TeeJay's Sweet Tooth

Best ice cream sandwiches and shakes. The oreo shake, ice cream doughnut sandwich, and brownie are my favorites.

Great new ice cream place.I went through the drive through with friends. We got our ice cream quick and it was delicious. They have tons of flavors!This place is definitely worth trying if you are on the north side of Indy.

Let's get into this review! This place is such a gem! I ordered mint chocolate mini cup it was delicious! But there are so many items to choose from that ate fun to eat and look at it! The inside was nice and was giving ice cream vibes! The service, the service, the service wonderful! Very friendly and kind and willing to assist! Wonderful ice cream shop! They also have spoons that are temperature changing, it's the little things that count!

Hyped for a reason! Local or visiting Indy, this should be on your list! We tried the popular donut sandwich with not one, but two flavors - Graham cracker and birthday cake mix. Just didn't disappoint - warm donut and delightful flavors! Strawberry shortcake Sunday was the surprise package! Beautifully layered strawberry ice cream with strawberry shortcake. The flavors were taste worthy! Rated as "Indy's top rated ice cream desert 2023" there's every reason why! Rain or cold, definitely go and try!

Wow this was so good. I had the Oreo milkshake and it was perfect thickness and perfect flavor. The family all loved theirs as well. The staff was great. They seemed to be having fun while working. The restaurant is clean and inviting with a fun feeling inside. They have games to play and purified water to drink as self service. Loved it!

If you're looking for a great dessert spot, this is it. Man, they have some crazy combinations that I was too boring to try (but don't worry, I'll be back!). We ended up stopping by after dinner one night for some ice cream. I got chocolate and mint chocolate chip and it was delicious. The staff was friendly, the space was clean and they have a decent amount of seating. It's right by our house so we'll be checking this out more often!

We all scream for TeeJay's!! Plenty of choices to choose from! Friendly service! And uniquely delicious ways to enjoy your ice cream! Went here for birthday desert and was not disappointed! I cannot believe how fresh and tasty the ice cream was! The mouth feel and the flavors are just to scream for! Please do your tastebuds a favor and swing by you won't let them down! The interior is simple and the vibes it gives off are just right!

I came here for the first time years ago for a Yelp event and loved the giant gingerbread milkshake I had around Christmas time. The cup had sweets adorned around the cup, such as sprinkles, with whipped cream and a gingerbread cookie on top. It had great flavor, the woman who assisted me was wonderful, and I looked forward to returning.I don't live nearby but have come by a handful of times since. Flavors are posted on social media daily, as well as on a hand written paper by the drive thru. Some flavors are made with local Sundae's (located in Geist) ice cream. Outside of my first visit for the event, customer service has been terrible. A young man always opens the window and just stares at you. No greeting or smile or anything to make you feel welcome. If you ask him any questions, he acts very put out, sighs, and comes back with an answer a little later. The shakes no longer have edible decor on the cups and are no longer topped with anything but prices are high for one shake ($8+). I tried to come here with a friend (their first time) over the weekend and customer service was again...not great. I asked what was in the blueberry cobbler shake and upon the young man's return, he told me it was blue raspberry ice cream to make it with. Uhmmm... I asked if they had blueberry ice cream and he just stared at us. I said, "I apologize if that's a weird question." Again, he just stared at us. I asked what the Twinkie milkshake and he sarcastically said, "It's just Twinkie." Maybe a dumb question on my end but I don't care for plain vanilla ice cream so I was curious how it was made. Cake ice cream, icing swirl...? I felt downright unwelcome at this point so I said, "Maybe another time but not today, thank you." and he just closed the window. I never need to come back and my friend said, "I am so glad we didn't spend any money here!" So disappointed because support local, especially mom & pops, is important! But for service like that, I'll go to Steak n Shake for a shake that's a fraction of the price.

Tons of great reviews may be a bit misleading. Walked in on a Saturday night and the place was welcoming enough. Sprinkles wallpaper and people sitting inside playing checkers. Workers were relatively attentive (as much as high schoolers are) and the price isn't too bad either. The whole ambiance seemed thrown together, and the smell of the place did not go unnoticed (it wasn't pleasant). Got two scoops and a brownie sundae. Nothing to write home about but not too shabby either. Bit on the pricey side for what it was., but their specialties seemed more worth it.

Everything is super super sweet but good for an extreme sweet tooth as long as it's not too often lol however I do recommend this business. The service was great and price wasn't too shabby.