Nyla's Restaurant

What a special place! Nyla's offers a uniquely intimate experience, incredible service, and an outstanding combination of flavors. It sits in a cute little culinary pocket in Westfield, with free parking a short walks distance from the restaurant, valet is also available. I definitely recommend a reservation because it seems to be a favorite of anyone who's ever been, and there are a few bars within the restaurant to visit at while waiting to be seated. We had the pleasure of being attended to by the charismatic bartender and server, and each team member we worked with, as well as returning guests around us, had nothing but positive feedback and suggestions about the menu. Dinner did not disappoint- big bold flavors, great quality ingredients, and overall an amazing experience. This will certainly be somewhere that comes in mind for dinner.

So close to 5 stars!I went here for a date night and I will definitely be returning!The barn style exterior is cute but the inside is cozy and classy with a rustic feel. There are 3 floors with moderate seating. The vibe is perfect for a date or a small group!The servers were friendly and helpful with suggestions. They were quick with everything except the 2nd cocktail I ordered, we had to remind the waiter for it. We had a mule and a margarita from the cocktail list that were amazing! We started with the filet tip's & Gorgonzola fondue for an appetizer which was good! The beef was tender and warm!We ordered the Ribeye and the Meatloaf. The Ribeye was cooked appropriately- medium rare. The meatloaf with a side of the Dijon gravy was delicious! I would order the meatloaf again! We added a side of the Million Dollar Bacon and the Honey & Dijon Brussel sprouts. Both were good but not amazing. Would try a few other items the next time we go.We got a dessert that was not in the menu, the blueberry dread pudding. This was okay. I'll likely try the chocolate cake next time.Overall, a good experience! I will be returning and would recommend this spot.

Even on the rainy weeknight of Wednesday, November 13, 2024, the foot traffic kept coming. Nyla's is situated on a one-way street with free parking just a few steps away.Nyla's is a three-story barn restaurant with an upscale farmhouse feel, which creates a warm ambiance unlike some other fine dining spots. I dined on a wedge salad and the shrimp and zucchini pasta. The pasta was delicious. For the price, the portions were petite and these options are suitable for a slightly hungry diner. My friend devoured his wagyu burger with fries. His eyes lit up when the ample-sized burger was served. It's worth returning, but I will try another menu option next time. Also, credit is due to Nyla's for the prompt and attentive service, so I'll definitely come again.

WOW One of the best restaurant experiences I've had in the area. Everything from the character of the architectural design, to the warm cozy cabin feel on the inside. The food has a savory, ' country comfort food feel. EXCELLENT quality....on par with some homemade meals. We had the meatloaf and Wagyu burger. QUALITY meat ...very tasty gravy ...juicy succulent burger. Sam the Bartender / Mixology specialist freestyled two excellent drinks based off of our ' preferred flavor profiles ...she was GREAT. I'm telling you ....this could be a top 3 Indy Restaurant.

The service was impeccable at Nyla's. We sat at the upstairs bar. Caroline, the bartender and our server, was engaging, interesting and pours a mean martini. She made menu recommendations. The menu is well rounded. We started with the deviled eggs and candied bacon. The bacon is downright addictive. The eggs were fresh and delicious. Dinner comes with mushroom soup or wedge salad. We both had the wedge salad with blue cheese and was refreshing with more delicious bacon. My husband had the Chicken Milanese, which he raved about. The chicken was moist and the caper sauce delightful. The tomato topping on the green beans is delicious. My Sirloin steak was huge with a wonderful buttery sauce. The steak was fairly undercooked for me (rare verses medium rare) so my husband ate most of it. The potato to was huge and a meal in itself. The OG Martini is simple and served in a frosty glass, I love a cold martini. I recommend. The restaurant is in eclectic barn style house. There are two floors and not a lot of tables. Parking has improved greatly with the new parking lot at the end on the street. But don't wear your good heals, as the lot is gravel. Nyla's offers valet parking as well.

Nyla's provides a fine experience from beginning to end. The atmosphere is quiet. Even with a full house, you can still hear the playlist. The service was extremely attentive without being annoying. The food portions were plentiful and it was all delicious. The cocktails were fantastic as well. I would return again for a special occasion

Great restaurant in the heart of Westfield. They have valet parking which I recommend because it can be tough to find a spot in busy nights. They serve steaks, seafood and items that remind you of home. Deviled eggs, meatloaf and fried green tomatoes. We had the fried green tomato app and they were great. Better than grandmas. I had the duck and it was fantastic. Nice wine and drink list. I would love to come back again.

We went last night , it is a cute red barn from the outside. Inside is a rustic but cozy true american feel. Not a big place but compact, warm, bustling yet laid back. We ordered the zucchini fries - really good alt of regular fries! I love the lemon aioli on the side as it is refreshing.I tried their Manhattan drink and it was delicious to me, I tasted the sweet cherry! - i love bourbon with cherry esp maraschino cherry!For our meal, we had sea bass w/ cauliflower risotto and broccolini, my husband had a chicken milanese w/ mashed potatoes and broccolini and wedge salad for all of us! The size portion was generous!! I love how the cauliflower risotto idea instead of regular risotto! For dessert, we went for the apple crumbs . The apple was tart that complimented the crumbs and vanilla icecream drizzled w/ caramel so it was not overwhelmingly sweet. It was a nice way to end our meal.Service was great! All the staffs are all friendly and laid back! We will come back!

It was a dark and stormy night... we visited on a warm rainy evening. They graciously accommodated our request to sit on the covered porch. But there's where the visit went flat - our food was very good but didn't meet the mark when considering the high price point. I had the Chicken Milanese which was prepared traditionally, and was excellent. Always appreciate the difficulty of presenting a thick, juicy chicken breast. However, the mashed 'taters were heavy and skimpy, and my husband's entree was mediocre at best. Our server had a fantastic personality, but perhaps we were "out of sight, out of mind," as there were huge delays in the service. A party of 4 that was sat about 20 minutes after us was served their meal before we received our app. Not sure I'll be back.

The lamb chops had maybe 2oz of meat on them. Service was good but not meaningful. Drinks were just ok.