Peterson's

A must if you are ever in the area or even within a couple of hours for sure! The owners are really committed to exceptional unreasonable hospitality! I was so amazed I begged for a little tour and found that every staff member i met has been there for 8-20 years!!! (They are celebrating their 25th anniversary this year!) I mean if that doesn't tell you how they treat their staff (especially in today's market) nothing will. The GM is super knowledgeable about both the food and wine. The chefs committed and passionate about food! Definitely the best experience I've had with fine dining in IN hands down! We had the oysters, lobster tempura, prime filet, creamy potato, spinach (wow!), lobster bucatini, grouper special, orange chicken, caymus and finished with banana bread pudding and the creme brûlée (not as easy to execute perfectly as many would claim!). The attention to detail when my after coffee came with a brilliant home made biscotti and then the check presented with a cookie dough truffle was the "ganache" on the cake!Can't wait to return home and do this experience again! Great if you have an event as well they do special wine/ chef dinners and are family friendly! I suggest you give them a try!

Hubs & I celebrated our anniversary here in early Oct '24. We dined at 6:30 on a Monday night, and the restaurant was not that busy. Our server Wendy was a delight. The atmosphere is old school steak house, white linen table cloths. Also for our anniversary, they came around and took a photos, which was then printed for us and came with a card signed by the staff. Cute. (And, it was a great pic!) We ordered: A "three broomsticks" (like an old fashioned) for the hubs, wine was half price so a bottle of brutacao for me (they seal and bag the leftovers to go, as I'm good for about a two glasses), and a crab cake appetizer to share. I had 4 oysters (also half price), I said chef pick so these were west coast. Entrees were the duck breast for me, and the dry aged rib eye with a side of au gratin potatoes for the hubs. Dessert was coffee and also their brownie a la mode, which they comped for our anniversary. Everything really was very delicious. Tender, flavorful, all that you would expect. Dinner came to $248, before gratuity. The wine norally $70, at half price was $35. My duck entree at $35 was very reasonable for a high-end restaurant. Half price oysters were $2 ea, also wonderful. The rib eye was pricey, $90. I thnk she said 20oz. It did not have the flash presentation of a giant bone-in tomahawk, but the concept was the same. It's high end pricing by our standards, but about what we expect for our special occasion meals, and again, everything was absolutely tasty.#yum #ReviewsByRL

Peterson's is one of Indinapolis' hidden gems! My husband and I went for our 5 year Anniversary and from the moment we walked in to the end of the evening we were in awe of the restaurant. The customer service, the personalization, the atmosphere, the attention to detail and the outstanding food! We rate it a 10 out 10! Can't wait to return! Food was delicious!!

A lovely and intimate dining experience. We had steak, crab cake, and crème brûlée, and it was all incredible. The service and attention is just right! Michael was engaging and helpful, but did not press or push. We will be back!

We had such a good time. The food was sooooo good. I had salmon and my fiancée had steak. I would def recommend. It's def on the pricier side, but worth it.

My husband and I celebrated our anniversary at this wonderful place, and we had a fantastic time!This place is absolutely stunning! The soft lighting creates a warm and inviting atmosphere, while the white tableclothed tables add a touch of elegance. Our waiter was simply amazing! He knew all the ins and outs of the menu, from the appetizers and the perfect wine selections. I hate that I can't remember his name, but when we go back, I'll be on the lookout for him This is a grown folks' experience, my friend. They have an age limit to who can dine here. (which I appreciate) I have little ones in my life (grand babies) but sometimes you need that time away from all the babies. (LOVE YALL)For all this, you'll have a 5-star experience for the price of your local family-style restaurant. Highly recommend!!!

10 out of 10! Amazing night celebrating our 13 year anniversary! Peterson's is such an amazing restaurant that provides stellar service, exceptional food selections, private dining vibe with dedicated parking. We had a 6:45p reservation and was greeted with "Happy Anniversary" and immediately seated. We were in a private area that allowed us to enjoy our special night with minimal interruptions. Our service team was attentive, knowledgeable and prompt; with everyone who engaged us saying "Happy Anniversary!"It has been several years since we celebrated an anniversary at Peterson's (primarily due to distance) however they will now be considered one of our primary restaurants for special occasions. Thank you Peterson's...we will see you soon!

My friend and I were taking advantage of Devour once again to try out fine dining establishments in Indianapolis area . Our vote again is Peterson's. A solid 10 across the board. It is truly a wonderful experience in upscale dining. Our waiter Coy was engaging and polished without pretension. The GM Bradley even came by our table to make sure everything was exceptional and it certainly was. Food was perfection. Steaks best we have had anywhere. Desserts topped of an outstanding meal. Go to Peterson's, ask for Coy and you will be assured of a memorable experience..

Ask for coy and enjoy the food ! He will make the night for you . We don't get out much but when we do :)

Great food, excellent service - Coy is the best! Great environment. Will definitely be back.