Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub

Super disappointed here. We saw there was trivia so we decided to give it a shot. We will never go back. We ordered 1 pizza the BBQ chicken with Cilantro and onions on half and add the spice which was $1 more. The receipt 100% shows it was her fault. No half cilantro and onions and add spice were NOT on the receipt and she never asked how our meal was. I then gave up and had only eaten one slice because the onions were everywhere.

Pearl Street has great pizza and a lot of beer/drink choices. Like sitting in the bar for the crowd vs sitting in the dining room with all the families. Always get the pretzels and unique Cesar salad.

Nice selection of beers and cocktails at this local Geist hangout. Cool atmosphere and our service was great. Go there.

My 6 year old is super impressed with this Pearl Street location because the lighting is dim and it's nice and cozy inside. So, if you're looking for a pizza pub that has dim, romantic lighting that isn't too fancy, Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub is your place. Tell them my 6 year old sent you.It was our first visit, and we didn't get the pizza, but we will next time. Instead, we all ordered separate things. My husband and I ordered calzones. Mine included mozzarella, ricotta, pepperoni and basil. My husband's calzone had mushrooms, bell peppers and onions in it, along with the requisite cheese. We really enjoyed our calzones. You could tell that the dough was house-made and the ingredients were very fresh. The calzone was ooey and gooey in all the right places.My kids ordered off the kids menu. One got the mac & cheese, which came with cavatappi pasta -- that curly kind of pasta. He loved it just as much as he loved the lighting in the restaurant. My other kid got the pizza sticks, which are basically four bread sticks stuck together with your choice of toppings. My child's pizza sticks looked more like pan pizza, though, which was great because he loves pan pizza. All kids menu entrees come with a choice of a side (fruit, chips or steamed broccoli) and a drink. And they do serve milk here, in child-sized cups. Pearl Street has a large beer menu. They serve a lot of local beers on tap, and they also have not-so-local beers on tap, as well as cocktails, sangria, bloody marys, wine and more. You will find an adult beverage here to satisfy your adult beverage needs.

Amazing deep dish pizza. My family and I usually order the Mexican pizza and it is always delicious. It can be pretty busy at times, but service is nice when you have to wait. It's a pretty big restaurant with a bar and some games. They have TVs playing sports most of the time. Would definitely recommend, but don't order too much because it can be really filling.

Good food, and good service happy to help with food allergies and get food out fast. Restaurant is a little dated but overall nice. Could use a refresh

I have to give a huge shout out to this location. You were all on fire last night! The service was the best it has ever been, and it is good to start with. What a team you have in place, kudos to that manager, he deserves a raise to make sure he stays. We are return customers and this is our go to place. We love the pizza and pretzels with beer cheese. Tonight we ventured out and had the chicken Parmesan and chicken ranch wrap. I did get the chicken Parmesan without the bread and it was kinda soupy, yet had a good flavor. My hubby likes the wrap but said it had a bit too much ranch/mayo for his liking . Even though they were extremely busy we were taken care of and the atmosphere was calm and enjoyable. Cant say enough good things- keep up the great work team! Hats off to you.

I'm not sure what I expected out of Pearl Street Pizzeria & Pub, a 2-location Central Indiana pizza joint that started in downtown Indy before moving to this Fishers location. I'd long wanted to try Pearl Street, however, neither location is particularly convenient for me and it seemed like every time I was by the Fishers spot it was at a time when it simply wasn't open. I'd decided to take a couple extra days of work during this Thanksgiving weekend and hitting some long desired restaurants was on my agenda for this "staycation." There is an intimacy to Pearl Street that I liked right away, a setting with dimmed lights and decor that says "you can have conversations here." It's interesting because there was rock music playing in the background throughout my time at Pearl Street with televisions overhead playing college football games. It could have felt very busy but never did. There are accessible parking spots adjacent to Pearl Street's strip center location. It's at 104th & Olio in the same strip center at Foxgardin's Family Kitchen spot. The accessibility ramps are ADA. The double-sided doorway into Pearl Street is a little heavy but manageable. This is not a busy strip center, though I'd imagine both Pearl Street and Foxgardin get busy at times. My mid-afternoon arrival was kind of ideal. There were two employees up front, my server Maria, and another who rushed to the door to assist when she saw my wheelchair arriving. She would do the same when I departed. She also ensured she moved a chair away when she showed me to my table. She was conscientious and spot-on with service - helpful but not overwhelming. I was shown the menus. I considered a beer, though opted for my usual unsweetened iced tea. Pearl Street has both a thinner style and pan-style of pizza in sizes that start with 8". They also have a build-your-own option which is usually the direction I go since I'm a boring dude who usually sticks to pepperoni or sausage. I opted for an 8" pan-style pepperoni. It arrived in a timely manner, but not so quick that you wondered about quality. Quality pizza should never be made too quickly. The menu also has a variety of other options mostly in the Italian cuisine arena. There's mostly local brews on tap including some hard to find options. As much as I love supporting local, I'll admit I was most intrigued by an Icelandic brew. Maria's service was also spot-on. She was friendly and helpful without being intrusive. I did enjoy a refill of iced tea. The pizza? Let me first say it was filling. I probably should have stopped at three of the four pieces. I arrived at my next destination with a full gut that said "Okay, maybe I ate too much." I felt like maybe the dough to toppings ratio was a bit high. I tend to think with a deep-dish, pan-style pizza that you should feel the toppings on your lips, or in my case on my goatee, as you're eating and I didn't quite have that experience. Still, this was a very good pizza and I would easily order it again. I would also be tempted to try the thinner crust having spied it at a nearby table.This was a terrific experience. I'm not quite ready to go 5 stars, though I wish I could go 4.5. This was the kind of experience that made me wish I lived closer and could truly get to know this business. As a single guy with a disability who has no family around, I tend to like building relationships with businesses because everyone needs places where they are known. This feels like that kind of place. I'll definitely return and I have no doubt I'll eventually fork over that 5th star. This is definitely one of my favorite pizza spots in Hamilton County and I look forward to my next visit. I tried to add some photos, but my phone is on its death bed and that will have to wait until my next visit. Trust me, this pizza even looks good.

Amazing out atmosphere. Food is very good. Service is excellent really like their barbecue chicken pizza and their Pearl Street salad.

We've been searching for great pizza for a while now. Their thick crust pizza is the best we've ever had! We've recommended them to many people since discovering them a few months ago.