Pizza by the Harbour

Friendly staff and service. As other's have said... "best pizza", although I'd say the bar has been set low for pizza in the area. Years of typical corporate pizza makes Pizza by the Harbour shine extremely bright. If they'd like to do a bit better and be on par with pizza in other areas, they need more sauce. Toppings and taste is great, but their pizza is typically dry. Unfortunately, inconsistency is often the plague of mom and pop shops. Sometimes there's enough sauce and it's fine, other times dry as a bone. Seems like a simple fix, and then they'd deserve five stars.

Best pizza in Noblesville area. Great crusts and tomato sauce. Really like the Italian sausage served.

Such a good spot for pizza!! I was searching for a new local pizza place around me and I was so happy with Pizza by the Harbour! Their pizza is super yummy and has a really nice crust. I prefer them not too thick and we ordered traditional crust, which was still a bit thinner than you would expect from a chain pizza shop. I think my favorite part though are their cheese stuffed breadsticks! I'm a huge fan of anything extra cheesy and love that they have an option that isn't just cheese bread. They also topped the cheese sauce with a single jalapeño and it gave it such a good flavor!

What a shame... One star for the prompt delivery. They quoted 65mins but arrived in 30mins!! Another star for the friendly delivery guy. Unfortunately, the pizzas get nothing. We ordered the Boat-load of veggie and the Island pizza for dinner. After few bites of the "island pizza," we realized that it wasn't what we ordered. If I have to guess, I think what we received was BBQ chicken. That's fine. Mistakes happen. Not a big deal, except when that mistake tastes like cardboard. Their thin crust tasted so dry, stale and old that I thought I mistakenly took a bite of the pizza box with dry BBQ sauce. All that you see in the picture went straight to trash. Boat-load of veggie was embarrassing too. It looked delicious in my eyes but not so much in my mouth. Again, the crust was dry, flat and stale even though this one was "traditional" crust. The veggies were undercooked. It almost tasted like they were steamed under the layer of cheese. Frozen pizza crust tasted better than this... I was really hoping Pizza by the Harbour to be my go-to local pizza joint. Hope they can do better than this next time.

My family loves Pizza by the Harbour! We are never disappointed, have tried numerous specialty options along with the traditional and thin crust and everything is delicious. Highly recommend for your next pizza night!

Food is good Inside has been remodeled recently and looks nice I am always pleased with quality and taste of pizza here. Price is a little high - guess I am spoiled as I am from outta state Make sure you ask what the specials are before placing your order on the phone.We will be back

Stopped in here after church with a small group. There's seats for 6 which is what we had so that was good. We ordered the "boat load of meat" pizza which was absolutely delicious. I also ordered the stuffed breadsticks with ham and bacon inside that were also scrumptious. If you are close or passing through and have an opportunity to eat here I would highly recommend it. Special thanks to Zach for his exceptional service

I went in last week for a chicken and ground beef thin pizza and a side of chicken wings and they were again wonderful. Zach, who took the order and made the food did a great job and the pizza was cooked perfectly. Thanks again.

Always fast, hot and delicious! One of my favorite pizzas. When I visit my son in Chicago, I always have to bring him the Buffalo chicken pizza.

I love your pizza the cheese and pepperoni are so good and the cheese bread Everything is just a little pricey compared to others so we cannot get you all the time The garlic dip is great