Selective Seconds Consignment

Great selection and prices!!! Super friendly staff! Can't ask for more!! Nice stock of items in my size (larger).

I found Selective Seconds from their Facebook Live shows. They have several lives each week and so many fantastic things to show and we all try to claim an item before someone else does. Its a fun way to shop. They are located in Greenwood, Indiana which makes it easy to pick up your purchased item if you don't want it shipped. Their website is https://selectiveseconds.com/pages/about. You can also shop from their website and in store. So many clothing, shoes, housewares, purses, etc. to pick from. You should check them out if you're looking for great buys with a great price.

I really appreciate the consignment business model, mainly from an environmental perspective. A family member recommended I try this biz to resell some of my gently worn clothing. I arrived within their hours of walk in service, but was advised that the buyer went to lunch and it could be around a half hour wait. I had about a half an hour before I needed to leave for another appt, so ok. I mentioned that I had another appointment on the other side of town and the employee said they would get to it as soon as possible. So I browsed around. This store had a nice variety of merchandise, from household decor to shoes, dress clothes, casual wear, jeans, jewelry/accessories and purses. I spotted a pair of Joe's jeans for $19! I have too many jeans in general though, so sadly had to pass them by. In about 10 mins, the attendant I had talked to called me back. I was somewhat surprised that she only accepted three of my items, and I was offered $5 cash or $7 store credit. I wish I would have asked why the other items weren't selected...I buy moderately priced brands like the Loft, Old Navy, Black House White Market, etc. Perhaps they had too many winter items? Anyway, I'll try again next season!

Selective Seconds is one of those consignment stores where, when you walk in, you know you're going to walk out with something. I walked out with four somethings: a denim shirt, a sweater, a workout shirt and a dress. The clothing is well curated and in very good shape. In fact, I would say that most things are new or NWT (new with tags). This isn't a thrift store where you'll be rummaging through bins of faded and misshapen old clothes. These are clothes that are in very good condition. And the price reflects the quality: You'll pay $25 for an Eileen Fisher blouse, but it's Eileen Fisher and probably cost three times as much. Also: I found a lot of Eileen Fisher items here. Also: You will just find women's clothing here. This store has lots of clothing, but also shoes, purses, accessories, and even housewares like mirrors, decorations and knickknacks. The women who work here are also super friendly and helpful, and the whole store just has a warm and welcoming vibe. I will definitely be back when I'm in the Greenwood area.

Nice consignment shop. I've never sold anything, but as far as shopping, prices are compatible with others. Verna and staff are very friendly.

Be forewarned, they only take walk-in for clothing consignments Tues-Thurs 10am-6pm. They are pretty fair in their pricing though.

I've never had any luck selling there, although they have always taken my items. However, I feel as though the return is minimal at best. Probably won't bother doing again.

This is a great thrift store for high-quality women's wear. The only high-end a purse I own is a classic Coach bag that I got for just $35! The plus-size offerings are a little Limited, but the ones they do have our quality pieces. I feel like their trade in offers are fair. They are always forthcoming and explain why they do not take a piece.

Well organized. Clean. Nicely arranged items. Expect to pay a bit more for the items than you might at other second-hand stores.

I went to Selective Seconds on a whim. I am so glad I did! I enjoy looking through their racks of clothing to see what kinds of outfits I can put together for great prices. I have browsed online then gone into the store to find the items to be sure it's what I want. Great experiences so far!