The NY Slice

EVERYBODY Is a pizza critic these days and EVERYBODY claims to know what a real NY Slice is all about. Look no further - here's where you'll find it. Wish I hadn't been so hungry or I would've gotten a picture of the pizza itself or the delicious chewy garlic knots - but alas I managed a photo of the cannolis so hopefully all is forgiven. RUN don't walk to this place - you won't regret it. And DAN is a great guy - show him some love!!

This is a very small restaurant located on the outskirts of the Greenwood Mall. It has a very small dining area that is not well maintained. There is also a television in the dining area, but it was not on while I was there. I deiced to eat there anyway, primarily because I did not want to eat in my car.The restaurant has adequate parking available, especial considering that it shares some of the mall's parking. There was also a farmers market operating right next to it while I was there. Also, they maintain a couple of food trucks that you will see in the parking lot. The staff was not rude and not over friendly. They did their job. Nothing more, nothing less.They do not have delivery, but you can use 3rd-part delivery such as Uber Eats or Grub Hub to bring you food. They have a drive through pickup window for those that had pre ordered. They have some appetizers such as mozzarella sticks, french fries, and garlic knots. They also have a few signature pies on the menu as well. You can buy a pie (3 sizes) or just a slice. You can also make your own. I got a small Da Big Meat Yorker. It took them about 15 minutes to make my pie. I ate it in the dining room. It was not really New York style, but it was good. It had flavor and was made fresh. If I am in the area, I would surly eat here again.

Stopped in randomly for a slice and man I'm glad I did! This was a fully authentic slice. Crust was light and crispy. Great undercarriage. Will be back

Great place to get a hot authentic New York slice or pie. We went with a slice and it was hot and tasty.

This place is literally the best NY styled pizza you will find anywhere in the area. GO HERE!! CHOOSE HERE!! I am not lying when I say I've had this pizza 10-15 times since I've moved here 4-5 months ago and I keep coming back!!!The owner is an absolute angel and you're supporting a local business! There are a lot of pizza options in the Indy area and this is the one you should choose.

The NYC is our new Friday pizza spot for the last four Fridays since we tried the Formaggi it is amazingly delicious!

The pizza, Stromboli,cannoli, salad, bread sticks is the best we have ever had. The owner Dan is wonderful and he has pride in his food. His prices are cheaper than other pizza places. Everything is fresh.

Best Pizza in Indianapolis area hands down! Dan the owner is super friendly and will be sure to treat you like family. Perfect pizza every time. True NY style. Please give them a visit if you are craving REAL pizza. Not fake Dominos or any of that fast food crap!

Owner Dan is very excellent and competent when it comes to his pie skills. !!!!!!!!!!!!!

Go to Greenwood, IN to experience perfection in NY pizza! It's the real deal; believe a New Yorker. The crust is very flavorful and has the right amount of chew and crisp in all the right places, and don't forget the char! The crust is not too thin and not too thick for folding the slice perfectly in half. There is the right amount of delicious and fresh tasting sauce and cheese. Next time I'll try other toppings but I have no doubt about their quality. I'm anxious to try other menu items, so I will be returning soon. Besides pizza, I had the best cannoli I ever ate in my long life, and I'm no stranger to the Italian bakeries on Arthur Ave. Dan, the owner, was trained at the esteemed Culinary Institute of America in Hyde Park, NY. A Chef and Restaurateur, he worked in his father's restaurant at the age of 8! He's spent his life in the industry. No wonder his food is perfection! You must let Dan cook for you! You deserve it!