't have to look pretty to taste amazing! Stoped in here the other night when it was still 90 after the sunset and this couldn't have hit the spot any better. Service was excellent, and there was a good amount of berries and hot fudge which made this a perfect evening treat!

This is a mom and pop shop has a big menu of not only food items, but custard and sundaes. It was hard to decide what to get because of so many great sounding options. Made - Rites are big in Iowa and I had heard of them and just never had one. That's what I chose along with macaroni salad. Both were good. The sandwich was loaded up with pickles, mustard, and hamburger meat. It was good! The dessert was the fiesta sundae with custard, corn flakes, honey, and chocolate syrup - I chose caramel syrup and it also had whipped cream on top. It was good and a big portion. They have some picnic tables outside to eat your food at and a drive - thru. If you're ever up in the Noblesville area check this local place out.

Delicious treats with a wide array of options! Their hours seem quite limited though and they are often closed when we want to visit.

Been wanting to stop here for years and finally did! Just a quick peanut butter cone that was #yum. And a pupcup for my boy that he equally enjoyed. Nearly 100* out and had to ask for napkins since everything started melting so quickly. Ate in the car with the ac, but they do have a few tables outside. Also a drive through option. Sandwiches as well as ice cream. #dogfriendly #ReviewsByRL

Do not go through the drive through. You will lose years off your life with how slow it is.I got the peach cobbler special sundae, which was way too sweet. I asked the girl working at the window what it had, and she said i dont know, she didn't know what peach cobbler is. Not a great look.They do give out pup cups, which is a nice touch.

There is a special place in my heart for good custard. I grew up in wisconsin where custard is king and Old Custard Stand gives me that taste of home. They have a flavor of the day that I follow religiously. Dreamsicile is a personal favorite, but their custard is top notch and reminds me of wisconsin.

This is a first for me: I liked the waffle cone better than the frozen custard. The flavors were underwhelming in comparison to the other frozen custard establishments I've tried...but the waffle cone sure was tasty! Knowing the other options in the area, I'll drive farther south next time.

I always thought this placed was shut down cause it was never open when I drove by. Turns out, they're only open during the warm seasons. Finally got to try them, got a small chocolate shake and a banana split. There are so many sundaes to choose from! I thought it'd be in a medium-ish size cup... nope it's a full on banana split in a boat. Cut up bananas in the bottom, 3 scoops of vanilla, sliced strawberries, chopped pineapple, chocolate syrup, whip cream, and chopped nuts! I wasn't expecting a full size sundae but I finished it! Yum! I want to go back and try some other sundaes and the food too. Wish they served french fries though.

The custard is AMAZING! Rotating flavors and pup cups too. The gals who work there are so nice too. Very sad they are being forced out.