Taylor's Bakery

I've always known Taylor's bakery to have great cakes but now I've experienced their donuts! Such a variety of both cake and yeast donuts. Couldn't decide so I got one of both and threw in a cinnamon roll as well. So delicious and great icing to dough ratio. Dangerous to be living so close to such a delicious bakery! Very clean and nice inside.

So all things sweet and good you gotta come here! I've been patronizing Taylor's Bakery ever since my oldest daughter's birthday which was in the late 90's and she's a Halloween baby to boo! So now it has come full circle now I went to pick up my granddaughters birthday cake.. it reminded me the days when I would go to pick up her mom's birthday cake! Their cakes are gorgeous and super moist.. and this was completed in 24 hours you can't beat that! It's a little pricey but it's going to be so worth seeing my granddaughter's face.. service there was great everyone was friendly and we had to take advantage of National Donut Day it was buy 6 get 6 free! I really like the Fishers location but I've been to the Allisonville Road location too! So if you're ever in the need for a quick sweet treat Taylor's Bakery is your place!

Great place for a sweet treat. Every time I am near. I always go. Their cupcakes yummy

2 stars.In a word: disappointing.I was in the mood for a delicious piece of wedding cake, so I popped in a grabbed a cupcake. Then, added on a sugar cookie on a whim.Neither was outstanding. Definitely did not live up to the hype. The cake was moist and had a perfect crumb, but lacked that almond flavor that is expected. The frosting was perfectly smooth and proportional to the cake, but was so sugary it made my teeth ache - literally!The sugar cookie was a nice size and had a good texture. It was right between soft baked and crispy. But lacked flavor. It was really bland. No lemony or vanilla notes were detected. None. It was dough and sugar. Customer service was great.Store was bright with good merchandising. Location is convenient. Parking is ample.I'm deeply saddened to learn that this bakery just doesn't get these two confections correct. But, I'll go back and try something else. I hope I can provide an updated review in the future.

Taylor's is great for donuts on Saturday morning or cake for a big birthday celebration. They have a great variety of fillings for their cakes.

Outstanding bakery products. Highly recommend. Reasonably priced in today's high inflationary market.

They have a pretty large selection of baked goodies and the prices are fair. I only tried donut holes and they were yummy!

I came in after being told by Kroger that a chocolate cake with white icing "isn't a thing." What? lol Taylor's had a huge selection of cakes of all different kinds, including the supposedly nonexistent chocolate cake with white icing. They also have adorable mini birthday cakes you can get to go! I opted for a single layer cake that was decorated with poinsettias. They offered to write a message on the cake for me and took it back and did it right away. My daughter LOVED her cake and we might have had some for breakfast today as well. Definitely worth paying just a little more (seriously, it's not that much more expensive than a grocery store cake!) for such a great product from a local business.

Taylor's is getting sloppy. I noticed it on the rush to service and get me out of the door a few weeks ago, but this may be the last straw for me. Is this a bakery cupcake I bought or did someone bring it from home? Barely frosted- and the frosting is hard

Taylor's Bakery cakes have starred at both our children's graduations, birthdays, and all our other events for over 30 years because they're just that good. This is the only place I will purchase a carrot cake because, perfect! Their éclairs are delicious as well.