Noble Roman's Craft Pizza & Pub

I really don't understand what is so hard about making a pizza. The only reason I come back to this place is because their gluten-free crust is the best one among other pizza places. I ordered the "Pizza Margherita," and I asked to add anchovies. I picked up my pizza, and this is what I got. A margarita pizza with no fresh basil, but it had onions. Never in my life has a margarita pizza had onions on it and 0 fresh basil. Not to mention, the anchovies were forgotten AGAIN. I appreciate that they offered to give me a side of them, but this is just beyond ridiculous at this point.

This place is going to be a go to for quick and convenient pizza! Both times I've gone there (one dine in and one carry out) I have been amazed at how fast you get your pizza. They make your order immediately so you get it quick. I had the Bacon the Double Pepperoni pizza, and it was great! I do think it could use some more pepperoni if it's going to have that name. I've also had the Fire in the Hole (spicy) and the Yucatán Sunset. The Yucatán Sunset was definitely the most original that we had. The tiny peppers on top were so unique and not something that I've ever had before, let alone on a pizza!You order right as you come in the door and then find a table. You fill your own drink and get a number for them to bring you your pizza. Lots of room to spread out and there is even a small bar too if you would rather sit there and have a drink. Would be a great location for kids because if you order breadsticks, you get them immediately.

A great chain restaurant, however, it is easy to miss with this specific "hidden" location. Highly recommend due to the great deals they have on family size pizza's and daily deals on drinks and food.

We had the most horrible experience on 6/8/24 when going with our family for dinner. Our grandsons spaghetti came with out meatballs and we were told they were under the sauce, WRONG! None, they did take it and add the meatballs and brought it back but then our son in law found not one hair but two hairs in his pizza so we sent it back after he had ate two pieces but they never brought a replacement, did not apologize and then let us walk out without a word. My wife and us both got sick a few hours later, she threw up and I had stomach pains. Never, EVER! Again! We have noticed a new manager and employees over the past year. We almost never went back after the last time when they were playing loud country gospel music on the loud speakers but gave it one more chance.....Not ever again!

The resurgence of Indiana-based pizza chain Noble Roman's continues with this recent opening of the latest Noble Roman's Craft Pizza & Pub. This time, it's McCordsville that benefits as this location opens up at the end of a strip center in the same parking lot as the still fairly new Meijer just at the Indy/McCordsville city limits. This Noble Roman's follows the same rhythm and decor as other locations within the chain that first started in 1972 but only recently developed the "Craft Pizza & Pub" concept. You can order online and pick up curbside. Additionally, they do have a drive-up window where you can carry-out your orders. While I believe this location only opened in the last day or so, they were already doing a fairly decent business though much of it appeared to be carry-out. The interior appears to be a bit smaller than many Noble Roman's locations, though the set-up lends itself fairly easily to socially distanced dining. Employees were wearing masks. I tried to order online, but the website kept trying to send it through the Carmel location. I finally got frustrated and just went inside. I sat very well distanced from everyone in a corner of the restaurant and actually got in some needed reading time. Unlike the location in Fishers, this one seems to be offering table service if you're dining in. You can definitely tell they're still working out the bugs in their systems, but the employees were friendly, helpful, and I have no doubt those bugs will get worked out. This is a new strip center. It looks to have maybe 3-4 other retail spots with only one other taken - a Verizon store. It has accessible parking and curb cuts. Like Most Noble Roman's locations, there's a two-sided glass door and a narrow aisle (with social distance markings) toward the host/ordering area. There's also a bar area and televisions throughout playing everything from sports to silent films. Also unlike Fishers, I did not have to get my own drink. I also appreciated that. They have both tables and booths - I always appreciate it when I'm offered an option. While logic dictates I prefer a table and stay in my wheelchair, there are days that getting out of the chair is nice. It did not appear they would be having any outdoor dining even when warmer, but that's just a guess based upon the space. That could change. I ordered a fairly standard Noble Roman's order for me - an individual-sized sausage pizza, deep dish. I also ordered garlic bread and my usual unsweetened iced tea. The bill came to about $13 without a tip (Yes, I did tip. Quit rolling your eyes). I find Noble Roman's to be remarkably consistent and I was definitely happy with the meal. I'll no doubt return. I sort of stumbled across this location as I'd headed out to visit a coffee shop that ended up being closed. Driving home, I spotted Noble Roman's and thought pizza sounded amazing. They use King Arthur Brand flour. They have 40 topping options. They offer salads, pasta options, and baked sandwiches. They have a variety of side items. Of course, they do have beer and a craft root beer tap. I was delighted to stumble across this great new addition to the McCordsville restaurant landscape. It's relatively close to my home and probably the closest location to me other than possibly Fishers. So, there's simply no doubt I'll be returning.

One of the few places where you not only can get a salad bar, but there is a self serve drink machine, they have potato salad and cottage cheese on the salad bar, they have Thousand dressing, and they also have drink specials

When I saw Noble Roman's was coming to my McCordsville neighborhood, I was taken back to memories of my grandparents taking my sister and me to NB for delicious breadsticks and cheese dip, and the monster character.The nostalgic memories were enough to motivate me to by some pies for our family pizza night. We ordered breadsticks and spicy cheese, the chicken Alfredo pizza, and the all meat pizza. We ordered medium pies which were $15 and $14 each. We also placed curbside pickup so we were able to pick up our pizza from there drive through with no fuss.The breadsticks were just like I remembered them and the cheese was awesome. I'm pretty sure we only ordered cheese pizza as kids so the pizzas themselves were brand new to me. The Alfredo pizza was pretty good. I felt like I could literally taste that the oven baked chicken was just pulled out the oven. It tasted just like the chicken I would bake myself.The all meat pizza did not look the same as it does on the website. Definitely looks better on the menu and all the toppings on the all meat looked like tiny crumbles which gave me end of the supply vibes. If I ordered again I would opt for the pepperoni and bacon pizza, and I'd hope it looked like the menu represents. I'd ordered again, definitely the breadsticks. Don't know if I'd crave it though. I'm not a beer drinker but they offer a pretty extensive list of options

Clean place and quiet. The guys working were fun and the pizza makers entertained my kids, made them laugh, and were fun to watch. Surprised as I had never been here before. Good value for the money.

I really hope this place stays in business. I like where it's located. The pub is nothing to write home about. I've been there two or three times and the staff doesn't really notice that you're in there at the pub I did a takeout pizza this last time which actually by the time I got home, it was very good. It was a very tasty pizza. We had a white sauce, so I was happy with that, there was a special advertised outside on a sign but when I came inside, I forgot to ask about it so I paid about 25 bucks for a pizza

The food is OK, but you would think with the premium they charge for extra sauces. They can at least fill the cup up more than halfway.