Butter Pecan Gelato -- now serving gelato at both locations!
Madagascar Dark Chocolate gelato
Grape & Prosciutto - Limited Edition
Spring Pie -- seasonal menu!
Order online at pizzauncommon.com [Pictured: Elote Pizza]
Try one of our Uniquely Crafted Pizzas!
Salted Burrata Pie -- a staff-favorite vegetarian pie
Gluten free Honey Apple Sausage pizza -- also available dairy free and vegan!
Honey Sriracha Bacon Breadsticks, pictured with our sauce options: ranch, garlic butter, marinara, and cheese sauce.
Gluten Free Hot Honey Pepperoni, topped with farm-fresh basil
Vodka Sausage: creamy vodka sauce, homemade sausage, fresh basil, fresh parmesan.
Jalapeno Bacon Breadsticks -- available gluten free, dairy free, and vegan.
Shiitake Mushroom Truffle pie -- a staff-favorite vegetarian pie
Caprese: extra virgin olive oil, fresh mozzarella, fresh tomatoes, sea salt, fresh basil, balsamic glaze.
Big Mac pizza and Thai Chicken pizza!
Nashville Hot Honey Chicken Pizza, topped with pickles! Available gluten free, dairy free, and vegan.
Chicken Lemon Pesto: basil pesto, mozzarella, roasted chicken, spinach, parmesan, fresh lemon.
Sausage Burrata & Pesto: basil pesto, mozzarella, homemade sausage, onion, parmesan, burrata, hot honey.
Hot Pepperoni Pizza! Super delicious has honey on it
Spring Pie - Limited Edition
Menu
Big Mac pizza, complete with pickle slices.
Gelato menu
Cherry Crumble Pie best thing you'll ever put in your mouth
David L.
Mar 3, 2025
The best pizza & gelato in Indiana by a long shot. Everything is made from scratch and the flavor combinations will challenge what you thought pizza and ice cream could be.
Read More
Sruthi K.
Feb 17, 2024
Easily one of the best pizzas I've tried. The sauce for the Shiitake Mushroom Truffle was rich and creamy. They were very generous with the mushrooms. The dough for the pizza and breadsticks was insanely flavorful and soft. I think on the menu it said the dough ferments for 100 hours. The Doritos Taco Sticks has a strong Doritos flavor and the nacho on top of the breadsticks also has hints of the Doritos flavor. All the ingredients felt really fresh. We also tried the gelato and got the dark chocolate flavor. It was very creamy and reminded me of mousse almost. When ordering gelato, the person behind the counter was so sweet and let us try different flavors. Their strawberry honey and salt and oil gelato were different and I would get that next time. One thing to look out for is that seating is limited, so on a weekend you might have to take your food to go. Overall, the ambiance and service was really nice. Would definitely come back to try all the different pizza flavors.
Read More
Jake L.
Nov 28, 2023
The pizza is great! Ordered the hot honey pepperonis pizza. Like the sauce and the over all flavor. The dough tastes great. Pick up was fast and service was friendly. Little bit pricy
Read More
Pardo P.
Mar 15, 2024
I was adventurous and ordered toppings I wouldn't have dreamed of combining on a pizza.... It was absolutely DELICIOUS!!! Sausage, Apple, Arugula with honey drizzle. We tipped over our cherry pizza and the staff was so kind in helping us clean the mess and made a fresh one for us to enjoy. We ate in the restaurant in their small dining room which was clean. All in all a great experience for baby's first outing. Thanks!
Read More
M. Spencer H.
Dec 21, 2022
I've ordered from here at least four times. My preference is for pick up instead of delivery since I had some issues with them leaving pizza out on my porch in the cold and not knocking which was frustrating. The best pizza so far is the Vodka Sausage! The flavors burst across the tongue. The combination of the sausage with the vodka sauce makes it easy to finish the whole pizza in one sitting. My mouth is watering just thinking about it and I had it last night! The Lemon Pepper Bianca was an excellent second pizza to order as it was light and fresh, the kick of the pepper and the tangy lemon were exceptional. I wasn't particularly impressed with the Meat Monster or Chicken Bacon Ranch. They were good, but nothing particularly special about them and I wouldn't order them again for the price. Typically I want something more specialized when I order from here. I wasn't as enthused with the Bacon Apple Sausage but I think it just didn't measure up in comparison to the Vodka Sausage.
Read More
Kecia B.
Jan 14, 2024
Great pizza! Love the different speciality pizzas that I prefer but that you can't find in the Lafayette area. Crust was great as were all of the topping flavors. This is definitely my new go-to pizza place. According to their website, this business helps them help kids so it's pizza for a good cause too!
Read More
TS O.
Aug 7, 2024
Pizza is the best in Tippecanoe county. It's our #1. Where's the beer tho?! I really want a cold beer when I'm eating pizza. I prefer a good Italian lager (Peroni) if I may suggest. Anyway, the only drawback for me. Otherwise pizza is a 5 star, solid.
Read More
Lola W.
Jun 21, 2023
Stumbled upon this gem near the Purdue Campus! We tried the Spicy Hot Honey Pizza and it was an amazing choice! It was honestly SO GOOD!! It had the right amount of sweetness, spice, and just the right amount of crunch. The team in there was extremely helpful and choosing the right busy was hard! Lol
Read More
Menchus Q.
Jun 13, 2024
Unique pizza toppings and sauces, also has a lot of vegan options, crust is very good, the breadsticks and wings are definitely oversalted though.
Read More
Shai K.
Aug 7, 2024
The crust of their pizza is soooo good!I would definitely come back for the cheese sticks and margarita pizza!
Read More