The Mill Tavern

It looks like open seating (went on a Wednesday night) and got garlic parm wings and the potato wedges. I think they call them tavern fries. The server was so nice!!! And also we fell in love with the potato wedges. We loved them so much that we got three large orders to go on Saturday hoping we would keep an order for ourselves but they all disappeared. We will be coming back for the service and the wedges!!! Also probably more than that because that's what normal people would do.

Mill Tavern is a popular bar that serves sandwiches, salads and various entrees and, of course, has a full bar. The dining area is relatively small with maybe 20 tables, so you can expect a wait for seating. The walls are decorated with vintage signs and the place is immaculate. There are a couple tv monitors playing sports. Quiet music plays in the background. Regulars sit at the bar - people seem to know each other. People are friendly - staff and patrons. Our server, Lisa, was friendly, helpful and checked on us regularly. Drinks and food came out fairly quickly.I had the Tuesday night special rib eye dinner. The steak is cut thin but still large and cooked to medium rare perfection. The steak was tender and juicy. The baked potato is huge and baked perfectly. The side salad was fresh. My husband had the breaded tenderloin sandwich. The tenderloin was smaller than most and was a little dry. The coleslaw side was creamy and delicious. I like this place because it is comfortable and the food is good. Parking can be tight in this busy strip mall, but generally available.

21+ bar, upscale pub food. I LOVED all the Xmas decor, it put us in a good mood. The service was amazing, it seemed like a lot of regulars. She seemed to know a lot of the people, and took care of everyone.The wraps are good, the broccoli cheddar soup was decadent. I love all the sauces they have. My husband said the honey mustard was some of the best he's had in a while. When I commented about the fun decor, the server said it took them 15 hours to finish! I love all the little details and lights. I forgot how cozy it was here. This is the type of place you could just sit at the bar, watch a game and feel completely at ease. We haven't been in a while, but need to fit it in the rotation more often.

Just stopped in for an out of town carry out order. Sorry no food picks! Just a review.The facility is located in a strip mall that was easy to get in and out of. Plenty of parking outside the store. The restaurant isn't flashy. It's a big box with and attractive bar and confortable seat of seating. The inside was clean and a buzz with customers watching games. I thought the inside was a bit dark.The staff was very friendly. The bartender was very welcoming. The host was very helpful and efficient at getting us in and out.We started with the hand battered rings - excellent! The batter was thick and uniform so you knew it was hand made. The batter was tasty with a bit of salty taste and some spice. Not overly greasy.I hand the breaded tenderloin. The patty was a tad thicker than normal but very moist and tender. The breading was slightly thick and had a bit of crunch. The tenderloin came with lots of fresh toppings. I also found the Cole slaw to be outstanding. Lots of small finely chopped pieces of cabbage. The slaw is mayo based. It is light on the mayo but enough to pull the slaw together. It had a slight amount of pepper spice to give it a little zip.Excellent food! We will order again from here!!

Love this place!!! We live right down the road and I'd eat here every night if I could. Service is outstanding, food is delicious and atmosphere is chill and comfortable.

Love the Mill Tavern. The staff is great, the food is fantastic and you are in an inviting atmosphere where you feel apart of the action. Totally recommend. The wings are very good and the beer is cold!

Wonderful little place in Westfield. Our son introduced us to it tonight. All in all we had a Ruben, BLT, chick wrap, The Boss, and hot ham & cheese. Everything was really good, fresh, boxed up well for travel. Price wise was really reasonable as well.

We just stumbled across this and tried it for dinner. It's a great 21+ pub with lots of TVs, good music, and great atmosphere. It's like The Friendly in Zionsville but newer, cleaner, and the tables are not as cramped. Our server was very friendly, offered good recommendations, and was pretty attentive. The menu is extensive! And they only have 1 freezer so much of the food is very fresh. Specials most nights. We went on a Tuesday and the special was a 10 oz steak, baked potato and a roll. Fridays special is fish and chips. 10 or 11 beers on tap. We love this local, non-chain, friendly restaurant. My wife and I think it will be our go-to spot. Highly recommend.

Excellent food! Although all tables were full, we sat at the bar and enjoyed the service from bartender AJ!

Really bad experience. Not a great scene, avoid. Know it has good reviews, but experience I had was not good. Sometimes local bartenders get cocky, treat visitors like crap. Find someplace else, non-regulars not welcome.