New Bethel Ordinary

Just wanted leave a quick positive review for a great place. I ordered wings and 10 inch pizza. It was ready when I got there, staff was quick and polite. Food was great, I was recommended to this place from someone I trust, so I didn't expect anything less. I was not disappointed. I'm from out of town, but I'm eating here again before I leave! Thanks again for the great food and service.

We went on a Thursday Night, and it was a packed house. Very quickly some put us on the short waitlist.Our server was very friendly and attentive. All of the food was very good. The meat lovers pizza had pepperoni, sausage and bacon. One piece and I was full.The boneless wings had a great tasting breading. The house made sauce was amazing.

FOLLOWUP ON MY REVIEWIt's been a few days since my initial review, and I just wanted to add a few afterthoughts to my experience with the large Meatlovers from New Bethel Ordinary. I have had 1 piece each day since. There are 8 triangle slices on the pizza and each one has been enough to satisfy a decent appetite. I heated the slices with an infrared toaster oven, which heats from the inside out. The pizza was $29, including tax. That comes to about $3.63 per slice. If you think about it, that's not particularly cheap. But I must say, each re-heated pie slice has been very good. I have added a couple of pics to show what the leftover slices look like. I wouldn't get this pizza too often, but it really hits the spot once in a while.

I was present during the incident mentioned in Tony's review, and I want to clarify what really happened. Tony's account is inaccurate and doesn't reflect the situation as it unfolded.Tony, you were upset that your pizza didn't come out as quickly as you wanted, and you chose to take that frustration out on a server who was simply doing her job. The server, a woman half your age, was doing her best under busy circumstances, and your reaction was completely inappropriate. You got in her face, creating a hostile environment not only for her but also for other patrons.What Tony failed to mention is that other customers, including men, stood up to defend the server, showing her respect when you did not. Despite your behavior, these patrons were polite and respectful to you, even though you didn't deserve it.Your aggressive actions disrupted the entire atmosphere for everyone around you. Despite being asked to leave, you were still given the courtesy of having your check comped, yet you continued to behave disrespectfully.It's important for reviews to reflect the truth, and this review doesn't. Those servers work hard to create a positive experience for everyone, and they deserve respect and professionalism in return .

I ordered a pizza for carry out. Service was very excellent, and so was the pizza. Cooked to perfection! Would definitely return again. When they handed me the pizza, I was shocked at how heavy it was. This is a loaded pizza!

I grew up eating here regularly, and let me tell you Ordinary does not miss. Every single time I've eaten here (mostly takeout) has been delicious. This time we dined in on a busy evening. We were promptly seated. The waitress greeted us timely.We had the breadsticks and loaded fries for an appetizer. Both were great. I love the cheese that comes with the breadsticks. We built our own pizza. You HAVE to get the crumble sausage on any pizza you get here. It's the best!!I cannot recommend Ordinary enough!

Seems like I've always have a solid experience when I come...and tonight was no different (first time dropping a review after being on Yelp though) This place always drops some fire (insert fire emoji) My wife and I went on a busy Saturday night. We were quoted 45 minutes for a table...and got a text 2 minutes after checking in that we could be seated.The waitress came and got our drink and food orders quick- there was a mishap with my wife's drink but the waitress quickly corrected it. We hadn't ate all day, so our stomachs were bigger than our appetite. We split a half order of breadsticks, cheese fries, a 12in pizza, and I had a side salad.Breadsticks: crunchy on the outside, soft on the inside. Cheese was a little spicy but delicious.Cheese Fries: can't go wrong here. Plenty of seasoning on the fries, lots of cheese and bacon- could have done with some more ranch but that's my problem for not asking for morePizza: if you are a fan of crumbly sausage, this is the place to go. Some of the best pizza around. Nuf said.Side salad: I couldn't believe my eyes when it came out- it was huge for the price. I ordered Italian with it, but honestly unsure if that was what came out. Whatever it was, it was delicious.A+ service as well: after we left, we forgot our leftovers, and the waitress ran out the restaurant and gave them to us. Never can go wrong with this place.

This place has been a local hotspot for many years. I haven't been here in a few years and thought we would get it tonight. We just ordered a pizza tonight they were busy which is always a good sign for a local place. The girl at the counter was very friendly and asked how my day was. It was very nice. The atmosphere is the same as it has always been. Local, rustic bar. Really comfortable. And the pizza was great! We got pepperoni, sausage and mushrooms. Tons of toppings, a crispy crust and delicious sauce. Great experience.

Second time trying this pizza and have enjoyed it both times. The pizza is chock full of toppings with just the right amount of sauce. So if you like heavy sauce then this may not be the pizza for you. This most recent visit, service was fast and our pizza was ready quicker than the estimated time. Although, it was crowded, our pizza was ready in about 15 minutes and we were initially given a 25 minute wait time. I look forward to trying different items on the menu.

We ordered pizza and wings. The wings were very good. Great flavor and crispy. The pizza toppings and sauce tasted good, but the crust was bad. The crust tasted like thin, pre-made, cardboard like texture.