Pots & Pans Pie Co.

If anyone said to me that I would love a sugar cream pie, I would never have expected that. I usually think pies are too unhealthy or what not but had to give this a try on a trip.We really picked the best place to get this by because it was phenomenal! Them a really large variety of pie options. They were available but we were there for that famous to the green pie so had to take that one. Fire was served cold but that was no issue at all. It was perfectly sweet and not too sugary sweet (I didn't usually go for sugary sweet stuff). Creamy and smooth and with a perfectly flaky crust and just overall delicious.It had a creme brulee kind of a topping on top which made it even better. Husband that I open this as soon as we got into the car. Finished it in a matter of minutes and then wanted more. That's how good it was!

Just an update to say it's been such a joy to watch this burliness grow. From veggie-friendly pot pies like broccoli and cheddar to shipping their products on GoldBelly, Pots & Pans has become a community staple. I popped by this week to pick up their Valentines Day mini pie four pack and cherry heart hand pies. Their fridges are stocked with mini and full size take and bake pies as well as their popular chocolate shortbread cookie dough to bake at home. Perfect for housewarming gifts, new parents, etc.

So good! This place has become a holiday tradition for us... It's just not the same without a Pots & Pan pie. Or two. Or three!Amazing people and an incredible dessert experience!We have taken their pies to events and gatherings, only to have the uninitiated tell us within days, that they had traveled to Indy just to get their own pies! They are the best!

I saw a TikTok featuring Pots & Pans, and I figured they would make a perfect stop for our return drive from Cincinnati to Northwest Indiana. Sadly, they didn't have the same pie I'd seen in the video, but we found a few other things on the menu we were interested in trying. The staff were helpful. The space is small, so this is definitely just a carry-out stop.

Honestly, one of the best specialty food places we have in Indianapolis. Homemade pies and pot pies are hard to find and Pots & Pans does it the best with sweet and savory options that change every month. We bring a pie to every single family function we have and always enjoy the flavors we get. Their chicken pot pie is a classic and our favorite for a reason. Their store is a tiny little walk up with take & bake pies available in the freezer and fresh/slices available in a glass case. Only about 2 to 3 people can be inside the store at one time but they're very quick so the wait is never very long.

Pies Pies PiesEvery month they offer a new Pie of the Month. They offer whole and by the slice. We've tried; keylime, apple, chocolate, mixed berry, refrigerator pie, banana cream They are a small local owned company that supports everyone. Please stop in and give them some love.

Pots & Pans is always my go to for a great pie in Indianapolis. I recently tried their Franken Pie - a limited edition special for Pi Day! It was a tasty combination of individual slices of their monthly flavors: Pineapple Passionfruit, Sugar Crème Brûlée, Cashew Coconut Cream, Butterscotch, Apple Crumble, and Blackbottom Frangipane. Trying a variety of flavors I normally wouldn't get to try, I was in awe of the high quality of each. The standout for me was the Pineapple Passionfruit, but each slice had unique qualities and left me wanting more.The pre-ordering online process is very simple or you can buy in store day of from the available flavors. Pro tip, they also have take and bake savory pie options and their Green Chile Pork Pie is incredible.

If you haven't tried pots and pans where have you been? Are you even a local if you haven't tried their amazing, buttery, flakey, flavorful pies??? We definitely spend our dollars here. Need a pot pie but don't have the time to make it? Pots and pans have bake and go pies that feel your stomach with warmth and healing flavors. Our go to is the masala pot pie. Another option is ordering ahead for those seasonal pies that you can bring to your next holiday weekend with family. I'm a classic girly and can't go without my apple crumble pie. But plan ahead because they sell out fast! Definitely worth the try. It's so nice on a Tuesday night when you can't find the motivation to cook anything, just stop by Pots and Pans because at 7pm you can grab a filling meal for dinner.

Came here in search of sugar pie because we were traveling and told that the must haves in Indy were pork tenderloin sandwiches and sugar pie. Pork tenderloins were everywhere we went! The sugar pies not so much!? The sugar pie was OK. My description is a creme Brule cheesecake. Not a ton of flavor yet super sweet. Definitely glad I found it to try and would recommend!Our favorite pie was the lemon cream. Sweet cream topping, tart lemon filling, really good Graham cracker crust!Out favorite ITEM was the oatmeal cream pie! Soft, sweet and delicious!If I were local I'd definitely give the pot pies a try! They sounded amazing!!!

The food is amazing and always fresh. You can buy a slice of your favorite pie or go and try a different one. I highly recommend going there in fact I visit a couple times a month