Taylor's Bakery

Taylor's has been in our neighborhood for years. The minute you walk in the door, if not a line, you are welcomed and they are ready to take your order. My favorite is angel food cake and iced sugar cookies. Although I would never complain, some of the bakery items are too sweet for me. One good thing is they often have samples out for you to try That way, you can decide for yourself on the sweetness. It is always clean, cases show no finger prints and the waitstaff always looks fresh and ready to serve. Would I go there again? For sure, I will be picking up a candy cane birthday angel food cake next week

Taylor's Bakery is a true staple in Indy, and I've loved this place since I was a child. We typically get our birthday cakes from here because, "It has to be from Taylor's." The cakes are always delicious, and the service is consistently on point and the staff is sooo nice and welcoming.However, I've had a couple of experiences recently that have been a bit frustrating. On the past two occasions I've gone to order a cake, the order has been wrong when I've gone to pick it up. I think the communication between the person taking the order and the pastry chef could be improved, as I know a couple other people who have gone through the same thing. It's a bit of a letdown, especially when you're expecting a 5 minute pick up order that turns into 20 because they have to redo your order the way it should have been.That said, I'm hopeful they can address this issue, because aside from this hiccup, I have no other complaints!

Taylor's is a bakery with history in Indianapolis, no fuss or frills, they have sheet cakes ready to go, and make themselves available for custom orders, morning donuts, cookies- just about everything. Their notorious icing is perfect for any occasion & their customer service is the cherry on top. This is my favorite place to just pop in and grab a sheet cake, or some cookies.

I have had baked goods from Taylor's and they have always been good but today was the first day that I went to their store. A Friday afternoon so there were other customers but it wasn't so busy that I felt rushed. The lady at the counter was friendly and pleasant with me. I ordered donuts and danish and a couple eclairs. This is definitely a solid place to go for baked goods and should be the season for them to have key lime pies. I didn't see them in the case but have had them before and they are delicious.That big flat glazed donut in the back of that pic of treats on the plate was amazing and would be dangerous around any lover of sweets!

A previous bakery canceled my order for a friend's celebration. Well, another friend suggested I reach out to Taylor Bakery, and I am very thankful for the suggestion. Their butter cookies were delicious with icing was enjoyed by all in attendance. The team did an amazing job, and the service was absolutely amazing. I look forward to using Taylor Bakery in the future to enjoy one of the yummy cakes I saw on their website.

Always fresh and delicious you will not be disappointed. The alligator pastries are a personal favorite. Go early before the best items sell out. Great for wedding and special occasion cake.

I have been buying treats from Taylor's for over 15 years. You are greeted as soon as you walk in the door. Even if there's a line, you will get waited on quickly.I find this place very nostalgic. From baked goods to ice cream you can get your sweet tooth taken care of. I always get their seasonal decorated cookies. I do seem to think that the icing recipe has changed. It's not as creamy and soft as it used to be. The last couple of times I've got cookies the icing seemed hard and without as much flavor. Their cakes are delicious! If you want to order a custom cake, you will need to go in and pre-order. They have a lot of photos to choose your desired design.

Taylor's has been one of Indianapolis premier bakeries for decades. When you really wanted to celebrate your birthday in style, a cake from Taylor's was the only cake you wanted. Since it is on the other side of town from me, I had not had the opportunity to go to Taylor's until recently. It is nice to know that some things never change.We were having a Mardi Gras Party for work and I wondered if Taylor's might have a King Cake. I knew they used to have them but was unsure if they still made them for Fat Tuesday. Well not only do they still make them, they are as good, if not better, than I remember. The cake they made was wonderful. The flakey dough with soft filling was tempting and tasty. My office mates were taken with the flavor and tradition of this cake and made sure to devour it in a short time. Thank you Taylor's for making this a party to remember.

It had been awhile since my last order from Taylor's so I was excited to return for a birthday cake for my son. We're big fans of anything almond flavored over here so we had their vanilla cake that has a tinge of almond in the batter. I opted for a smooth round cake so I could add my own decorations at home. The cake and ordering process were both super smooth I cakes in two days before picking it up and preferred over the phone. I fought the urge to buy any donuts or treats while inside. Overall, a tasty and great experience at one of Indy's classics.

Awful!!!! I got a bear claw and Thai thing couldn't be less than a week old. No flavor and dry as a brick. I am sad this was the first time I got to come here. The other pastries we just ok I got a donut, a petite four a bear claw and a fried danish. For 12 dollars... I want my money back but don't wanna drive back there.