Noble Roman's Craft Pizza & Pub

Love the Sicilian!! First pizza experience as a kid in Indy and loved sharing it with my traveling band parents from South Carolina! Kudos!

Unfortunately I dont have much good to say. The food quality is pretty mediocre at best and its not cheap. $35 + tip got me a very how-hum medium pizza with processed ingredients....along with a salad bar with the same processed ingredients...and an Iced Tea. The Iced Tea was easily the best thing I ordered.I decided to eat my food in their "for here" area which was amusing. Looks like it was originally designed to be some kind of sports bar atmosphere with a full bar and a ton of TV's. Well the bar was empty with no active bartender. Seemed like they were using the bartop as a space to store pizza boxes. Something happened that killed half of their TV sets....they have some kind of deep blue tint on them that makes the picture almost unviewable. The few tv's that worked were showing skateboarding on NFL Sunday. So - uh - I guess they aren't worried about catering to the sports crowd despite that being the obvious intention of the design. Ok then. My advice to mgmt - if you just want to sell mediocre takeout pizza then find a nice hole in the wall location with cheaper rent. If you are going to set up shop in such a premium sit-down place in the center of town then you need to do it right. Get better food - better ambiance - better entertainment. As it is - thumbs down.

This place just gets sadder and sadder every time we come here. Today we stopped by for lunch and just the overall lack of cleanliness is disappointing. The people that work there don't even try to look interested in customers and the manager has the same aura. They've taken the drink off their lunch specials and the kid who took 2/4 orders didn't even bother to ask if they wanted a drink after ringing them up without one, his solution was to just give them cups but they had to buy separately next time. They just don't care anymore from a service perspective. Right restaurant, wrong management at this location. Get someone in that tries.

Well, this was my first time trying them. Wow horrible! Probably the worst-tasting and overvalued pizza and sub I have ever experienced. The reviews are right, just awful and it's obvious the owner doesn't care to fix anything g people have legitimate complaints about.Gave them two stars because their meatballs in the sauce were spicy and good.

I'm very sad to write a poor review for this Noble Romans location. The service was good but that was one of very few things that was good for our visit. Noble Romans was a pizza experience staple in my childhood visits to see relatives in Indiana! My family and I loved Noble Romans! This location unfortunately is not what I remember from my childhood. My wife and I stopped to pick up 12 breadsticks and nacho cheese sauce. We also added 4 Sicilian sliders with pepperoni and marinara dipping sauce which we're on special for 5 bucks. We also got a sprite to drink. The breadsticks were not consistent in quality at all! Some were hard, some chewy, some really slender, some wider and longer, and some overcooked. The taste of the breadsticks is similar to what I remember but not as good. The nacho cheese is also very similar to what I remember and was good. The sliders are good but not worth the money for a little cheese and 1 pepperoni each. No sauce comes on the slider because you dip them in marinara. The biggest disappointment was the salad bar!! I use to love this salad bar as a kid! The salad bar use to have fresh romaine lettuce, shredded thicker cut cheddar cheese, sweet gherkins pickles, and house dressing! I was glad to see the French dressing but I'm not sure this is the same French from my childhood which was good. The salad was iceberg and looks nothing like the picture shown above the salad bar. We didn't order a salad bar because it was upsetting to see the condition of the salad bar. Unfortunately, I don't see a long future with this location of Noble Romans. I liked the open air kitchen and the dough room with glass that is viewable. The pizza makers use to put on a pizza making show for kids to watch through a glass window! I didn't try the pizza at this location but I plan on going to an original Noble Roman's on 10th street in Indy. We won't be visiting this location again unfortunately.

Pizza is okay. We ordered a large specialty pizza but it is still a little on the small side. I thought it was supposed to be 10 pieces but it was only 8. The breadsticks are good as they have always been. We ordered carry out so I cannot speak for a dine in experience. The person who took my phone order was very nice and personable.

I must say that I am not a big fast food eater but when I go out, I do want good food and good service. Hear the service was great, we had a teenage girl that was very personable and accommodating.My issue with Noble Romans is the cost/value for your dollar. We spent $34 plus a $4 tip and all we got was one personal pizza and a 6 inch sub sandwich with potato chips and drinks.Pizza is pizza, so I don't have an issue with that, but my sausage sub sandwich was not good. These aren't sausage meatballs. These are tiny pieces of sausage that they would put on a pizza and there are nowhere near enough of them on a sub sandwich to make it worth the price. It was so underwhelming that we both laughed when it came out.It had been a long time since I've eaten at this restaurant and I probably won't ever again.

The deep dish Sicilian works is the best! Service (Kelsey) and food were both excellent. I only wish their craft root beer came in diet

Always a good experience. Great food. Never had bad service. Get delivery a lot, no problems with the orders. Love doing business with them. As long as they keep she's no sour grape on the menu.

We came at about 8:30 on a Thursday night. There were a few people sitting in the dining room but not many. We ordered our food and waited about 10-15 minutes for the breadsticks. The tasted a little burnt but still good. We got our pizza and wings. pizza was good, wings were decent but burnt. The staff seemed to be all teenagers, running in and out of the store. At around 9 we were the only people in the restaurant. The dining room was a dirty mess. Tables were not cleaned and trash was spilling on to the floor. Meanwhile the staff was talking very loudly instead of during their jobs. And when they did clean, they were eating pizza as they did it. When we were ready to leave, no one was to be found when we needed a box. When the guy finally came to the counter, he looked like he just got done smoking a joint. I was going to give the place only two stars, but they did give us free cookies at the end of the night.